next previous
Up: Determination of the

3. Contaminating foreground sources

As mentioned earlier, the development of detector technology is advancing rapidly, producing detectors for CMBR experiments with very low noiselevels as indicated in Tables 1 (click here) and 2 (click here). Thus, the main obstacle for at least space based experiments is the contribution from different galactic and extragalactic foreground sources to the emission in the microwave and FIR sky.

The galactic foregrounds are identified as:

The extragalactic sources mainly consist of: Solar system objects like the Sun, the Earth and the Moon also play a vital role as effects contaminating observations of the CMBR anisotropies introducing noise by increased level of radiation. Unlike for the galactic and extragalactic sources, it is possible to compensate strongly for the effects introduced by solar system objects by choosing an orbit which minimizes these effects. It is shown by Muciaccia et al. (1996), that placing a satellite like PLANCK in the Lagrangian L2 point of the Sun/Earth system makes the effect induced by the Sun, the Earth and the Moon possible to handle. When the satellite points in anti-solar direction these objects will always be at large angles making straylight rejection and thermal control possible in order to achieve the high sensitivity required.

Only Jupiter will enter the field of view resulting in some loss of sky coverage. The planet can and will on the other hand be used for calibration purposes.

The effect of extragalactic sources on the observation of CMBR anisotropies has been studied extensively by e.g. Franceschini et al. (1989). Their results show, that point source confusion mainly becomes a problem on the tex2html_wrap_inline1520 level at angular resolutions better than 30' at least for the 50 to 200 GHz range. At higher frequencies IR point sources become increasingly troublesome.

With regards to the diffuse galactic emission Tegmark & Efstathiou (1996) find that the fluctuation power spectrum of these foregrounds is roughly consistent with tex2html_wrap_inline1658 assuming a coherence scale of tex2html_wrap_inline1660 corresponding to about tex2html_wrap_inline1662. This implies that fluctuations in the galactic foregrounds will be of less importance for higher tex2html_wrap_inline1664 i.e. smaller angular scales.

In the following a discussion of the foregrounds included in the modelling in this work is given. These include only galactic sources since the modelling is done only for a 30' angular resolution for all frequency bands for the PLANCK mission and parts thereof and for an 18' resolution for the MAP mission i.e. at angular scales where fluctuations from extragalactic sources are largely negligible.

3.1. Synchrotron radiation

The galactic synchrotron radiation is produced by Cosmic Ray (CR) electrons spiraling in the magnetic field of the Galaxy. It can be shown, that the emissivity and thus the intensity of the synchrotron radiation as a function of frequency follows a power-law if the energy spectrum for the CR electrons is assumed also to follow a power-law. The latter has been empirically established by means of observations of CR electrons close to Earth (e.g. Salter & Brown 1988). The intensity of the galactic synchrotron radiation can thus be expressed as:
equation342

Here tex2html_wrap_inline1670, where tex2html_wrap_inline1672 is the spectral index for the CR electron energy spectrum.

Radio surveys made at 408 MHz covering the entire sky with an angular resolution of 51' (Haslam et al. 1982) and at 1420 MHz covering the northern hemisphere down to declination tex2html_wrap_inline1676 with a 34' resolution (Reich 1982 and Reich & Reich 1986) show, that there is a rather significant variation of the spectral index. A variation of tex2html_wrap_inline1680 from 1.3 to 0.1 with a mean of 0.7 at declinations spanning from tex2html_wrap_inline1682 to tex2html_wrap_inline1684 was found by Brandt et al. (1994) by fitting spatially corresponding pixels of the two surveys and then fitting to a power-law.

But not only does the spectral index vary with position - it also tends to steepen with increasing frequency (Lawson et al. 1987). This steepening is thought to be induced by diffusive shock acceleration of the CR electrons perhaps caused by supernova explosions.

The overall picture is thus very complicated. The radiation depends on several parameters like electron density, electron energy distribution and magnetic field strength, which are not well known or rather not known for every position in the Galaxy. The only way to make significant progress in the attempts to describe the galactic synchrotron radiation is, by making high sensitivity, multifrequency measurements covering the entire sky with constant, high angular resolution and beam pattern. Such work by others is in progress (Danese et al. 1996) and should soon yield results.

