The 53 observed galaxies suspected to have
a "transition'' spectrum are listed in
Table 1 with the various names under which they are
known, and in Table 2 with the published line intensity ratios
,
and
. Table 3 gives their optical positions
measured on the Digitized Sky Survey
(Véron-Cetty & Véron 1996).
Spectroscopic observations were carried out during several observing runs
in May, June and July 1996 and January, March, October and November 1997
with the spectrograph CARELEC
(Lemaître et al. 1989) attached to
the Cassegrain focus of the Observatoire de Haute-Provence (OHP) 1.93 m
telescope. The detector was a pixels,
m
Tektronic CCD. We used a 600 lmm-1 grating resulting in a dispersion
of 66 Åmm-1; the spectral range was
Å in the red (with a Schott GG 435 filter)
and
Å in the blue. In each case, the galaxy
nucleus was centered on the slit.
Usually five columns
of the CCD ( 5
) were extracted.
The slit width was 2
1, corresponding to a projected slit width on
the detector of
m or 1.9 pixel. The slit position angle was not always
the same for the blue and red spectra; as the aperture used
is rectangular (2
1
5
), this may introduce some
inconsistencies when the line emitting regions are extended.
The resolution, as measured on the
night sky emission lines, was
Å FWHM. The spectra were
flux calibrated using the standard stars given in Table 4,
taken from Oke (1974);
Stone (1977);
Oke & Gunn (1983) and
Massey et al. (1988). The journal of observations is given in
Table 5.
Morgan (1958, 1959) has introduced a classification of galaxies based on their nuclear region stellar population. Classes "a'' and "af'' are dominated by early-type stars. The main absorption features are the Balmer lines, which are usually filled up by emission as these objects invariably contain a H II region. Classes "g'', "gk'' and "k'' are dominated by a bulge of old population II stars. Intermediate classes "f'' and "fg'' have, in addition to a population of young stars, a faint bulge of old stars. The old star population have similar spectra in all classes (Bica 1988).
Whenever
necessary, we have added a or
absorption component; as,
usually, the
absorption line is completely filled up by the
emission lines, we assumed its intensity to be 1.8 times the intensity
of the nearby absorption Ca I
6495 line
(Véron-Cetty &
Véron 1986b). Whenever a template and/or absorption component was used
in a fit, this is indicated in Table 6 which contains the line
fitting analysis results for the 53 observed galaxies.
The line fitting analysis of the spectra was done in terms of Gaussian
components as described in
Véron et al. (1980, 1981b,c). The three
emission lines, and [N II]
6548, 6583 (or
and
[O III]
4959, 5007)
were fitted by one or several sets of three Gaussian components;
whenever necessary, two components were added to fit the
[O I]
6300, 6363 lines. The width and redshift of each
component in a set were supposed to be the same. The intensity ratios
of the [N II]
6548, 6583, [O III]
4959, 5007 and
[O I]
6300, 6363 lines were taken to be
equal to 3.00, 2.96 and 3.11, respectively
(Osterbrock 1974). Whenever a fit
resulted in a small negative intensity for a
component, we set the
corresponding
ratio to 10, the mean value for Seyfert 2s.
All line widths given in this paper have been
corrected for the instrumental broadening. The spectra and best
fits are plotted in Fig. 1, the parameters describing the
individual components required by the analysis being given in Table 6.
Mark 938. This galaxy is apparently undergoing a merger as evidenced by
the presence of tidal tails
(Mulchaey et al. 1996;
Mazzarella & Boroson 1993).
The nature of its emission-line spectrum
has been rather controversial.
Afanasjev et al. (1980) classified it as a Seyfert 2,
Osterbrock & Dahari
(1983) claimed that it is not a Seyfert;
Dahari (1985),
Véron-Cetty &
Véron (1986a)
and
Veilleux et al. (1995) called it again a Seyfert 2, while
Mulchaey et al. (1996), observing a weak emission of [O III]5007 and
a strong
over the entire galaxy, suggested that there is no Seyfert activity
in this object, in agreement with
Mazzarella & Boroson (1993) who called it
a H II region. The line ratios published by
Veilleux et al. (1995)
and Vaceli
et al. (1997)
indicate a "transition'' spectrum, the [O III] lines
being weak for a Seyfert 2 galaxy (
= 4). The high resolution
spectroscopic observations of
Busko & Steiner (1990), showing complex emission
line profiles with great differences in width and shape between
and
[N II]
6583 (the measured line widths are
and
for
and [N II]
6583, respectively), suggest
a "composite'' spectrum. To fit our spectra, two components are needed: one
is a H II region with narrow lines (
255
FWHM);
the other is a Seyfert 2 with much broader
lines (
760
FWHM). For this component, we find a very high and
unlikely
ratio (
6.8); however, there is a very strong and broad
absorption line. It is probable that the broad
emission component
intensity is greatly reduced by the presence of a
absorption line
which has not been accounted for.
Mark 957. This galaxy has been identified with the radiosource 5C 3.100
(Antonucci 1985) and a ROSAT X-ray source
(Boller et al. 1998).
Dahari & de Robertis (1988) called it a Seyfert 2. However,
Koski (1978)
and Halpern & Oke (1987) have observed strong Fe II emission lines in
this object; furthermore, the continuum is very flat, extending far into the
blue (Koski 1978), accounting
for the classification of this object as a Narrow Line Seyfert 1 galaxy. This
classification is supported by Boller et al. (1996) who have found a steep
soft X-ray component (photon index ) with a variable
flux (by a factor 1.9 over 18900 s). The
line is very narrow
(FWHM < 685
) (Goodrich 1989); narrow
and [N II] lines are observed
as far as 10
from the nucleus (with
)
(Halpern & Oke 1987), suggesting the presence of an extended H II region. In the
nucleus, the high ionization lines ([O III] and [Ne III]
3869) are
found to be blueshifted by
280
with respect to the low
ionization lines. Although having a relatively low signal-to-noise ratio,
our spectra are quite interesting. In the blue, there is a very narrow
emission line (
) associated with very weak (
0.15) and relatively broad
(
) [O III] lines; the
associated broad
component is
weak (
) and accounts for only 8% of the total
flux.
