For large samples of stars, the best method for ,
logg determination
is based on the use of calibrated photometric indices.
For early-type stars the
and Geneva photometric systems
are the most
commonly used. In the
photometric system specific filters measure
the strength of the H
line.
We have determined and logg using calibrations of both
photometric
systems. A non systematic
discrepancy between the the two sets of values will be used as an
additional
information to interpret the spectra.
We adopted the Moon & Dworetsky (1985) [hereafter MD]
and Künzli et al.
(1997)
calibrations for
and Geneva systems respectively.
The homogenized colours are taken from the Hauck & Mermilliod
(1990) Catalogue [hereafter HM]
and are given in Cols. 2 to 5 of Table 2.
In this catalogue the Strömgren indices are erroneous
for HD 225200 (Geneva code = 409010021) and we adopted the
values from the Simbad data base. The indices are missing for
the 2 stars HD 27660 and HD 216931 and we checked that there is no update
in the recent edition by Mermilliod et al. (1997). The reddening
of these stars has
been estimated from the UBV indices: it is negligible for the
first star and E(B-V)=0.06 is derived for the second one.
We also note that the secondary component of the
broad visual double HD 87344, indicated as HD 87344(2) (V=8.0),
in the Hauck and Mermilliod Catalogue is in reality HD 87330 (V=7.13,
B9III-IV).
Its spectrum clearly shows that the star HD 87330 is an SB2 with a well
developed system of double lines at the epoch of our observations
(May 13, 1990 and April 8, 1993).
For the Geneva photometry the version of the Catalogue available at CDS has been used. HD 129791 is not included in this Catalogue.
We recall that as a first step dereddened colours must be computed; for our sample of stars, dereddening is expected to be very low or negligible; a strong reddening is likely to indicate a flux distortion due to spectral peculiarities or undetected binarity.
For these bright stars, mainly belonging to the BSC, standard methods of dereddening are assumed to be valid, these stars being expected to be slightly reddened. We used the programs by Moon (1985) to compute the colour excess. A similar determination cannot be performed from the Geneva photometric indices because no updated procedures are published.
The A-type stars are in the domain where the Balmer lines reach their maximum.
According to Strömgren (1966), the calibration
requires that each star should be assigned to one of the three
groups: early (
depends
mainly on the luminosity, c0 is mainly related to the
),
late (the roles of
and c0 are reversed) or
intermediate (for which a combination of various indices must be used).
In the program UVBYBETA by Moon (1985) the choice of
the group is based on photometric quantities and spectral
classification. Since the
boundaries between the groups overlap in some cases, the assignment
to a group is sometimes ambiguous and uncertainty in group selection cannot
be avoided. In this case, the computations have been made for both groups;
the result is an average difference of 0.02 in the colour excess
E(b-y).
Details concerning this effect can be found in Gerbaldi et al.
(1998a).
The final choice of the group defined in the
UVBYBETA program is given in Col. 6 of Table 2; this choice
is made on the basis of the lower E(b-y) and
by the analysis of the atmospheric parameters derived for both cases
(see next subsection).
The determination of the amount of reddening, being based on the empirical
calibration of the system, is model independent.
However,
the intrinsic colours are slightly different according to different
authors and this may lead to different values of the
colour excess; a discussion
on this effect can be found in Figueras et al. (1991) and in Jordi
et al. (1997).
According to these papers,
for our sample of nearby stars, we can safely use the Moon program UVBYBETA
without any further modification.
The value of E(b-y) is given in Col. 7 of Table 2. Only 6 stars have E(b-y) higher than 0.02; to this we can add the estimated value for HD 216931. The highest value, E(b-y)=0.05, is found only in one case, for HD 151527, which with HD 111786 [E(b-y)=0.00] are the only two stars to present the peculiarity of a (b-y) index very high for stars belonging to the A0 type. These two newly detected binaries are further discussed below. For the three stars HD 7916, HD 114570 and HD 129791 the colour excess is E(b-y)=0.04; for two others HD 67725, HD 104039 the value of the colour excess is E(b-y)=0.03.
