next previous
Up: ROSAT All-Sky Survey

2. Identifying X-ray emitting IRAS galaxies

Our RASS II source catalogue only includes sources with a detection likelihood larger than eight. In addition, the number of source photons in the (0.1-2.4 keV) energy band must be larger than six. The latter restriction is obtained from an analysis of the distribution of detection likelihood values versus the ratio of source to background count rates. Sources with five or less source photons show unusually high source to background count ratios for their values of the detection likelihood, compared to sources with a higher detection likelihood. This may be due to uncertainties in the standard analysis software analysis of weak sources. To avoid the uncertainties introduced by the SASS detection algorithm we therefore require the number of source photons to be above some threshold. The RASS II source catalogue thereby constrained has 116 471 sources.

Through a correlation of the positions of 14 315 IRAS galaxies with 116 471 RASS II source positions we obtained a list of 372 possible identifications. Because of its superior positional accuracy, when available we used the IRAS FSC position instead of the IRAS PSC position. Table 2 lists the corresponding FSC and PSC names for such objects.

In Sect. 2.1 we estimate the number of chance coincidences among our correlated IRAS and RASS II sources, as well as the dependence of that number on the positional uncertainty of the RASS II source positions.

In a second step (Sect. 2.2) the candidate identifications were individually examined through superimposing the X-ray emission contours on optical images taken from the Palomar Digitized Sky Survey. In these images we also show the IRAS 3 tex2html_wrap_inline1818 error ellipse. All objects were classified according to how clearly the X-rays appear to originate from the optical counterpart of the respective IRAS source.

2.1. Identification through positional coincidence and chance coincidence rate

This section describes our first identification step, a search for RASS II sources within 5 arcmin around each of the 14 315 IRAS galaxies. We estimate the chance coincidence rate and its dependence on the positional identification uncertainty.

2.1.1. Chance coincidence rate from two random sets

From two random sets of N1 = 14 315 and N2 = 116 471 sources we expect
displaymath1824
chance pairs with an angular separation less than tex2html_wrap_inline1826, where tex2html_wrap_inline1826 is measured in arcsec. Within a separation of 100 arcsec we therefore expect 98 chance coincidences, which account for one quarter of the source pairs we found.

To empirically verify this number of chance coincidences we re-correlated the IRAS galaxy positions five times with RASS II positions that were offset by tex2html_wrap_inline183030 arcmin in right ascension and/or declination. The number of chance coincidences of separation less than 100 arcsec turned out to be 101 (tex2html_wrap_inline1832), 105 (tex2html_wrap_inline1834), 113 (tex2html_wrap_inline1836.), 105 (tex2html_wrap_inline1838), 102 (tex2html_wrap_inline1832, tex2html_wrap_inline1838). The slightly higher number of pairs in the test correlations may be due to an excess of correlation below about 150 arcsec separations that we attribute to a wider spatial correlation between diffuse cluster X-ray emission and the infrared emission from galaxies within the clusters (see the discussion in the following section).

The number distribution of pairs drawn from two randomly distributed sets of N1 and N2 objects, respectively, should follow
displaymath1848

A least square fit to the average distribution up to 300 arcsec of our five test correlations (cf. Fig. 1b) yields tex2html_wrap_inline1850, which corresponds to tex2html_wrap_inline1852, in fair agreement with the expected value of tex2html_wrap_inline1854.

2.1.2. Chance coincidence rate from the RASS II - infrared catalogue

We searched for RASS II counterparts within a radius of 5 arcmin around the position of each of the 14 315 IRAS galaxies and found 372 possible identifications. Figure 1 (click here)a shows the distribution of distances between the infrared position and its nearest X-ray source. In contrast to the distribution of random associations displayed in Fig. 1 (click here)b, the actual correlation of the two catalogues shows a strong excess of source pairs within about 50 arcsec. Of the 372 pairs within 100 arcsec the expected number of chance coincidences is 105, with an uncertainty estimated from the different X-ray catalogue offsets of about tex2html_wrap_inline18308. Thus statistically, we should have found about 267 IRAS sources with X-ray emission in their actual vicinity.