The [O III] lines are blueshifted by
with respect to
.
The red spectrum is also reasonably fitted with two sets of components; one
is narrow with weak [N II] lines, while the second is broader with
relatively strong [N II] lines. This is in satisfactory agreement with Halpern
& Oke's results, and suggests that the nuclear spectrum is dominated by a
strong H II region superimposed onto a relatively weak Seyfert 2 nucleus.
IRAS 01346 - 0924 was identified by
de Grijp
et al. (1987) with a galaxy they called MCG -02.05.022, which seems to be
erroneous. It was classified a Seyfert 2 by de
Grijp et al. (1992) on the
basis of its emission- line ratios.
We discussed this object in Paper I,
giving it the wrong name (MCG -02.05.022); we suggested,
on the basis of a
blue spectrum, that it was "composite''. The best blue spectrum fit
is obtained with three sets of three Gaussians,
two being typical of a
H II region and the third of a weak Seyfert 2
nebulosity.
![]() |
A weak broad (
)
component may also
be present. The Seyfert 2 cloud is so weak that it is not detected on our
red spectrum.
Mark 1066 is an early-type spiral galaxy
(Afanasjev et al. 1981;
Mazzarella & Boroson 1993). It was classified as a Seyfert 2 by
Afanasjev et al. (1980) and as a Seyfert 1.9 by
Afanasjev et al. (1981) on the basis of
weak broad components in the Balmer lines; the existence of these broad
components has not been confirmed by
Goodrich & Osterbrock (1983) who
concluded, on the basis of the line ratios ( = 4.35,
= 0.88,
= 0.08), that
this object is a Seyfert 2. However,
Osterbrock & Dahari (1983), on the
basis of the same data, called it a "marginal'' Seyfert 2, the
ratio being relatively weak. The spectra
published by Wilson & Nath (1990)
and Veilleux (1991a) show that the
emission lines have a broad blue wing extending up to velocities of
1000
with respect to the line peaks, the [O III] lines being
significantly broader (403
FWHM) than the Balmer lines (280
)
(Veilleux 1991b,c).
De Robertis & Osterbrock (1986) noted a good correlation
between the width of the line at half-peak intensity and the critical
density, suggesting that the narrow line region (NLR) is density stratified;
however, the density
stratification mostly affects the high velocity gas producing the wings of
the line profiles (Veilleux 1991c).
Haniff et al. (1988) have published an
[O III] image suggestive of a double structure with a separation of
0
8, and
the continuum nucleus in between. There are two emission peaks in the
core of the low-ionization lines; these peaks are separated by about 0
5,
the velocity difference between them being
(Veilleux 1991c). High-resolution (0
1) HST images
(Bower et al.
1995)
reveal that the
and [N II] emission comes from a 3
-long
region centered on the nucleus, while the [O III]-emitting gas is concentrated
in a bright "jet-like'' structure extending 1
4 NW of the nucleus.
Long-slit spectroscopy suggests the existence of two kinematically distinct
regions: the first, of low-excitation, lies in the plane of the galaxy and
is normally rotating, while the second, of high-excitation, would be
inclined with respect to the disk.
Bower et al. (1995) suggested that the
high-ionization cloud is a Seyfert 2 (with
) and the
low-ionization cloud is a Liner (
); it seems, however, that
the [O I] lines are weak and that this region could be a H II region instead.
Three sets of lines are needed to fit our spectra; one set originates,
most probably, from a H II region, the two others having line ratios typical
of Seyfert 2 clouds. The velocity difference between the two Seyfert components
is
in the blue and 105
in the red. The complexity
of the line emission regions in this object, revealed by the HST observations,
makes the measured line ratios for each individual component rather
inaccurate. It seems likely that the density-stratified cloud emitting
relatively broad lines is compact and coincides with the nucleus. This is,
therefore, a "composite-spectrum object''.
IRAS 03355 + 0104 has been identified by
de Grijp et al. (1987)
with a galaxy shown to be a Seyfert 2 by
de Grijp et al. (1992) who
have measured = 0.58, a normal value for such an
object; however, Vogel et al. (1993) have found much weaker [N II] lines,
with
= 0.18. Our red spectrum gives
H
, in agreement with
de Grijp et al. (1992), and
= 0.12, so this object
is a Seyfert 2 galaxy. In addition, a weak broad
component
seems to be present, in which case it would be a Seyfert 1.9 galaxy.
IRAS 04210 + 0400 has been identified with a compact blue galaxy with a
faint blue, spiral companion
(Moorwood et al. 1986). It is associated with a
double lobed radio source, 20-30 kpc in size
(Beichman et al. 1985;
Hill et al. 1988).
The galaxy has an apparent spiral structure
(Beichman et al.);
however, these features are dominated by emission lines, and the galaxy
is probably an elliptical (Hill et al. 1988;
Steffen et al. 1996).
We have searched the Hubble Space Telescope archives and found images
obtained with the Wide Field Planetary Camera 2, on January 31, 1995
through medium and broad band filters isolating several emission lines and
a line-free continuum. We retrieved and analysed these unpublished images, the
HST observing log being given in Table 7.
The galaxy was imaged on
the Planetary Camera, a
pixels CCD with a readout noise
of
e-pixel-1. The pixels size is
m,
which corresponds to 0
0455 on the sky; the field is
36
4
36
4 (Trauger et al. 1994;
Holzman et al. 1995).
Both the +[N II] and the [O III] images (after subtraction of the
continuum) show a
very complex structure with a bright unresolved nucleus, a relatively bright
elongated central region extending over
2
4, made of several
distinct clouds, and a thin spiral feature with a total extent of about
15
(Fig. 2).