For the remaining stars the E(b-y) is what expected, i.e. in the range -0.01, +0.02, with the exception of HD 60629, which has a slightly higher "blueing" E(b-y)=-0.02. These values of reddening and bluing are interpreted as possible sign of abnormality. These stars will be discussed in Sect. 7.
The atmospheric parameters have been derived from
the photometry, using the calibration by Moon & Dworetsky
(1985) (Table 2, Cols. 8 and 9) which has been
tested by recent studies (Napiwotzki et al. 1993; Smalley &
Dworetsky 1993, for stars cooler than A0). The corrections
determined by Castelli (1991) and by Dworetsky & Moon
(1986)
have no influence on our range of parameters.
The internal errors on and logg due to the scatter of the
individual
observed colours have been estimated by Lemke (1989) to be
approximately
100 K and
0.1 dex respectively.
A different approach to the evaluation of these errors is found in
Gerbaldi et al. (1998b),
where it is shown that a difference of 0.015 in colour excess implies a
difference of 200 K in
.
When the value of the colour excess has been found to be negative, no correction
has been applied to the colour indices and logg.
We computed the atmospheric parameters from the Geneva photometric indices by using the recent calibration by Künzli et al. (1997).
This system provides an independent way to determine
and logg since
it does not include any filter centered on a Balmer line.
We limited this computation to undereddened stars, i.e. to those
which, according to
photometry, have a colour excess
E(b-y) in the range
0.01.
The computed
and logg are given in Table 2, Cols. 10
and 11.
The atmospheric parameters derived from the two photometric system are
directly comparable only for stars with E(b-y)=0.0.
In order to have a larger sample, we consider as unreddened the stars with
and, in order to have homogeneous data, the MD parameters
have been recalculated for this comparison without taking into account
the colour excess for stars with E(b-y)=0.01.
Figures 1a and 1b display the results for and
logg respectively;
Fig. 1a does not include the
abnormally low values of
derived from both photometric
systems for the
Boo star HD 111786, which is, in fact, a binary,
as demonstrated by Faraggiana et al. (1997).
We check the consistency of the two sets of and logg
and we look for possible
systematic differences.
The values of
from the
are systematically higher than those from the Geneva photometry.
This difference is not related to the stellar rotation as it appears from the
absence of any
systematic relation between the
and the
value.
Nevertheless, the difference between these two sets of values is small, the
average being 150 K.
The logg comparison shows higher scatter than that of
; the largest difference
refers, to the already cited HD 111786.
The star HD 85504, is an intriguing object with peculiar
spectrum and kinematics (see
the Appendix).
For most of the stars,
logg (MD) is higher than logg (Gen) for large logg values, while
the opposite is true for logg lower than 4. The correction of
logg (MD) proposed by Napiwotzki et al. (1993),
being independent of the logg value,
does not
solve this discrepancy.
A discrepancy between logg values obtained from these two sets of
photometric indices, such as for HD 85504 and HD 111786 can be
interpreted as a sign of difference in their flux distribution compared to
that used for calibration. The H intensity plays an important
role
in the calibration of the Strömgren photometry, so we suggest that
for these two stars,
such a
difference shows that their H
intensity is not coherent with their
continuum character.
Independently of the adopted calibration, it is clear that the A0 dwarf
stars occupy a broad domain of and logg which leads to a
loose correlation with spectral type
and luminosity class appears.
We remind that
the internal accuracy
reached by different MK classifiers is of
0.7 in luminosity class (Jaschek
& Valbousquet 1997); the logg parameter plotted in Fig. 1b,
cannot be
directly related to this luminosity class.
If we exclude the binary HD 111786,
the Boo star HD 31295 (
(MD) = 8763 K) and the
peculiarly
reddened star HD 151527
(
(MD) = 7610 K),
(MD) spans from 9070 K
(HD 21473)
to 10930 K
(HD 87344) and logg (MD), when only A0 V stars are considered, covers
the range from 3.30 (HD 67725) to 4.50 (HD 80950).
Copyright The European Southern Observatory (ESO)