next previous
Up: Optical photometric monitoring

3. Results

In the following figures only light curves in the R band (in general the best sampled ones) are shown. Pointing periods of the EGRET instrument on board CGRO are indicated by boxes. In some cases the data published in Villata et al. (1997a) relative to the first year monitoring are presented together with the new data in order to better describe the source behaviour. In other cases only the latest data are shown in the light curves to make the plot clearer. In any case, tables contain all observations made by our group in the R, V, and B bands from November 1994, together with indication of the minimum and maximum magnitudes registered and the number of frames taken in each band.

In subsets to the light curve figures an estimate of the measure accuracy is given by plotting the deviation from the mean magnitude difference between two reference stars. These deviations are also shown as error bars on the corresponding points of the light curve. However, lower limits on the error bars are set, taking also into account the brightness difference between the source and the reference stars: the nearer the brightness, the more reliable the error estimate given by the above deviation.

Table 1 (click here) contains the list of our sources, with indication of their name, right ascension, and declination. A brief outline of the observational material in the optical and tex2html_wrap_inline1425 bands available in the literature was already presented in Villata et al. (1997a), so that in this paper we quote the most recent papers only.

 

Source Name RA (2000) Dec. (2000)
0219+428 3C 66A 02 22 39.61 +43 02 07.8
0420-014 PKS 0420-01 04 23 15.80 -01 20 33.1
0422+004 PKS 0422+00 04 24 46.84 +00 36 06.3
0528+134 PKS 0528+134 05 30 56.42 +13 31 55.1
0805-077 PKS 0805-07 08 08 15.54 -07 51 09.9
0827+243 OJ 248 08 30 52.09 +24 10 59.8
0836+710 4C 71.07 08 41 24.37 +70 53 42.2
0851+202 OJ 287 08 54 48.87 +20 06 30.6
0906+430 3C 216 09 09 33.50 +42 53 46.1
1101+384 Mkn 421 11 04 27.31 +38 12 31.8
1156+295 4C 29.45 11 59 31.83 +29 14 43.8
1226+023 3C 273 12 29 06.70 +02 03 08.6
1229-021 4C -02.55 12 32 00.00 -02 24 05.8
1510-089 PKS 1510-08 15 12 50.53 -09 05 59.8
1611+343 DA 406 16 13 41.06 +34 12 47.9
1633+382 4C 38.41 16 35 15.49 +38 08 04.5
1641+399 3C 345 16 42 58.81 +39 48 37.0
1739+522 4C 51.37 17 40 36.98 +52 11 43.4
2230+114 CTA 102 22 32 36.41 +11 43 50.9
2251+158 3C 454.3 22 53 57.75 +16 08 53.6
2254+074 PKS 2254+074 22 57 17.30 +07 43 12.3
2356+196 PKS 2356+196 23 58 45.98 +19 55 18.6
Table 1: List of the monitored blazars

 

3.1. PKS 0420-01

The quasar PKS 0420-01 was detected by EGRET, which revealed a variable tex2html_wrap_inline1425-ray emission (Lin et al. 1996).

All our data on this source in the R, V, and B bands are shown in Table 2; in Fig. 1 (click here) the last-season light curve in the R band is presented. The R magnitudes are calculated by a provisional calibration; we can thus confirm the historical maximum on September 15, 1995 (Villata et al.\ 1997a), when the source reached R=14.15. As for the V and B magnitudes, they are normalized to that of Star A of our reference stellar sequence.

  figure737
Figure 1: Light curve of PKS 0420-01 in the R band

This object continues to show an intense activity: after the fall of tex2html_wrap_inline1559 in 40 days from the historical maximum, the brightness started to increase again up to R=14.98 on December 11, 1995 (tex2html_wrap_inline1563), which means a magnitude variation tex2html_wrap_inline1565 in 48 days, with a steepest increase of tex2html_wrap_inline1567 in 6 days tex2html_wrap_inline1569. After a new drop, the source brightness oscillated around tex2html_wrap_inline1571.