The Balmer decrement observed
over a 2 2
area centered on the nucleus is relatively
large (
/
= 5.5) (Hill et al. 1988), implying a large extinction
(
mag). We cannot exclude the possibility that the
extinction varies over the emission nebulosity; therefore, the ratio
(
+ [N II])
5007, which is approximately equal
to
5007 as [N II]
6583
1/3
, cannot
be taken as an estimate for the excitation
parameter
. Our entrance aperture (2
1
5
0), with
the slit oriented in the E-W direction, basically includes the central point
source and the bright central nebulosity.
Published nuclear line ratios (Hill et al.) led to the classification of
this object as a Seyfert 2 (Beichman et al. 1985;
Holloway et al. 1996)
although = 0.35, a low value for this class. The core region shows
asymmetric spatial structure with several separate
components in velocity and space; there are systematic shifts between peak
positions for the different lines
(Holloway et al. 1996). Our spectra
basically confirm the line ratios obtained in the nuclear region. This is a
Seyfert 2 galaxy with abnormally weak [N II] emission lines.
IRAS 04507 + 0358 has been identified with an elliptical galaxy
(de Grijp et al. 1987) shown to be a Seyfert 2 by
de Grijp et al. (1992) who,
however, have measured = 0.28, a very low value
for an object of such a class. Our red spectrum gives
= 0.47 with,
perhaps, a weak broad Lorentzian
component. Therefore, this is
not a "composite-spectrum object'', but rather a Seyfert 2 galaxy or perhaps a
Seyfert 1.9, if the broad component is confirmed.
VII Zw 73 has been classified as a
Seyfert 2 galaxy by
de Grijp et al. (1992) on the basis of its emission line
ratios ( = 3.96,
= 0.56);
however, as in the case of Mark 1066, the [O III]
5007 line is rather
weak for a Seyfert 2. Our blue spectrum shows
to be clearly narrower
than the [O III] lines, an indication of the probable
"composite'' nature of this galaxy. To obtain a good fit
to our blue and red spectra, three components are needed. However, two of
these components turned out to have similar velocities and widths, making
the determination of the line ratios rather uncertain. We therefore re-observed
this galaxy with a higher resolution (33 Åmm-1) in the red on
October 29, 1997 and in the blue on October 30. Again three components were
needed to fit the spectra, but this time they were clearly
identified as corresponding to two Seyfert 2 nebulosities and a
H II region.
Mark 622. The line ratios published by
Shuder & Osterbrock (1981) show
that it is a Seyfert 2 galaxy, although the [O I]6300 relative flux is
too low for such a class (
= 0.06). Furthermore,
these authors found that the [O III] lines are much
broader (
) than the
, [N II] and [O II]
lines (
) suggesting the presence of two emission-line
regions of different ionization.
Wilson & Nath (1990) have shown that,
in the nucleus, the [N II] lines are broader than
(
and
respectively); moreover, the [O III] image of this object
is only slightly resolved, while
60% of the
emission comes from
an extended component
(Mulchaey et al. 1996). Our spectra confirm these
results; in fact, two components are needed in order to obtain a good fit:
one is representative of a H II region, the other is typical of a
Seyfert 2 cloud.
3C 198.0. The line ratios in this elliptical radio galaxy
are those of a H II region, as discussed in Paper I. Our measurements are
in agreement with the published values: 6300/
= 0.05
and
= 0.28. This is therefore a really puzzling
object.
KUG 0825 + 248. The published emission-line relative intensities
(Augarde et al. 1994)
are typical of a H II region except for the
[O I] lines, which are too strong
(
= 0.13). On our
red spectrum, we measured
6300
= 0.02. Our values
for
and
are in agreement
with the published values. This object is, therefore, a typical H II region.
IRAS 09111 - 1007 has been identified with the
western component of a galaxy pair
(Murphy et al. 1996). The eastern
component, separated by 40, is called IRAS 09111-1007E, although
it is probably unrelated to the IR source; it has a "transition'' spectrum
with
H
,
= 0.74 and
= 0.07
(Duc et al. 1997). Our
observations suggest that the spectrum of this object is indeed
"composite'', the [O III] lines being broader than
. The
blue spectrum CCD image clearly shows the
line to be double and spatially
resolved. In fact, to obtain a good fit to the
+[N II] and
+[O III]
lines, three components are needed: one with line ratios typical of a
Seyfert 2 cloud, and the two others typical of H II regions.
Zw 238.066. On the basis of the published line
intensity ratios,
Veilleux et al. (1995) have called this object a Liner;
however, the [O I] lines are weak ( = 0.07).
Our observations suggest that it has a "composite'' nature.
The red spectrum image clearly shows the
and [N II] lines to be extended,
with a low relative intensity of the [N II] lines. The blue spectrum shows that
the [O III] lines have a broad blue wing not seen in
. We have therefore
fitted both the red and blue spectra with three sets of lines. The blue
spectrum has a rather poor signal-to-noise ratio which probably explains
why the parameters of the blue and red fits (especially the line widths) are
not in good agreement; however, the differences of profile of the
different lines leave no doubt about the "composite'' nature of this
spectrum. Indeed, the fits show that the emission-line spectrum is dominated
by two H II clouds
separated by
220
; but there is, in addition, a weak Seyfert 2
nebulosity with relatively broad lines (
FWHM).
UGC 5101. This is an ultra-luminous infrared galaxy
(
1012
); it is a peculiar galaxy with
a large ring and a 15 kpc tidal tail extending to the west, which suggests a
merger, although no companions are known to this galaxy. It has a single
bright nucleus (Sanders et al. 1988). Optical spectra have been
published by Sanders et al. who classified it as a Seyfert 1.5 galaxy on the
basis of a relatively broad
line, by
Veilleux et al. (1995)
and Wu et al.