The width of the distribution of "real'' source pair separations arises from positional uncertainties in each catalogue, resulting in a Gaussian distribution with some angular width tex2html_wrap_inline1818. We therefore model the observed distribution as the sum of tex2html_wrap_inline1860 "real'' pairs, and a background characterized by the total number, tex2html_wrap_inline1862, of pairs in two sets of randomly distributed objects:
displaymath1864
A least square fit to the observed distribution yields tex2html_wrap_inline1866 arcsec and tex2html_wrap_inline1868 (we have fixed the value of tex2html_wrap_inline1862 to that obtained from the distribution of Fig. 1 (click here)b). Our visual inspection (cf. Sect. 2.3 and our overlays) of all 372 pairs resulted in 197 secure identification of X-ray emitting IRAS galaxies, a number in good agreement with the 204 objects attributed to the central Gaussian of the pair distribution function.

figure243   figure250
Figure 1: Distribution of separations between the IRAS PSC and ROSAT All Sky Survey II sources (left pannel) and an offset X-ray catalogue (right pannel, see text for details). We chose a maximum angular separation of 100 arcsec to obtain a first set of 372 candidate identifications. We estimate between 98 and 113 chance coincidences among these. After a visual examination of these objects we allow for a maximum separation of only 30 arcsec, which reduces the number of expected chance coincidences to tex2html_wrap_inline1872 pairs

The number of 204 sources we attribute to the central Gaussian is smaller than the total number of pairs to 100 arcsec minus the expected random pairs, 372 - 105 = 267. This is probably due to another excess above the expected random distribution and outside the central Gaussian peak, reaching out to about 150 arcsec (cf. Fig. 1 (click here)a). This wider excess could most naturally be explained as coming from IRAS galaxies embedded in clusters with diffuse X-ray emission from the intercluster gas. In such cases the IRAS galaxy is not the source of the X-ray emission, which come from the cluster gas and may peak somewhere within the cluster size away from the IRAS galaxy. The size of nearby clusters from which we would expect RASS-detectable intercluster gas emission is in fact of order 2 arcmin. In our detailed comparison of the ROSAT emission with the optical images we indeed found such clusters that we flagged accordingly (grade 3, see Sect. 2.3). The X-ray emission on the line of sight to IRAS F05537-6653 is a representative example.

For our 372 candidate pairs we searched the NASA/IPAC extragalactic database (NED) for optical identifications within a distance of 2 arcmin around the IRAS PSC positions. Table 3 lists the X-ray and infrared positions, and the positions of the found NED counterparts (we list at most nine of them) with their basic optical properties. Since NED comprises many catalogues, it may identify a given galaxy with several different names and coordinates. When an IRAS galaxy was clearly identified with an optical galaxy, the more accurate optical galaxy position is listed in Table 3 instead of the IRAS position.

We are aware that the spectral classification in NED is collected from the literature without quantifying the likelihood of the classification. For a better and consitent classification we therefore initiated an optical follow-up program the results of which will be presented in a separate paper.

2.1.3. X-ray position accuracy

In order to estimate the positional (aspect) errors of the X-ray sources we selected all IRAS galaxies with optical counterparts, and correlated the optical and RASS II positions. For accurate optical positions for the IRAS galaxies we searched the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) Guide Star Catalogue (GSC) (Lasker et al. 1990; Russell et al. 1990; Jenkner et al. 1990). Within a search radius of 5 arcmin 16 274 counterparts were found. Figure 2 shows the distribution of the optical and RASS II position offsets. Under the reasonable assumption that the accuracy of the HST GSC positions is much higher than that of the RASS II positions, we estimate the aspect error of the X-ray positions from the Gaussian width of the central distribution peak as tex2html_wrap_inline1882 arcsec. For a Gaussian distribution this results in 68% (90%) of ROSAT sources found within 10 arcsec (18 arcsec) of the HST GSC position. These numbers are in good agreement with the results (12 and 20 arcsec) found by Voges & Boller (1997) by correlating the ROSAT Bright Source Catalogue (Voges et al. 1996b) with the TYCHO catalogue for bright stars having an error of less than 1 arcsec (see their Fig. 3).

 figure266
Figure 2: Distribution of separations between the HST GSC and RASS II detected IRAS galaxies. The standard deviation tex2html_wrap_inline1818 of the Gaussian distribution is 11 arcsec. The value of 11 arcsec can be used to estimate the pointing accuracy for RASS II sources

  figure270
Figure 3: Soft X-ray flux tex2html_wrap_inline1886 derived from a power-law model with fixed spectral index tex2html_wrap_inline1888 and corrected only for Galactic absorption, plotted against the flux tex2html_wrap_inline1890 computed from a best fit power-law spectrum with free spectral index and absorbing column tex2html_wrap_inline1892

2.1.4. Comparison with RASS I catalogue

The 14 315 IRAS galaxies were previously correlated with the RASS I source catalogue and the results were presented in Boller et al. (1992a). The advantages of the RASS II processing with respect to the RASS I processing are discussed in the introduction of this paper. 52 objects from the original RASS I source catalogue are no longer included in the present catalogue. There are three reasons why objects were excluded; (i) the infrared flux at 100 tex2html_wrap_inline1898 is greater than 10 Jansky (see the footnote in our introduction), 26 objects fulfill this criteria; (ii) the positional offset from the new RASS II processing between the RASS II position and the infrared position is larger than 100 arcsec and/or the RASS II detection likelihood is less than eight (25 objects), and (iii), the number of RASS II source photons is less than six (one object).

