next previous
Up: Atomic data from

3. Discussion of resonances and their effect on tex2html_wrap_inline2136

Of our energy dependent collision strengths only those for the 18 transitions between n = 2 and n' = 2, 3 are perturbed by autoionising resonances. In some cases the resonances greatly increase the effective collision strengths. But in general this happens at temperatures below a million degrees so it is not of particular astrophysical significance since, as mentioned earlier, under conditions of coronal ionization equilibrium the abundance of Fe+23 is essentially zero at such "low" temperatures.

It would be tedious to discuss in detail the energy dependence of each of the 39 collision strengths we have calculated. Here we select a few cases which serve to illustrate the main features. For conciseness and convenience we label the target energy levels nlj in ascending order with the index shown in Table 2 (click here). This starts at 1 for the ground level (tex2html_wrap_inline3044) and ends at 15 for the highest level (tex2html_wrap_inline3048).

Transitions tex2html_wrap_inline3050 and tex2html_wrap_inline3052 are optically allowed and, apart from their numerical values, the collision strengths tex2html_wrap_inline3054 and tex2html_wrap_inline3056 have almost identical resonance patterns. Figure 1 (click here) shows tex2html_wrap_inline3054 from threshold up to the energy of the tex2html_wrap_inline2156 level. Note that we plot tex2html_wrap_inline3062 against the final electron energy Ef in Rydberg units. The initial energy of the colliding electron E i relative to the the lower state is given by E i = Ef + E if, where E if is the transition energy and can be obtained from Table 2 (click here). At tex2html_wrap_inline3072 there is an indication in Fig. 1 (click here) of some structure in the collision strength. Suspecting that this is caused by resonances converging on the level tex2html_wrap_inline3074, we give a blow-up in Fig. 2 (click here) of the tex2html_wrap_inline3076 energy interval tex2html_wrap_inline3078). Here we clearly see a number of narrow, well separated resonances. A striking amount of detail, which is completely hidden in Fig. 1 (click here), is now revealed. The apparently random way the peaks of these small resonances vary is caused by not using a sufficiently small steplength in energy for the purpose of scanning. To do so would greatly increase the amount of computing time required and make the whole calculation extremely arduous. The reason why resonances occur over less than half the interval is because the search for them was stopped after a finite number had been located. Figure 3 (click here) shows tex2html_wrap_inline3080 as a function of temperature over the interval tex2html_wrap_inline3082. One can see a slight increase in tex2html_wrap_inline2136 for temperatures below about 106. This is due to the resonances shown in Fig. 2 (click here); those at higher energies have a much smaller effect on tex2html_wrap_inline2136 and produce a barely perceptible increase at temperatures above 106.

  figure929
Figure 3: tex2html_wrap_inline2150 effective collision strength for the temperature range tex2html_wrap_inline3094. Full line: IRON Project; broken line: Zhang et al. (1990)

The optically forbidden transition tex2html_wrap_inline3096 is a much more interesting case. Here we cover the range from Ef = 0 to the tex2html_wrap_inline3100 level by means of four separate plots in order to illustrate the varied structure of the resonances. Figure 4 (click here) covers the range tex2html_wrap_inline3102, which corresponds to the interval tex2html_wrap_inline3104. A thick forest of resonances is seen to occur here. A comparable forest also occurs in Fig. 5 (click here) for the range tex2html_wrap_inline3106 (interval tex2html_wrap_inline3108), while in Fig. 6 (click here) for the range tex2html_wrap_inline3110 (interval tex2html_wrap_inline3112), the forest of resonances is preceded by a collection of isolated peaks. Between the levels tex2html_wrap_inline3114 and tex2html_wrap_inline3116 there are no resonances and no graph is shown. In Fig. 7 (click here), which covers the interval tex2html_wrap_inline3118 (tex2html_wrap_inline3120), a striking series of Rydberg resonances appears. The process of delineation was stopped a short way from the tex2html_wrap_inline3122 level after 5 groups of resonances had been delineated. Figure 8 (click here) shows that after thermal averaging the effect on tex2html_wrap_inline3124 of all those resonances is considerable at temperatures below about one million degrees.

Finally, the transition tex2html_wrap_inline3126, namely tex2html_wrap_inline3076, is the only case encountered where resonances have a really big effect (50% increase above the background) at temperatures near ten million degrees, see Fig. 9 (click here).

The dotted curves shown in all graphs of tex2html_wrap_inline3062 or tex2html_wrap_inline2136 represent the DW calculations by Zhang et al. (1990). In order to make use of their tabulated collision strengths we first fitted them by cubic splines using the program OMEUPS (Burgess & Tully 1992). Each spline fit was then used to generate a tableau of collision strength values for the purpose of plotting. The same tableau was used to compute a thermally averaged collision strength in order to make a graphical comparison with the present IRON Project results.

  figure967
Figure 4: tex2html_wrap_inline3134 collision strength shown over the range tex2html_wrap_inline3136 (i.e. from tex2html_wrap_inline3138 to tex2html_wrap_inline3140). Full line: present Breit-Pauli calculation; broken line: DW calculation by Zhang et al. (1990)

  figure978
Figure 5: tex2html_wrap_inline3134 collision strength shown over the range tex2html_wrap_inline3144 (i.e. from tex2html_wrap_inline3146 to tex2html_wrap_inline3140). Full line: present Breit-Pauli calculation; broken line: DW calculation by Zhang et al. (1990)

  figure989
Figure 6: tex2html_wrap_inline3134 collision strength shown over the range tex2html_wrap_inline3152 (i.e. from tex2html_wrap_inline3140 to tex2html_wrap_inline3156). Full line: present Breit-Pauli calculation; broken line: DW calculation by Zhang et al. (1990)

  figure1000
Figure 6: tex2html_wrap_inline3134 collision strength shown over the range tex2html_wrap_inline3160 (i.e. from tex2html_wrap_inline3162 to tex2html_wrap_inline3164). Full line: present Breit-Pauli calculation; broken line: DW calculation by Zhang et al. (1990)

  figure1011
Figure 7: tex2html_wrap_inline3134 effective collision strength for the temperature range tex2html_wrap_inline3094. Full line: IRON Project; broken line: Zhang et al. (1990)

  figure1020
Figure 8: tex2html_wrap_inline1984tex2html_wrap_inline3172 effective collision strength for the temperature range tex2html_wrap_inline3094. Full line: IRON Project; broken line: Zhang et al. (1990)

Acknowledgements

This work was done with the support of a PPARC grant GR/K97608, and an EC network contract ERB CHRX CT920013. We thank David G. Hummer and Hong Lin Zhang for their constructive comments on an earlier version of the paper. The figures were prepared using the "trace vite et bien" graphics software written by Georges Gonczi at the Observatoire de la Côte d'Azur and available from http://www.obs-nice.fr/tvb/tvb.html.


next previous
Up: Atomic data from

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)
web@ed-phys.fr