next previous
Up: Fundamental parameters of

3. Imaging of Westerlund 1

In Fig. 3 (click here)a we show the V vs. (V-I) diagram for 233 measured stars in the field of Westerlund1. It is evident that the cluster is projected against a rich field of foreground/background stars, making it very difficult to trace a clear fiducial main sequence. In order to obtain a better definition of the CMD for the cluster stars by eliminating possible non-physical members, we first determined a centre for the cluster. This was accomplished by building the stellar density profiles as a function of pixel bins in the x and y directions, using all stars in Fig. 3 (click here)a. The final coordinates that we adopted for the position of the cluster centre are (tex2html_wrap_inline1615, tex2html_wrap_inline1617. We determined the cluster extent by calculating the average stellar density in successive 20 pixel wide annuli around the adopted centre. The resulting density profile is shown in Fig. 4 (click here), which shows that Westerlund1 presents a core and a relatively extended low-density corona. The angular radius of the core is about 36tex2html_wrap1599 (80 pixels) while the angular cluster diameter reaches tex2html_wrap_inline1621. This value was obtained by comparing the radial density profile of the cluster with independent determinations of the stellar density in four different fields around the cluster region. The derived diameter is very close to the average of 2tex2html_wrap1587and3tex2html_wrap1587 estimated by Westerlund (1961) and van den Bergh & Hagen (1975), respectively.

  figure186
Figure 3: Colour-magnitude diagrams for Westerlund1: a) all measured stars (dots), b) circular extraction for tex2html_wrap_inline1627 (filled circles) are superimposed, c) same as b) for tex2html_wrap_inline1629 (crosses)

  figure310
Figure 4: Density profile of Westerlund1

  figure315
Figure 5: HR diagram of Westerlund1. The solid lines are the solar metallicity isochrones of Bertelli et al. (1994) corresponding to 4 and 50 Myr, respectively. Symbols are as in Fig. 3 (click here). Identification and spectral types of stars are from Westerlund (1987)

We extracted V vs. (V-I) diagrams around tex2html_wrap_inline1635, tex2html_wrap_inline1637) for tex2html_wrap_inline1627 (50 pixels), basically corresponding to the cluster core, and tex2html_wrap_inline1629 (100 pixels), thus extending to the coronal region. These diagrams are shown in Figs. 3 (click here)b,c. The smallest circular extraction allowed us to know which are the CMD zones where the fiducial cluster sequences are located. Figure 3 (click here)c is a compromise between minimizing the unavoidable field contamination and maximazing the number of cluster stars.

Despite the presence of a certain amount of field stars, the main features of the cluster CMD are now clear. Westerlund1 appears as a vertical and very reddened main sequence affected by scatter. The vertical position of the main sequence resembles those in young open clusters. The scatter mainly arises from differential reddening, since the photometric internal errors are much smaller (Sect. 2 (click here)). Figures 3 (click here)b,c also exhibit several supergiant stars, as previously shown by W87.

To estimate the mean cluster reddening and apparent distance modulus we matched the CMD extractions (Figs. 3 (click here)b,c) to the theoretical isochrones by Bertelli et al. (1994). Figure 5 (click here) shows the results of our fitting using a solar abundance (see Sect. 4.1 (click here)) isochrone, corresponding to an age of 4 Myr; we have also included the next available isochrone (50 Myr) for comparison purposes. We derived tex2html_wrap_inline1643 or tex2html_wrap_inline1645 according to the E(V-I)/E(B-V) ratio given by Walker (1985), and an apparent distance modulus tex2html_wrap_inline1649. It is important to note that both the vertical position of the main sequence and its width makes it difficult to achieve an accurate placement of the isochrone, mainly along the V-axis. The presence of supergiants at tex2html_wrap_inline1653 mag helped us to match the rapid evolutionary phase at the top of the 4 Myr isochrone more properly. Using E(B-V) = 4.3 and R=Av/E(B-V)=3.0, we derived a visual absorption Av=12.9 and a true distance modulus of V0 - Mv=10.9 mag, equivalent to a distance of 1.5 kpc.

The derived visual absorption Av shows a very good agreement with the values found by Lockwood (1974) from stars observed at near-infrared wavelengths tex2html_wrap_inline1665), and that of Borgman et al. (1970) using K-filter observations. We have also obtained a similar value of Av from our CCD integrated spectrum (see Sect. 4.1 (click here)). The present visual absorption and true distance modulus differ significantly from the values derived by W87, whereas they are in fairly good agreement with Westerlund's (1961) earlier results (see also Sect. 1 (click here)).

Looking for a possible explanation for the difference with W87, we first examined how similar both (CCD and photographic) photometries are. This was done from 8 supergiants spread out within the cluster core region and for which W87 obtained MK spectral-types, V-Johnson magnitudes and (V-I) Kron colour indices. The comparison between both V magnitude scales yields a mean difference of tex2html_wrap_inline1677 mag, our values being sistematically brighter. To compare the (V-I) colour indices we first transformed the present (V-I) Cousins values to the Kron system. For this purpose, we used the MK vs. tex2html_wrap_inline1683 relationship given by W87, Bessell's (1979) relations between the Cousins and Kron systems, and the fact that the ratio Av/E(V-I) is the same in both systems (W87). A comparison of our transformed (V-I) indices with the values published by W87 yields a mean difference of 0.8 mag. This implies a 0.8 mag shift in the E(V-I) colour excess, which in turn leads to an Av value increased by 1.6 mag with respect to that of W87. Therefore, taking into account these zero points, the revised W87 true distance modulus and cluster distance are 11.7 and about 2.0 kpc, respectively, which are now consistent with the present CMD-fitting values.

An alternative way to derive the cluster distance is to use our CCD V magnitudes and Mv from W87 for the nine brightest stars in the cluster central region. We obtained tex2html_wrap_inline1697, equivalent to a distance of 1.2 + 0.3-0.2 kpc, adopting tex2html_wrap_inline1701 computed from appropriate R values (Crawford & Mandwewala 1976). This distance is somewhat smaller than that we obtained from the fitting analysis (Fig. 5 (click here)). However, if the couple (Av, tex2html_wrap_inline1707) is adopted, the 4 Myr isochrone in Fig. 5 (click here) would be displaced downwards nearly 1.0 mag, the fit being still satisfactory. In this case, only the brightest star (G0Ia+, No. 4 in W87) would slightly fall away from the sequence. Nevertheless, it might still be a member considering the amount of differential reddening present in the cluster.

An additional method to derive distance is to use the Mv magnitudes given by Mermilliod (1981a,b) from his open cluster age groups. We have recognized several features in the V vs. (V-I) plane with the aid of W87's MK spectral types, which resemble those in Mermilliod's NGC 457 and NGC 884 age groups (10-15 Myr). These features are: (i) a concentration of blue and yellow supergiants (Nos. 7, 8, 16, 32 and 33 in W87), (ii) a single very bright blue supergiant (No. 4), (iii) a red supergiant (No. 26, M2I), (iv) a Be star (No. 9), (v) the upper main sequence, and (vi) a V gap between the main sequence and the hotter supergiants. These features are consistent with a cluster distance of about 0.7 kpc.

After considering the three independent determinations, we adopted tex2html_wrap_inline1719 kpc, thus considerably improving the knowledge of the distance for Westerlund1.


next previous
Up: Fundamental parameters of

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)