next previous
Up: X-ray variability

4. Discussion

Large intensity variations over very short time scales are present in many black-hole candidates and in some neutron star systems. In the neutron star systems if the magnetic field is weak, the inner radius of the accretion disk can be very close to the neutron star surface resulting in flux variation at the Keplerian frequencies, or at the beat frequencies between the Keplerian frequency and spin of the neutron star. In the case of black-hole sources, the disk can extend upto the lowest stable orbit (3 times the Schwartzchild radius) for a non-rotating black hole, or even closer to the compact object for a maximally rotating compact object. The fast variations observed in GRS 1915+105 indicate size of the emission region tex2html_wrap_inline1065 0.1 light second, large for the inner disk of a few stellar mass black-hole.

The hard X-rays are found to be delayed compared to the soft X-rays indicating that the soft and hard
X-ray emitting regions are not the same and the variations in luminosity of the two regions are not simultaneous, as it is expected to be for physically separated regions. The hard X-ray emissions from black hole candidates are usually thought to be reprocessed emission of underlying soft photons from an inner disk. In such cases multiple inverse Compton scattering by the energetic electrons in the corona, which is responsible for the increase in energy of the photons, may introduce some delay between the soft and hard X-ray spectrum. Our observation of hard X-ray delay in the source, which is overlying on the QPOs as shown in Fig. 4 (click here), indicates that the soft X-rays (most of them of energy < 6  keV) from the inner disk are up-scattered by a plasma of size of a fraction of a light-second.

Quasi-periodic oscillations of many different frequencies are observed in GRS 1915+105 (Morgan et al. 1997). During the bright state, low frequency QPOs were observed with harmonics. QPOs of two or more different frequencies were also observed. The QPO frequency in the flaring state varied erratically between 0.0016 Hz and
0.16 Hz with a higher frequency QPO of 7.6 Hz observed on May 14. In the two flaring states the QPO frequency is relatively high, 1.5 Hz to 8 Hz varying erratically with a low frequency QPO of 0.003 Hz observed on June 16. The 67 Hz QPOs are observed during the bright and flaring state. The QPOs frequency variations during the low-hard state, seems to have some definite pattern in it. The QPO frequency was 2.3 Hz at the beginning of the low-hard state, decreased slowly to a lowest frequency of 0.62 Hz on July 25, and again increased slowly to 2.0 Hz towards the end of the low-hard state. The QPO frequency history of GRS 1915+105 during its low state inferred from published data is shown in Fig. 6 (click here). The rms/mean of 6 days observations of ASM around each data point is plotted along with the QPO frequency. Crossed circles are PPC observations, the dotted circles represent PCA observations (Morgan et al. 1997) and the stars are the rms/mean obtained from ASM archival data. We notice that the QPO frequency decreased to a minimum during our observations and then increased again. Erratic changes in the QPO frequency between segments of observations on the same day are present. An overall trend of a smooth decrease followed by increase in the QPO frequency is clearly observed. The rms deviation of the X-ray intensity shows dramatic change when the source makes transition from flaring to low state and again back to the flaring state. The QPO frequency appears to be very strongly related to the rms/mean intensity of the source. The hardness ratio between the tex2html_wrap_inline1069 keV flux and tex2html_wrap_inline1011 keV flux increased during the low-hard state and decreased again as the source went to the flaring state again.

  figure316
Figure 6: The QPO frequency (left scale) and rms variation (right scale) history of GRS 1915+105 during the low-hard state. The crossed circles are PPC observations and dotted circles are PCA observations. The stars represent the rms/mean during a 6 days period in the ASM light curve around each point

The quasi-periodic oscillations detected during our observations are stable, narrow and strong. It may represent the Keplerian motion of blobs of hot material in the disk. Stability of the QPO frequency in the range 0.62 to
0.82 Hz during 5 days of observations, during which the overall intensity of the source is also nearly constant, indicates that the QPO production region is narrow in the radial direction and is stable when the mass accretion rate is stable. But the force behind confinement of the hot spots in the radial directions which can produce narrow QPOs, is not understood.

In a model of disk accretion around black hole sources, in which the disk passes through a standing shock close to the centrifugal barrier, a QPO generation mechanism has been developed (Molteni et al. 1996). Oscillations around the mean shock location can give rise to intensity modulations similar to the quasi periodic oscillations observed in the black hole candidates like GX  tex2html_wrap_inline1035, GS  tex2html_wrap_inline1041 etc. The oscillations of the shock surface arise as a balancing act between the infall of the converging disk material and the outflow of the hot shockfront. If the cooling time scale of the expanding postshock halo and the infall time scale of the disk are nearly the same, a modulation of upto tex2html_wrap_inline1077 of the intensity can be produced. In this model the QPO frequency is predicted to increase with mass accretion rate. Sustained quasi-periodic oscillations are possible if the dominant cooling process is bremsstrahlung. Chakrabarti & Titarchuk (1995) have shown that for sources emitting near their Eddington luminosity the post shock region emits mainly by bremsstrahlung. The smooth QPO frequency variations during the low-hard state can be attributed to a similar increase in the mass accretion rate. This is in agreement with the QPO production process mentioned above. In this model the spectrum becomes harder at lower luminosity. This fact also has been observed in the ASM data showing a harder spectrum during the low state (Bradt 1996). For a tex2html_wrap_inline1079 black hole (for a stable 67 Hz QPO observed with PCA to represent the Keplerian rotation of the innermost stable disk around a non-rotating black hole) and 0.7 Hz QPO, the average shock front is at a radius of around tex2html_wrap_inline1081.


next previous
Up: X-ray variability

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)