(1998a,b) who called it
a Liner, and by Liu & Kennicutt (1995). However, the published line ratios
(
= 2.9-4.7,
= 1.17-1.35,
= 0.06-0.09) rather indicate a
"transition'' spectrum. Our red slit spectrum (PA = 270
)
shows spatially extended narrow emission lines with a steep velocity gradient
across the nucleus in addition to broader, spatially unresolved lines in
the nucleus itself. We have extracted five columns centered on
the nucleus and analysed separately the five spectra. In each case, we have
found a narrow component (
)
with
0.50 and
0.05, the velocity decreasing
from
250 (West) to -120
(East).
On three spectra, we detected relatively broad (
)
lines, with
> 1 and
< 0.40. In addition, on the
two central spectra, there is a weak, broad (
)
component. It was not possible to perform such a detailed analysis on
the blue spectrum, which has a much lower signal-to-noise ratio due
to a large Balmer decrement (
/
= 8.3;
Sanders et al. 1988).
Nevertheless, we can draw some conclusions: the medium width
component flux, coadded on the three central columns, represents
24% of the total
flux on the same three columns
(excluding the broad
component); assuming that the Balmer
decrement is the same for the narrow and medium width components, and that
the narrow component is a H II region (this component
having
0.50, must have
< 2), we conclude that the
intermediate width lines set must have
> 3.5 and is, therefore, a
Seyfert 2 cloud. So, UGC 5101 has a "composite'' spectrum with a rather strong
starburst component and a Seyfert 1.8 or 1.9 nucleus
(we are not able to decide between 1.8 or 1.9 as, because of the rather
poor signal-to-noise ratio around
, it is not possible to put a significant
upper limit to the broad
component flux).
NGC 2989 is a Sc galaxy (Sandage & Bedke 1994). Published data (Table
2) indicate a "transition'' spectrum;
Phillips et al. (1983) called it a
intermediate object, but
Véron-Cetty & Véron (1984), on the basis of
the same line ratios, classified it as a H II region. Our measured flux
ratios ( = 1.70,
= 0.04 and
) are in good agreement
with Phillips et al. and show that this is indeed a pure H II
region with, perhaps a marginally large
ratio.
CG 49. This galaxy has been shown to have a Seyfert 2 spectrum
by Salzer et al. (1995); however, they have measured a low relative
intensity for the [N II] lines ( = 0.30) as the redshifted wavelength
of [N II]
is 6873 Å and falls on the atmospheric B band.
After correction for this absorption, our spectrum gives
= 0.80,
a normal value for a Seyfert 2 galaxy.
NGC 3185 is a SBa galaxy (Sandage & Bedke 1994). Its
emission-line spectrum is power-law photoionized
according to Stauffer (1982).
Ho et al. (1997a) called it a Seyfert 2,
although the published line ratios indicate a "transition'' spectrum.
We have fitted the lines with two sets of Gaussian profiles:
one system is a H II region; the other corresponds to a Seyfert nebulosity,
although the [O I] lines are quite weak ( = 0.04).
Arp 107A is the SW component of an interacting galaxy pair
(Arp 1966).
It exhibits Seyfert 2 activity and its spectrum shows very strong [N II]
lines ( = 3.0) according to
Keel et al. (1985). Our spectrum shows a
more normal value.
In fact, the lines have a complex profile which can best be fitted by
two sets of Gaussians having different widths, but similar
ratios,
namely 1.41 and 1.23.
NGC 3504. This Sb galaxy
(Sandage & Bedke 1994) has a "composite''
nucleus showing both non-thermal activity and recent star formation, the
optical spectrum being dominated by the regions of stellar activity
(Keel 1984).
Ho et al. (1993a), who published line ratios for this object,
suggested that it could be a "transition'' between a H II region and a Liner,
but Ho et al. (1997a) called it a H II region. Fitting our red spectrum
with a single set of Gaussians does not give a satisfactory fit and indicates
the presence of weak broad wings in the [N II] lines; two sets of Gaussians
are needed, revealing the presence of a weak Seyfert-like nebulosity with
= 1.87. The blue spectrum was also fitted by two sets of Gaussians
satisfying, respectively,
= 0.1 and
= 10. The NGC 3504
spectrum is therefore "composite'' and dominated by a starburst; a weak Seyfert
feature is also present. No component showing Liner characteristics was
detected in this object.
IRAS 11058 - 1131. In Paper I we concluded, on the basis of a red
spectrum, that this object, classified as a Seyfert 2 by various authors
(de Grijp et al. 1992;
Osterbrock & de Robertis 1985), has
weak [N II] lines. Re-analyzing the red spectrum, we have found
the possible presence of a weak broad
(
)
component with 24% of the total
flux. Our blue
spectrum confirms that this is indeed an AGN with
/
and
a relatively strong He II
4686 line (
= 0.18).
Our conclusion is that IRAS 11058-1131 belongs to the relatively rare
class of Seyfert 2 galaxies having weak [N II] lines, discussed in
Sect. 4.3;
other galaxies belonging to this class are UM 85 and 3C 184.1 (Paper I).
NGC 3642 is an Sb galaxy
(Sandage & Bedke 1994). It was classified as a
Liner by Heckman (1980).
Filippenko & Sargent (1985) noted the presence
of very narrow emission lines (
) superposed on weak,
significantly broader components; a weak broad
component was also
detected.
Koratkar et al. (1995) confirmed the presence of the broad
component and called this object a Liner, although their published line ratios
rather point to a "transition'' spectrum. Our spectra confirm the
presence of a broad
component (
) and show, in
addition, that the narrow line spectrum is made of two clouds, one with
line ratios typical of a H II region and the other of a Seyfert 2 cloud, this
object being, therefore, a "composite''.
Mark 1291. Spectroscopic observations of this barred
spiral by Kollatschny et al. (1983) show it to be a "transition object''
between Seyfert 2s and H II regions; however, high excitation lines
characteristic of Seyfert 2s such as [Fe XIV]5303
and [Fe X]
6374 are detected. The nuclear emission
is compact (González Delgado et al. 1997).