Due to the merging of the original RASS I strips into 1378 sky-fields of 6.4 tex2html_wrap_inline1812 6.4 degree, 78 new objects at fainter X-ray fluxes are detected in the RASS II processing with respect to the RASS I processing and these objects appear now also in our new RASS II catalogue of IRAS galaxies.

The improved RASS II processing and our individual examination of the X-ray emission structure with respect to the optically visible galaxy and its environment together provide a higher degree of reliability of this catalogue compared to the previous RASS I - IRAS correlation. A third release of this catalogue might be called for if major improvements can be made in the SASS processing.

2.2. X-ray contours on optical images

The Photon Event (PET) Files from the RASS II processing were used to produce X-ray images and contour plots. To obtain an optimal spatial resolution of the X-ray images, the PET files were binned in 5 arcsec width bins. The resulting images were then smoothed with a tex2html_wrap_inline1904 arcsec Gaussian filter, corresponding to a full-width at half maximum of 45 arcsec, which is the expected width of the point spread function in the ROSAT All-Sky Survey. X-ray contours were computed in units of source photons per FWHM detection cell. The background photon density tex2html_wrap_inline1906 is known at each source position from the RASS II processing. To detect at least one source photon within a circular area of 45 arcsec diameter requires a mean photon density of tex2html_wrap_inline1908. The source plus background photon density is known from the PET files and the exposure map. The lowest contour line was chosen to represent two source photons per FWHM detection cell. The higher contour levels represent 3, 5, 9, 17 (doubling the contour value difference) and then 2n (for tex2html_wrap_inline1912) photons per FWHM detection cell. This choice of contours appears to best trace the source structure over their dynamic range.

The X-ray photon flux contours were overlaid on optical images, and a cross marks the centroid X-ray position obtained by the RASS II processing. Rectangles were drawn to mark the positions of NED sources, and for the IRAS FSC or PSC sources the 3tex2html_wrap_inline1818 error ellipse. The likelihood grade of the association of the X-ray emission with the IRAS galaxy (see next section) is printed in the lower right corner of each image.

2.3. Classification of X-ray detection likelihood

For a visual inspection we consider all 372 pairs with a separation of 100 arcsec as potentially "real'' correlations subject to further analysis.

This does however not necessarily imply that the IRAS galaxy itself is responsible for the X-ray emission. Since galaxies tend to be clustered (see our discussion in Sect. 2.1.1), the IR and X-ray emission may arise from neighboring galaxies, or from extended intercluster gas. An visual inspection of all 372 sources is therefore necessary to assess the emission structure in relation to the optically visible galaxy and its environment. In the visual examination we finally allow for a maximum separation of only 30 arcsec between the X-ray and the IR position, which reduces the number of expected chance coincidences to tex2html_wrap_inline1872 pairs.

We adopted a classification scheme with the following six grades to characterize the quality and likelihood of an identification of the RASS II emission with an IRAS galaxy.

1) The X-ray emission is spatially clearly coincident with an optical counterpart to the IRAS galaxy. There is no significant surrounding X-ray emission peak within the 5 arcmin detection cell used in the RASS II processing. Objects with a classification grade 1 have the highest likelihood that the X-ray emission is actually originating from the IRAS galaxy.

2) The X-ray emission is spatially coincident with an optical counterpart of the IRAS galaxy. However, there is significant surrounding X-ray emission within the RASS II detection cell. In this case the RASS II count rate was corrected by subtraction of the surrounding emission peaks, using the PET files. The number of source photons after subtraction of the secondary peaks is still required to be equal or greater then six.

2db) The IRAS galaxy may be a blend of two or more galaxies not resolved in the IRAS FSC or IRAS PSC. The X-ray emission is spatially coincident with the infrared position. The spatial resolution of the ROSAT All-Sky Survey does not allow a unique identification of one of the optical counterparts with the X-ray emission.

3) The X-ray emission shows complex and diffuse structure and cannot be uniquely associated with the IRAS galaxy. The complex emission may originate from intercluster gas, background or foreground objects. An identification with the IRAS galaxy is uncertain.

4) There is significant X-ray emission near the IRAS position, but it peaks at a distance larger than about 30 arcsec from the IRAS galaxy, which is about tex2html_wrap_inline1918 from the X-ray peak. This appears too far, but in some cases may be due to pointing errors in RASS II.