The PLANCK mission will however produce high quality maps of the entire sky at frequencies where synchrotron radiation dominates. Such maps will be of great importance for constraining models for this radiation source. It will also make PLANCK more independent of ground-based observations and will thus play a significant role in the actual data processing.

In the present study, the synchrotron radiation is modelled as a perfect power-law, where both the spectral index and the baselevel are allowed to vary independently within limits, which should be sufficient to model any local variation. The spectral indices used in the models are thus not assumed to be frequency dependent.

3.2. Free-free emission

The galactic free-free emission originates from free electrons in the approximately 105 K hot ionized interstellar medium (ISM), which are deflected and thus slowed down by ionized atoms, mostly protons. The difference in kinetic energy of the electron before and after the deflection is the amount of energy radiated as free-free emission or "bremsstrahlung''.

Bennett et al. (1992) derive an expression giving the antenna or Rayleigh-Jeans temperature induced by the free-free emission as a function of frequency and find that the frequency dependence of the antenna temperature follows a power-law, tex2html_wrap_inline1688. The spectral index tex2html_wrap_inline1680 is a weak function of frequency and the kinetic electron temperature. In terms of intensity the frequency dependence of the free-free emission also takes the shape of a power-law with a spectral index of tex2html_wrap_inline1692.

The free-free emission component of our Galaxy is still rather poorly understood in the sense, that no usable all-sky maps exist. Bennett et al. (1992) produced all-sky maps from the COBE DMR data using both a subtraction and a fitting technique. Both maps are noise dominated - especially on small scales - and model dependent, since the modelling of the synchrotron radiation is uncertain (Brandt et al. 1994). Some conclusions can nevertheless be drawn from these maps, namely that the galactic free-free emission almost follows a cosecant-law when going to higher galactic latitudes (Bennett et al. 1992). The maps also show that the bulk of galactic free-free emission is confined in the plane of the Galaxy. This should come as no surprise since the hot, massive stars, which produce the environment suitable for making free-free emission are all located in the galactic plane (Partridge 1995).

Besides this work by Bennett et al. (1992) there is another approach based on a relation between the intensity of Htex2html_wrap_inline1680 and free-free emission as discussed by Reynolds (1992). Unfortunately no full sky survey of the interstellar Htex2html_wrap_inline1680 background exists yet so this method can only be used as an further estimate of the distribution of the free-free emission. Such estimates confirm the cosecant-law found by Bennett et al. (1992).

Kogut et al. (1995) have reported a spatial correlation between free-free emission and galactic dust emission (see below) on angular scales larger than the tex2html_wrap_inline1546 COBE DMR beam. They conclude that if this correlation holds to smaller angular scales, free-free emission should be a less significant contaminant for anisotropy measurements on degree scales at frequencies above 20 GHz.

This is confirmed by recent work by Simonetti et al. (1996), which indicates that free-free emission contribution to fluctuations at 27.5 GHz are negligible to CMBR anisotropies on degree-scales. These results were obtained by making sensitive Htex2html_wrap_inline1680 images and comparing these with recent data from the Saskatoon CMBR experiment.

Even though the lack of surveys of the galactic free-free emission leaves many open questions, the situation is a bit more relaxed than with respect to the synchrotron radiation since the possible range of parameters, like spectral index, are more constrained, as the physical processes causing the free-free emission are less sensitive to local changes in the environment (e.g. kinetic electron temperature).

In this work the free-free emission is modelled as a perfect power-law, as is the synchrotron radiation, where both parameters are allowed to vary within reasonable limits, in order to cover the resulting emission range produced by local variations.

3.3. Galactic dust emission

The galactic dust consists of conglomerates of molecules in a range of sizes from tex2html_wrap_inline1702 Å to tex2html_wrap_inline1704m, of which most are formed in the "cool" atmospheres of red giant stars and from there ejected into the ISM. Here the dust grains can be heated by the photon flux from stars and will then seek thermodynamic equilibrium by emitting radiation in the IR or the FIR part of the spectrum (see e.g. Alexander & Ferguson 1994; Sedlmayr 1994; Knapp 1991).