Our optical spectra show a weak broad (
)
component
suspected by Kollatschny et al. The narrow lines are well fitted with a
single Gaussian profile (
FWHM). The line ratios are
= 3.84,
= 0.04 and
6583/
= 0.73
(significantly larger than the published value, 0.48); the classification
of this object is therefore ambiguous: it is a Seyfert 2 in the the
vs.
diagram and a H II region in the
vs.
diagram. It would be of interest to obtain high-resolution, high
signal-to-noise spectra of this object to confirm its "transition'' nature.
IRAS 11285 + 8240 A has been classified as a Seyfert 2 galaxy
by Klaas & Elsasser (1991), with = 8.25 and
= 0.46. Our
red spectrum is well fitted by a single set of components with
= 0.45,
in excellent agreement with the published value, and
/
. This is
another example of Seyfert 2 galaxy with marginally weak [N II] lines.
Mark 739 has a double nucleus
(Petrosian et al. 1978).
The eastern nucleus has a Seyfert 1 spectrum
(Petrosian et al. 1979;
Netzer et al. 1987). The western component, Mark 739W, has a starburst
spectrum according to Netzer et al.; however,
Rafanelli et al. (1993)
have remarked that is unresolved with a resolution of 130
,
while the [O III] lines are significantly broader
(
FWHM). Our observations show that this spectrum is
indeed "composite'' with a Seyfert 2 nucleus and a H II region and, in
addition, a weak broad
component.
SBS 1136 + 594 is a Seyfert 1.5 galaxy
(Markarian et al.
1983;
Martel & Osterbrock 1994). The narrow-line spectrum, however, has
very weak [N II] lines (
= 0.25; Martel & Osterbrock);
this is confirmed by our spectra, with even weaker
[N II] lines (
/
). This object belongs to the class of AGNs
with very weak [N II] lines discussed in Sect. 4.3.
The individual components used to fit the red spectrum of this
object are plotted in Fig. 1.
NGC 4102 is a Sb galaxy
(Sandage & Bedke 1994).
For Ho et al.
(1997a) it is a H II region, although its UV spectrum does not resemble that
of a starburst galaxy (Kinney et al. 1993). The spectrum published by
Ho et al. (1995) rather indicates a "transition object''. Our blue spectrum shows
a line obviously narrower than the [O III] lines, indicating that the
spectrum is "composite''. The blue spectrum was fitted with two sets of three
Gaussians. The broadest
profile in the fit contains 7% of
the total
flux. The red spectrum having a very high signal-to-noise
ratio, we needed three sets of three Gaussians to get a good fit;
we forced one set to have the same width as the broadest
set in the blue fit. The fitting analysis gives two strong narrow
components and a weak broad one, containing
5% of the total
flux and having
= 1.57.
There was no need to use two narrow components to fit
the
line, as the spectrum was taken under poor transparency conditions
and its signal-to-noise ratio is much lower. Our conclusion is that the nucleus
of NGC 4102 is dominated by a starburst, but that a weak Seyfert 2 component
is present and detected mainly by the broadening of the [O III] lines.
IRAS 12474 + 4345 S. For
de Grijp et al. (1992), this object is a
H II region; however, the published line ratio (2.93) is slightly
high for the corresponding
ratio (0.42). Fitting our spectra with
a single set of lines gives an unsatisfactory result, while the solution
with two sets of lines is acceptable, with small residuals. One set of
lines corresponds to a H II region, while the other has
= 4.43,
= 0.03 and
= 0.40; these values are intermediate between
those corresponding to H II regions and Seyfert 2 nebulosities. Moreover,
the He II
4686 line is detected with
= 0.17, if all the
He II flux is attributed to the "transition'' component. We are unable
to conclude concerning the nature of this second component.
UGC 8621 is a Seyfert 1.8 galaxy according to
Osterbrock & Martel (1993).
Our blue spectrum shows the line to be much narrower
(< 80
) than the [O III] lines (
665
),
but no evidence of a broad component. To account for the different
widths observed, we fitted the blue spectrum with two sets of lines; for
the narrow component, we found
= 0.28, while we have
forced the broader component to have
= 10. We fitted the red
spectrum with two sets of three Gaussians, imposing
to one of them to have the same width as the broader [O III] component; an
additional Gaussian was added to fit the broad
wings.
We find no trace of [O I] emission
(
0.01) for the narrow component and
< 0.3 for the
Seyfert cloud. This is a "composite object'', with a relatively strong H II
region and a weak Seyfert 1.9 nebulosity.
Mark 266 is a merging system with
two nuclei separated by 10
(Hutchings & Neff 1988;
Wang et al. 1997).
It is a Luminous Infrared Galaxy (LIG), i.e.,
1011.2
1012
(Goldader et al. 1997).
Line intensity ratios in the two nuclei have been measured by
Osterbrock &
Dahari (1983);
Veilleux & Osterbrock (1987);
Mazzarella & Boroson (1993);
Osterbrock & Martel (1993)
and Kim et al. (1995); all these measurements
are in good agreement, if we make the assumption that Kim et al. have
inverted the NE and SW components. On the basis of these line ratios,
Mark 266SW has been classified as a Seyfert 2 by Mazzarella & Boroson,
Kim et al. and Wu et al. (1998b), and as a "marginal'' Seyfert 2 by
Osterbrock & Dahari, while Mark 266NE has been called a Liner by
Mazzarella & Boroson, Kim et al. and Wu et al., and a
"narrow emission-line galaxy'' (NELG) by Osterbrock & Dahari and
Veilleux & Osterbrock. NELGs, for
these authors, are emission-line galaxies that may be either Liners or
H II regions. For Mark 266NE, we have only a blue spectrum which, by simple
visual inspection, shows quite different
and [O III] line profiles. Our
line profile analysis reveals two clouds, one with narrow lines
(
) and
= 0.96, the other with broader lines (
) and
= 2.2 and containing 37% of the total
flux. The published
value of the intensity ratio
is 0.15. If the narrow component is
associated with a H II region, it contributes in a small amount to the
observed [O I]
6300 flux and therefore the
ratio for the broader
component is likely to be significantly larger than 0.12, which means that this
component could be a Liner. We have fitted the blue spectrum of Mark 266SW
with three sets of Gaussians: one of them corresponds, most probably, to a
H II region with narrow lines (295
FWHM) and
= 0.36;
the two other sets have widths of 200 and 600
and
= 3.7
and 13.3, respectively. We also fitted the red spectrum with three sets
of Gaussians,
forcing, in addition, one of the sets to have a width of 600
. The result
is a set of narrow lines with
= 0.58 corresponding to the
narrow blue lines, confirming that this system is indeed coming from a
H II region. The set having the broadest lines has intensity ratios typical
of a Seyfert cloud. The third set, with
= 3.65 and
= 0.58, has
still an intermediate spectrum.