3.2. PKS 0422+00

The light curve in the R band of PKS 0422+00 is plotted in Fig. 2 (click here), showing the results of two observational seasons. The complete list of our data in the R, V, and B bands is given in Table 3. The choice of the photometric sequence for the source magnitude calibration is described in Massaro et al. (1996). Data from the first observational season have been already published in that paper as part of a national collaboration on this source. The new data confirm the pronounced oscillating behaviour of this source, variations in the B band being wider than those in the R band. Massaro et al. (1996) have already shown that the spectral index appears to be related with the source brightness, the spectrum becoming flatter when the flux increases. In order to check this point with the new data added, colour indexes versus R magnitude are shown in Fig. 3 (click here): one can see that B-R clearly decreases with increasing source brightness, even if this tendency is not so evident when looking at the V-R versus R plot.

  figure741
Figure 2: Light curve of PKS 0422+00 in the R band

  figure743
Figure 3: Colour indexes of PKS 0422+00 versus R magnitude

3.3. PKS 0528+134

Because of its faintness, we observed PKS 0528+134 in the R band only; the corresponding last-season light curve is shown in Fig. 4 (click here), whereas the complete set of data is given in Table 4. The source magnitude is normalized to that of our reference Star A.

  figure745
Figure 4: Light curve of PKS 0528+134 in the R band; the box indicates the EGRET pointing period of October 17-31, 1995

Small amplitude oscillations characterize the source luminosity behaviour; only at the end of the observational period we registered a brightness increase of tex2html_wrap_inline1607 in 15 days.

3.4. PKS 0805-07

We made only four observations of PKS 0805-07, in the period around the EGRET pointing of January 2-16, 1996. The data, in the R band, are given in Table 5. Magnitudes are rescaled to that of Star B in our reference star sequence.

3.5. OJ 248 (0827+243)

The noticeable variability of OJ 248 has already been reported in Villata et al. (1997a), where calibration of the photometric sequence was also given; data from the new observational season show an even more intense activity. As can be seen from the light curve in the R band plotted in Fig. 5 (click here) and tabulated in Table 6, the source brightness reached a maximum of R=15.60 on November 18, 1995. As far as we know, this is the highest optical level ever registered for this source. A very steep brightness decrease followed the peak: a variation of tex2html_wrap_inline1621 in about 20 hours was observed as part of a wider decrease of tex2html_wrap_inline1623 in 16 days. Finally, another peak of R=16.25 was reached, with a brightness rise of tex2html_wrap_inline1627 in 19 days and a decrease of tex2html_wrap_inline1629 in 15 days. Two data in the V band and three data in the B band are also given in Table 6.

  figure747
Figure 5: Light curve of OJ 248 in the R band

3.6. 4C 71.07 (0836+710)

The complete set of our data on 0836+710 is given in Table 7. The last-season light curve in the R band is shown in Fig. 6 (click here), where the box indicates the period of EGRET pointing. Magnitude calibration has been performed according to the photometric sequence published in Villata et al. (1997a). Only small amplitude magnitude oscillations were reported in that paper, the average brightness level being tex2html_wrap_inline1641 and the maximum overall variation tex2html_wrap_inline1643. Data from the new observational season reveal a more pronounced variability, as well as the historical brightness maximum (R=16.09) on November 20, 1995.

  figure749
Figure 6: Light curve of 4C 71.07 in the R band; the box shows the EGRET pointing period of April 3-23, 1996

3.7. 3C 216 (0906+430)

The results of our observations are reported in Table 8, where magnitude calibration is based on the photometric sequence published in Villata et al. (1997a). Only four data in the R band were taken in the last observational season, showing no indication of significant variability.

3.8. Mkn 421 (1101+384)

No significant variability of the tex2html_wrap_inline1425-ray flux from Mkn 421 was detected during phases 1 and 2 of EGRET observations (Sreekumar et al. 1996). This source is known to be very active at TeV energies. Gaidos et al. (1996) have recently reported on observations by the Whipple telescope: two dramatic outbursts were detected in May 1996, the flux reaching the highest level ever recorded in the first flare.