5) There is no spatial association of the X-ray emission with the IRAS galaxy. The RASS II centroid position only fortuitously coincides with the IRAS galaxy position.

9) Other:
(i) a bright foreground star close to the position of the IRAS galaxy is the most likely source of the X-ray emission;
(ii) less than 2 source photons are detected at the position of the RASS II centroid position, i.e. no contour lines are plotted (cf. IRAS 05576-7655).

Only objects with a classification grade 1, 2 or 2db are considered secure identifications of X-ray emission with an IRAS galaxy.

2.4. RASS II sources with resolved X-ray emission

In Table 1 (click here) we list sources considered as secure identifications which have an source extent that exceeds the point spread function. The likelihood of the source extent is required to be at least 10, a value obtained from a verification process of that SASS parameter.

 

(1) (2) (3)
IRAS name extent likelihood
F07387+4955 27 186
F13518+6933 1323
F14157+25221026
F14400+3539 1238
F16136+6550 1119
F17020+4544 1211
F18011+42467512
F18216+6419 23485
F20240-52336716
F22402+2927 926
23566-04241910
Table 1: RASS II sources which have a source extent larger than the point spread function. Column 1 gives the source name from IRAS FSC or PSC, respectively. The source extent above the point spread function in arcsec in given in Col. 2. The last column lists the likelihood of the source extent (cf. Cruddace et al. 1986)  

 

PSC name FSC name PSC name FSC name PSC name FSC name PSC name FSC name
00127+2817 00128+2817 00360-243200361-2432 00488+2907 00489+2908 00540-013300541-0133
01134+3046 01134+3045 01464+1249 01464+1248 02025+0941 02025+0940 02093+3714 02092+3714
02223-1922 02223-1921 02537-1641 02536-1641 03208-3723 03207-3723 03229-0618 03229-0619
03398-2124 03398-2123 03543-7216 03544-7216 04105-6811 04105-6810 04339-1028 04340-1028
04384-4848 04384-4849 04470-6227 04469-6227 04503+0114 04504+0114 04576+0912 04575+0912
05264-3936 05263-3937 05291-2608 05290-2608 05335-7359 05334-7359 05399-8345 05400-8345
05339-5804 05340-5804 05576-7655 05577-7655 05581-5907 05580-5907 06280+6342 06279+6342
06295+5743 06296+5743 07388+4955 07387+4955 07451+5543 07452+5543 08080-6109 08081-6109
08066-1905 08068-1906 08082+7900 08080+7900 08162+2717 08162+2716 09162+2628 09161+2628
09241+5735 09242+5735 09571+8435 09572+8435 10213+0644 10214+0644 10291+6517 10290+6517
11029+3130 11028+3130 11033+7250 11034+7250 11058+7159 11060+7158 11161+6020 11162+6020
11395+1033 11396+1033 11419+2022 11419+2023 12055+6527 12056+6527 12175+2933 12176+2933
12409+7823 12409+7824 12446-4058 12446-4057 12551+2040 12552+2039 12561+2752 12561+2751
12566+3507 12566+3506 12584+2803 12585+2803 13003+8017 13004+8017 13150+2051 13150+2052
13177-2021 13176-2020 13428+6652 13429+6652 13446+1121 13445+1121 13467+4014 13468+4013
13503+6104 13504+6104 13519+6933 13518+6933 13510+0442 13509+0442 13578+0516 13577+0517
14156+2522 14157+2522 14457+2308 14457+2309 15480+6822 15480+6821 15519+1444 15519+1445
16040+1818 16042+1824 17166-7536 17167-7536 17520+3250 17520+3249 17550+6520 17549+6520
17552+6209 17551+6209 17511-6542 17512-6542 18011+4247 18011+4246 18130+5703 18129+5703
18216+6418 18216+6419 18396-6225 18402-6224 19073-5257 19074-5257 19290+5830 19289+5830
19463-5843 19462-5843 19519-8141 19518-8142 20051-1117 20050-1117 20069+5929 20068+5929
20044-6114 20045-6114 20448+2515 20448+2514 20546-4849 20547-4849 21236-6013 21235-6013
21467-5530 21468-5530 22403+2927 22402+2927 22453-1744 22454-1744 22482-7027 22481-7028
22537-6511 22537-6512 23016-5144 23017-5144 23229+2835 23229+2834 23252+2318 23251+2318
23410+0228 23411+0228 - - - - - -
Table 2: FSC names and PSC names for identical objects
 


next previous
Up: ROSAT All-Sky Survey

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)