Mark 1361 was called a Seyfert 2 galaxy by
Kim et al. (1995). Our
analysis of a red spectrum (Paper I) lead to the conclusion that it is a
"composite object''. Our blue spectrum confirms this result. Three sets of
three components were needed to get a good fit.
In one set we had to impose
= 10, in another
= 0.1. The best fit resulted in a narrow set
of lines with very weak [O III] lines and two sets of lines with
strong [O III] contribution. We then re-analyzed the red spectrum using three
sets of three lines; we had to add a weak broad
component
(
, with
10% of the total
flux) in
order to obtain a good fit. For the
narrowest set of three lines, we found
= 0.54, for the other two,
0.66 and 1.04 respectively. The conclusion is that Mark 1361 has a
"composite'' spectrum with a H II cloud contributing half of the
line and a Seyfert 2
nebulosity with complex line profiles (two Gaussians were needed for the fit).
If the presence of the broad
component is confirmed, this object could be
a Seyfert 1.9 galaxy.
Mark 461 is a Seyfert 2 galaxy according to
Huchra & Burg (1992);
however,
Cruz-González et al. (1994)
have measured = 1.13. The emission
is concentrated in the nuclear region
(González Delgado et al. 1997).
No other line ratios have been published for this object. The
and
[O III] lines obviously do not have the same profile. To get
a good fit, two sets of lines were necessary. The object is "composite'', one
component being a H II region and the other probably a Seyfert 2 nucleus.
4C 26.42. This object has been identified with a cD galaxy,
MCG 05.33.005 (Carswell & Wills 1967;
Olsen 1970;
Merkelijn 1972), the
brightest member of
Abell 1975
(Parma et al. 1986;
Pilkington 1964); it is
a FR I, Z-shaped radiosource
(van Breugel et al. 1984;
Ge & Owen 1993).
Emission lines have been detected in the nuclear region, with = 0.4,
= 0.8 and
= 0.2
(Anton 1993). These
values are similar to the ones usually observed in Liners, but for
the low [O III]
5007 line intensity. Examination of
the red spectrum shows that the lines are obviously double. Fitting the lines
with two sets of components revealed two clouds with a velocity difference of
330
. Their line ratios are very similar and typical of Liners
with exceptionally weak [O III] lines.
I Zw 81.
Koski (1978) observed narrow (
)
emission lines in this galaxy, with
5007/
= 3.14,
6583/
= 0.67 and
= 0.07; the
narrowness of the emission lines and
the relative weakness of the [O III] lines led him to
conclude that this is not a Seyfert galaxy, but rather a "transition''
case between a H II galaxy and a Seyfert 2.
Shuder & Osterbrock (1981)
and Veilleux & Osterbrock (1987) called it a narrow-line Seyfert.
Our red spectrum shows the lines to be double with a separation of 220
. Fitting both the red and blue spectra with two sets of three Gaussians,
we found
= 2.05 (1.41) and
= 0.78 (0.56) for the high (low)
velocity clouds. In both cases, the [O I] lines are undetected with
< 0.04. The two clouds are most probably H II regions.
Mark 477. This object was discussed in Paper I, where we concluded from
the published data and the analysis of a red spectrum that its nature
was unclear. Heckman et al. (1997) have argued that the observed UV through
near-IR continuum in the nucleus of Mark 477 is dominated by light from a
starburst. The narrow Balmer emission lines would then be excited by ionizing
radiation from both the hidden Seyfert 1 nucleus and from the hot stars in
the starburst. We have re-analyzed our old red spectrum together with our new
blue spectrum. Three sets of components were needed to fit these very high
signal-to-noise data. The three line-systems are typical of Seyfert 2s,
although two have relatively weak [N II] intensities, with
6583/
= 0.31 and 0.38, respectively. We found
no evidence for the presence of broad Balmer components.
Mark 848S is a LIG
(Goldader et al. 1997) belonging to a pair of
interacting galaxies (Armus et al. 1990). The northern galaxy is a H II
region (Wu et al. 1998a,b); the southern component has been called a
Liner (Mazzarella & Boroson 1993;
Veilleux et al. 1995), though its
line ratios
(Kim et al. 1995) are ambiguous, the [O I]6300 line being
rather weak for a Liner. The line profile analysis of our spectra shows it
to be a "composite object'' with two distinct emission-line clouds: a narrow
one (
, with
= 0.83,
= 0.43 and
= 0.03), identified with a H II region, and a somewhat broader one
(
), with line ratios typical of a Seyfert 2
(
= 4.20,
6583/
= 0.71 and
= 0.14).
IRAS 15184 + 0834.
De Grijp et al. (1992) called this object a
Seyfert 2; however they found relatively weak [N II] lines ( = 0.42).
Our spectra show that the [N II] lines are significantly stronger than the
published values. A reasonable fit is obtained with two sets of components:
one is a H II region; the other could be a Seyfert 2, although the [O I]
lines are relatively weak.
NGC 5953 is a peculiar S0
(Rampazzo et al. 1995) or Sa
(González Delgado & Pérez 1996) galaxy interacting with NGC 5954
(Arp 1966). It
has a Seyfert 2 nucleus (Rafanelli et al. 1990;
González Delgado & Pérez)
surrounded by a ring of star formation with a radius of 4
(González Delgado & Pérez). Rafanelli et al. and González
Delgado & Pérez
studied this object using a slit width of 2
0 and 1
5 respectively.