All our data in the R, V, and B bands are given in Table 9. Figure 7 (click here) shows the light curve of Mkn 421 in the R band; magnitudes are normalized to that of Star B of our stellar reference sequence. We have four data around middle May (the last four ones), just after the first flare observed by Whipple on May 7, but at the time of the second flare, registered on May 15. We cannot confirm a relevant brightness increase during the second TeV flare, and we can say nothing on the previous period because of lack of data. We notice however that when the second TeV flare was detected, the optical state was relatively high (see also Weekes 1996).

  figure751
Figure 7: Light curve of Mkn 421 in the R band; the box indicates the EGRET pointing period

3.9. 4C 29.45 (1156+295)

This quasar shows rapid variability in the tex2html_wrap_inline1425-ray emission (Sreekumar et al. 1996). Its light curve in the R band is shown in Fig. 8 (click here), where boxes indicate periods of EGRET pointing. The complete set of our data in the R, V, and B bands is given in Table 10; source magnitude calibration was discussed in Villata et al. (1997a).

  figure753
Figure 8: Light curve of 4C 29.45 in the R band; boxes indicate EGRET pointing periods

A great activity characterizes the source luminosity behaviour: when considering the two observational seasons, the maximum magnitude variation is tex2html_wrap_inline1679 and tex2html_wrap_inline1681. By looking at the new data in Fig. 8 (click here) one can see that in December 1995 a brightening of more than a magnitude occurred in 8 days (tex2html_wrap_inline1683, tex2html_wrap_inline1685); after the peak of December 20, a brightness decrease of almost two magnitudes occurred in 39 days (tex2html_wrap_inline1687, tex2html_wrap_inline1689), within a total drop of tex2html_wrap_inline1691 in 73 days. Data taken in the period corresponding to the EGRET pointing of February 20 - March 5, 1996 are also plotted in Fig. 9 (click here). At that time the source was in a low state and moderately active; some colour change was registered too. In particular, a rapid brightening of tex2html_wrap_inline1693 in 3 days was observed at the end of the pointing period.

  figure757
Figure 9: An enlargement of the 4C 29.45 light curve in the R band to show data in the EGRET pointing period of February 20 - March 5, 1996

We notice that very different optical states correspond to the two EGRET pointings shown in Fig. 8 (click here); this should set serious constraints on theoretical models when optical data will be compared to the tex2html_wrap_inline1425 ones.

3.10. 3C 273 (1226+023)

This quasar was detected in a high tex2html_wrap_inline1425-ray state during EGRET phase 3 observations (von Montigny et al. 1996).

The results of our monitoring on 3C 273 in the R, V, and B bands are reported in Table 11; the light curve in the R band is plotted in Fig. 10 (click here). Periods of EGRET pointing are shown by boxes.

  figure759
Figure 10: Light curve of 3C 273 in the R band; boxes indicate EGRET pointing periods

This source did not present relevant magnitude variations. We notice that one of the two reference stars that we chose for the source magnitude calculation (Stars E and G of the Smith et al. (1985) photometric sequence) is probably variable. This can be inferred by looking at the subset of Fig. 10 (click here): there is a decreasing trend in the deviation from the mean magnitude difference between Star E and Star G. By comparison with the other two stars in the Smith et al. (1985) sequence, we verified that the candidate to variable star is Star E.

3.11. 4C-02.55 (1229-021)

We could collect only a few data on 4C-02.55; its light curve in the R band is plotted in Fig. 11 (click here), where boxes indicate EGRET pointing periods. Magnitude calibration was given in Villata et al. (1997a). All our data in the R, V, and B bands are presented in Table 12. No significant brightness variation was found.

  figure761
Figure 11: Light curve of 4C-02.55 in the R band; boxes indicate EGRET pointing periods

3.12. PKS 1510-08

The results of our observations of PKS 1510-08 in the R, V, and B bands are reported in Table 13. The light curve in the R band is shown in Fig. 12 (click here), where magnitude calibration is performed according to Villata et al. (1997a).

  figure763
Figure 12: Light curve of PKS 1510-08 in the R band

While in the first observational season this source did not show noticeable variations, a brightness rise of tex2html_wrap_inline1753 in 13 days was detected at the end of February 1996, with a final increase tex2html_wrap_inline1755 in 24 hours up to the peak of R=15.02 on March 1 (tex2html_wrap_inline1759).