Dust will radiate as a grey-body, meaning that the emission spectrum for the dust will be a black-body corresponding to the equilibrium temperature, T, of the dust modified with a frequency dependent emissivity conventionally given as tex2html_wrap_inline1708 (Banday & Wolfendale 1991). The intensity of dust emission from a population of dust grains heated to the temperature, T, would then be:
equation376
where tex2html_wrap_inline1712 is the black-body radiation corresponding to the temperature, T. The spectral index, tex2html_wrap_inline1680, depends on the atomic and geometric structure and composition of the dust grains (Banday & Wolfendale 1991). Detailed calculations and laboratory experiments have demonstrated that tex2html_wrap_inline1718 for larger grains, whilst smaller grains tend to index values lower than 2.

Due to the contaminating effect of the Earth atmosphere, most information about the galactic dust emission is supplied by observations made by satellites i.e. IRAS and COBE.

Especially the COBE FIRAS and DIRBE instruments have provided vast amounts of information about the galactic dust at IR and FIR wavelength. Wright et al. (1991) reported preliminary spectral observations of the Galaxy by FIRAS, stating that there are two major components in the spectrum of the Galaxy, namely a continuous component due to heated dust and strong line emission from the 158 tex2html_wrap_inline1620m line of singly ionized carbon.

With respect to the continuum, Wright et al. (1991) split the dust emission into two functions - one of position (i.e. galactic longitude and latitude) and one describing the spectral behaviour (tex2html_wrap_inline1722). In order to determine the spectral behaviour Wright et al. (1991) tried out different forms of analytic fits with functions of the form given by Eq. (2). They found that the best fit was obtained with the expression:
equation386
where the term tex2html_wrap_inline1724 represents the galactic synchrotron radiation component. They obtained an even better fit, when introducing a cold dust component with a temperature of 4.77 K:
eqnarray393
The better fit by the two-temperature dust model is due to the fact, that the FIRAS data exhibit an excess of emission at long wavelength. The 4.77 K black-body emission supplies the excess needed to fit the data.

Similar spectral fitting, also based on the FIRAS data, has been performed by Reach et al. (1995). They also find evidence for a widespread, very cold (4-7 K) dust component, which has an optical depth that is spatially correlated with the "warm'' (tex2html_wrap_inline1728 K) dust. They argue that the cold component could either be a result of enhanced emissivity of the warm dust at submilimeter wavelength or be caused by a so far unknown population of dust grains.

The subject is nevertheless controversial since Boulanger et al. (1996) find, that the emission excess which Wright et al. (1991) and Reach et al. (1995) interpret as a cold component is not correlated with the 21 cm emission which traces the neutral hydrogen. Boulanger et al. (1996) conclude that the excess is either due to an unknown extragalactic source or caused by the FIRAS instrument. The work of Kogut et al. (1995), which indicates a correlation between the galactic free-free and dust emission does not exclude the possibility of a cold dust component but does not support it either.

Results from the COBE DIRBE instrument are not able to settle this dispute since the longest wavelength utilized by DIRBE is 240 tex2html_wrap_inline1620m. Any dust component radiating at 5-10 K would not contribute significantly to the intensity at 240 tex2html_wrap_inline1620m implying that such a component would remain largely undetected by DIRBE (Sodroski et al. 1994).

In this discussion one could find arguments to support the modelling of the galactic dust emission both as a two-temperature and a single-temperature dust. There is however a less complicated approach, which can be used. No matter whether the dust consists of one or more components, the Rayleigh-Jeans part of the dust spectrum can be approximated as a perfect power-law. Since the baseline frequency coverage of the PLANCK mission only just stretches further than the Rayleigh-Jeans part of the black-body for a 20 K dust component, the galactic dust emission is in this work modelled both as a two-temperature dust with a very cold component and as a perfect power-law with simultanious varying baselevel and spectral index covering all possible dust emission intensities demonstrated by the DIRBE 240 tex2html_wrap_inline1620m map extrapolated to the wavelength range of PLANCK.


next previous
Up: Determination of the

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)