The seeing was
1
during González Delgado & Pérez' observations, while
it was not specified by Rafanelli et al. who, however, easily separated
the galaxy nucleus from a star located 3
away.
We may reasonably assume that, in both cases, the nuclear spectrum
corresponds to a 2
0
2
0, or smaller, aperture.
The line ratios given by these authors (see Table 2) are
typical of a
Seyfert 2 region, although [O I]
6300 may be somewhat weak for
this type of objects; but as stressed before, we cannot exclude some
contamination by the circumstellar emission region.
Both Keel et al. (1985)
and Kim et al. (1995) have observed the NGC 5953
nuclear region with a relatively large aperture: Keel et al. used a
= 4
7 circular aperture, while Kim et al. used a long
2
14
slit. It is clear
that these two large aperture spectra must contain a significant
contribution from the circumstellar emission region and, indeed, the
published line intensity ratios are those of "transition'' spectra.
We used a 2
1 slit and the seeing was 2
6; we extracted
7 columns, i.e., 7
6, so some
contamination from the circumstellar emission region was expected.
Effectively, by doing the line profile fitting analysis, we were able to
identify two components of different line widths and strengths, one of
which can be associated with a H II region
(
= 0.55,
/
,
= 0.03 and
); the
other component, broader (
), reveals the
presence of a Seyfert 2 nebulosity, the measured line intensities being:
= 1.96 and
= 0.18, with
fixed to 10.
Lines of [Fe III]
4659 and [Fe VII]
5158 are clearly visible in
the blue spectrum. A very weak broad
line is possibly detected,
which would qualify NGC 5953 as a Seyfert 1.9 galaxy.
Kaz 49 has been classified as a Seyfert 1 by
Yegiazarian & Khachikian (1988), as a Seyfert 1.9 by
Moran et al. (1994), who have detected a weak broad
component (
), and as a H II region by
Boller et al. (1994). The latter classification was based on measured line
ratios
(
= 2.58,
= 0.56,
= 0.025) that rather point to a
"transition'' spectrum. The line profile analysis of our spectra shows a
strong H II region (
= 2.21,
= 0.05,
= 0.55) and a
weak Seyfert 2 component for which we have fixed
= 10. There is no
evidence for the presence of a broad
component; however, the blended
weak
and [N II] components, each having a
may be
easily mistaken for a broad
line.
IRAS 16129 - 0753 has been classified as a possible Liner by
de Grijp et al. (1992) on the basis of the measured line intensity
ratios
( = 2.03,
/
),
although [O I]
6300 was very weak.
The line fitting analysis of our blue spectrum shows this object to be
"composite''. The red spectrum, which has a relatively low signal-to-noise
ratio, is well fitted by a single set of lines corresponding to the H II
region; the Seyfert component is undetected.
IRAS 16382 - 0613 has been called a Seyfert 2 by
Aguero et al. (1995) and a possible Seyfert 2 by
de Grijp et al. (1992);
however, the
[O I]6300 line is marginally weak for a Seyfert 2, with
=
0.09 (Aguero et al.). The line profiles on the blue spectrum are obviously
complex. Fitting these lines with two sets of Gaussians reveals a narrow
component (
) with
= 3.94, and a broader
component (
) with
= 4.06. The red spectrum
fit gives a solution compatible with the blue solution plus a broad Balmer
line (
). The two components have strong [N II] lines,
but the [O I] lines are weak. For the broadest set of lines, we find
< 0.12, compatible with a Seyfert 2 nebulosity; however, the narrow
component has
< 0.03 and seems therefore to have a genuine
"transition'' spectrum.
Mark 700 was called a Seyfert 1 galaxy by
Denisyuk et al. (1976), who
found a broad component. For Koski (1978), it is a weak-lined Seyfert
galaxy with Balmer absorption lines, very similar to "normal''
emission-line galaxies.
Ferland & Netzer (1983) included it in a
Liner list, on the basis of the intensity ratios published by Koski.
Our observations show that this object is, indeed, a Liner; the
broad
component seen by Denisyuk et al. is confirmed.
MCG 03.45.003. The [N II] lines measured by
de Grijp et al. (1992) are
rather weak for a Seyfert 2 galaxy ( = 0.42) and, on the basis of a red
spectrum, we concluded in Paper I that this object could have a "composite''
spectrum. Our analysis of both the blue and red spectra show
that two kinematically distinct clouds are present in this object,
both of them having Seyfert 2 characteristics.
PGC 61548. The red spectrum is "composite'' and confirms the
result presented in Paper I. The line profile analysis reveals the presence
of both a H II region (5007/
= 0.41,
6583/
= 0.50,
6300/
= 0.04,
)
and a Seyfert 2 nebulosity (
fixed to 10.0,
3.9,
0.5 and
).
Kaz 214 is a Seyfert 2 galaxy for
de Grijp et al. (1992), with
= 5.23 and
= 0.39; however, the [N II] lines are weak for
a Seyfert 2. On our red exposure, the slit position angle was PA = 139
.
By simple visual inspection of the CCD image, we see that the lines are double:
in one of the line-systems the lines are spatially extended and narrow,
with relatively weak [N II]; in the other, the lines are spatially unresolved,
but relatively broad, and [N II] is stronger. The spectrum is obviously
"composite'' with a H II region and a Seyfert component. However, when analysing
the spectrum obtained by extracting three columns centered on the nucleus,
we were unable to get a satisfactory fit confirming the visual impression.
We then extracted individually seven columns (numbered 1 to 7, from SE to NW)
containing obvious emission lines; the continuum was brightest in
Cols.