3.13. DA 406 (1611+343)

Table 14 collects our observations of 1611+343 in the R, V, and B bands; the light curve in the R band is plotted in Fig. 13 (click here), where the two boxes show periods of EGRET pointing. The source magnitude calibration was done according to Villata et al. (1997a). No long time scale trend was detected for this source, but a short time scale flickering.

  figure766
Figure 13: Light curve of DA 406 in the R band; boxes show periods of EGRET pointing

3.14. 4C 38.41 (1633+382)

All our observational data on 1633+382 in the R, V, and B bands are given in Table 15. Figure 14 (click here) shows the light curve in the R band; the two boxes indicate EGRET pointing periods. Magnitude calibration was performed by using the photometric sequence presented in Villata et al. (1997a).

  figure768
Figure 14: Light curve of 4C 38.41 in the R band; boxes indicate EGRET pointing periods

In the first season a big flare was detected in the R band, the source reaching a historical maximum (Villata et al. 1997a; see also Bosio et al. 1995; Raiteri et al. 1996) with very steep brightness increase and decrease. A noticeable intranight variability was observed too. No particular feature was noticed during the last observational season probably because of lack of data; the range of magnitude variation was tex2html_wrap_inline1787.

3.15. 3C 345 (1641+399)

The results of our optical monitoring of 3C 345 in the R, V, and B bands are reported in Table 16. Figure 15 (click here) shows the light curve in the R band; two boxes indicate EGRET pointing periods. Stars D and E from the Smith et al. (1985) photometric sequence have been used for the source magnitude calibration.

  figure770
Figure 15: Light curve of 3C 345 in the R band; boxes show periods of EGRET pointing

The most interesting feature in the new data is the brightness increase tex2html_wrap_inline1801 in the last 54 days.

3.16. 4C 51.37 (1739+522)

Our data in the R, V, and B bands are given in Table 17 and the light curve in the R band is shown in Fig. 16 (click here). The source magnitude is normalized to that of Star A in our stellar reference sequence. Only three data belong to the new observational season.

  figure772
Figure 16: Light curve of 4C 51.37 in the R band

3.17. CTA 102 (2230+114)

This quasar was detected as a strong tex2html_wrap_inline1425-ray emitter by EGRET, with a variable photon flux (Lin et al. 1996).

The complete list of our data on CTA 102 is presented in Table 18. The light curve in the R band from June 1995 to January 1996 is plotted in Fig. 17 (click here), where the EGRET pointing period is indicated by the box. The source magnitude is normalized to that of Star B of our stellar reference sequence.

This source did not present big magnitude variations. On November 19, 1995, nine frames were taken in the R band, showing an oscillating behaviour with tex2html_wrap_inline1643.

  figure774
Figure 17: Light curve of CTA 102 in the R band; the box indicates the EGRET pointing period of November 28 - December 14, 1995

3.18. 3C 454.3 (2251+158)

Blazar 3C 454.3 is another example of a strong and variable tex2html_wrap_inline1425-ray source (Lin et al. 1996).

The data of our monitoring of 3C 454.3 in the R, V, and B bands are presented in Table 19; the last-season light curve in the R band is shown in Fig. 18 (click here), where the box indicates the EGRET pointing period.

  figure776
Figure 18: Light curve of 3C 454.3 in the R band; the box indicates the EGRET pointing period of November 28 - December 14, 1995

An interesting feature is that on November 18, 1995 a peak of R = 15.63 was detected, immediately followed by a brightness decrease of tex2html_wrap_inline1843 in 1.7 hours. In the same time, the source brightness in the V band varied by tex2html_wrap_inline1847 only, which is inside the errors. Rapid variations in the R (but not in the V) band were already reported by Villata et al. (1997a).

3.19. PKS 2254+074

The BL Lac PKS 2254+074 was observed in the R band only; the light curve is given in Table 20 and Fig. 19 (click here), where magnitudes are normalized to that of Star D of our reference sequence.

  figure778
Figure 19: Light curve of PKS 2254+074 in the R band

The new data confirm the fast variability already noticed in Villata et al. (1997a). In particular, a brightness decrease of tex2html_wrap_inline1859 in 21 hours is visible on November 18-19, 1995.

3.20. PKS 2356+196

The source PKS 2356+196 was observed in the R band only; data are presented in Table 21 and Fig. 20 (click here), where magnitudes are given with respect to that of Star A in our stellar sequence. The box in Fig. 20 (click here) indicates the period of EGRET pointing.

  figure780
Figure 20: Light curve of PKS 2356+196 in the R band; the box indicates the EGRET pointing period

No significant brightness variation was found.


next previous
Up: Optical photometric monitoring

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)