4 and 5. Columns 1, 2 and 7 were fitted with a single set of lines, while for
Cols. 3 to 6, two sets of lines were necessary. We have made the assumption
that the Seyfert component is really spatially unresolved and, consequently,
forced the redshift, width and the
ratio of this component to be the
same on all columns (that is, 120
, 525
FWHM and 0.60,
respectively), the
only free parameter being the
intensity. In addition to this Seyfert
component, we have found, on all columns, a narrow component with relatively
weak [N II] lines; the velocity of this narrow component increases from
-25
to 140
from Cols. 1 to 7. The blue spectrum was taken with
the slit oriented N-S. As the seeing was rather poor, seven columns were
added together when extracting the spectrum. The best fit was obtained with
three sets of lines: for one of them, we forced
= 10
(this turns to be
the broadest component); the two other sets have narrow lines, with moderate
ratios. We therefore conclude that Kaz 214 has a "composite''
spectrum.
But this example shows that it may not be possible to show that
a "transition'' spectrum is a "composite'' spectrum when
the spatial resolution is insufficient,
this being due to the large velocity dispersion gradient sometimes present
in the nuclear region which broadens the lines.
NGC 6764 has been called a Seyfert 2 galaxy by
Rubin et al. (1975),
in spite of being stronger than [O III]
5007; this classification
was based on the width of the
and [N II] lines (
750
)
but Wilson & Nath (1990) found these lines to be much narrower
(
FWHM).
Koski (1978) noticed the presence of weak
H I absorption lines and, from the line intensity ratios, concluded
that it was very much like "normal'' galaxies, while for
Shuder &
Osterbrock (1981), it is not a Seyfert 2.
Using the line ratios published by
Koski (1978);
Ferland & Netzer (1983)
classified it as a Liner.
Osterbrock & Cohen (1982) have detected in the
spectra of this object the
4650 Wolf-Rayet emission feature. For
Ashby et al. (1992), it is a starburst galaxy. Line profile fitting of our
spectra revealed the "composite'' nature of this object.
Two systems were identified: a narrow one (FWHM = 325
)
with line ratios compatible with those usually observed in H II regions
(
= 0.62,
= 0.65 and
= 0.04) and a broader system
(FWHM = 480
) with line ratios similar to those of Liners
(
= 0.44,
= 0.96 and
= 0.14). This is, therefore,
a "composite object''.
IRAS 22114 - 1109 was classified a Seyfert 2 by
Veilleux et al. (1995); however, the [O III] lines are relatively weak
for this type of objects ( = 4.22;
Kim et al. 1995).
A line profile analysis was performed on the red and blue
spectra. The measured line intensities and widths are compatible with the
simultaneous presence on the slit of both a H II region
(
= 1.33,
= 0.70,
< 0.07 and
FWHM = 185
) and a
Seyfert 2 nebulosity (
fixed to 10.0,
= 0.60,
= 0.12 and FWHM = 415
), so this is another example of a
"composite-spectrum object''.
Mark 308 was called a Seyfert 2 galaxy by
Popov & Khachikian (1980)
and Zamorano et al. (1994);
Véron-Cetty & Véron
(1986a) classified it as a H II region, although the published
line ratios (Table 2) are unlikely
for either classes. The analysis of our blue spectrum (Paper I) showed this
object to be "composite'' with one narrow component with weak [O III] lines and
two broader components with strong [O III] lines; the analysis of our red
spectrum confirms this result, the narrow system
(
) being
typical of a H II region (with
fixed to 0.1,
= 0.30 and
= 0.06)
and the two broader line-sets
(
and 1045
, respectively)
of Seyfert-like clouds. Moreover, we have detected a weak broad
(1725
FWHM)
component containing
of the total
flux. The companion
galaxy, KUG 2239+200A, at z = 0.024
(Keel & van Soest 1992) and located
53
NE of Mark 308, has a H II-like emission-line spectrum.
Mark 522 is a Seyfert 2 galaxy according to
Veilleux & Osterbrock (1987);
however, the [O III] and [O I] lines are relatively weak
( = 3.23,
= 0.07).
Our observations show this object to be "composite'',
with two different line systems: one, "narrow''
(
),
typical of a H II region
(
= 0.63,
= 0.53
and
< 0.04),
the other, somewhat broader
(
), associated with a
Seyfert 2 nebulosity
(
= 7.87,
= 1.50 and
< 0.2).
Mark 313 is a Seyfert 2 galaxy according to
Osterbrock & Pogge (1987)
(with = 3.52,
= 0.52 and
= 0.10), and
Moran et al. (1996);
the [O III] lines are relatively weak for a Seyfert 2.
Images in [O III] and
+[N II] show a very complex structure, with high
excitation gas restricted to a symmetric, linear feature
(Mulchaey et al. 1996). From a two-component Gaussian fitting of high-dispersion spectra
of the nucleus of this object,
Maehara & Noguchi (1988) concluded that
it is a "composite object'' with a H II region and a Liner nebulosity.
Line profile analysis of our spectra reveals the contribution of two
different line-emitting regions: one, with
= 2.29,
= 0.44,
= 0.10 and narrow width (135
FWHM), is typical
of a H II region; the other, much weaker, is not detected in the blue
and its line ratios are
= 0.71 and
= 0.28; it could be either
a Seyfert 2 or a Liner, depending on the
ratio.
Zw 453.062 is a LIG (Goldader et al. 1997); it was called a Liner by Veilleux et al. (1995) on the basis of the measured emission line ratios, while Wu et al. (1998a,b) found its properties to be intermediate between H II regions and Liners, although the [O I] lines are very weak. Our spectra suggest that it is a "composite object'', one component being a Seyfert 2 nebulosity and the other a H II region.
IC 5298 is a LIG
(Goldader et al. 1997).
Wu et al. (1998a,b) found
that its properties are intermediate between H II regions and Liners;
it was classified as a Seyfert 2 by
Veilleux et al. (1995) although the
[O I] lines are rather weak ( = 0.05). Our observations suggest
that the spectrum is "composite'', being dominated by a H II region.
Copyright The European Southern Observatory (ESO)