next previous
Up: Deep morphologies of

3. Results

Table 2 (click here) displays line intensity measurements taken from Acker et al. 1993 (hereafter Acker93) and Cahn et al. 1992 (CKS92) as well as other published parameters collected from the literature for seven PN in study. Peimbert & Peimbert 1983 defined as type I PN those having tex2html_wrap_inline1222 or N/O tex2html_wrap_inline1224, and which generally display bipolar structures. Table 2 (click here) summarizes the measured parameters (PN dimensions, ionized mass in solar mass, and absolute fluxes).

3.1. A 39: PN 047.0 +42.4

The tex2html_wrap_inline1126 and [OIII]5007 Å images display a nearly circular and identical shape (Figs. 1 (click here)). However, this circular symmetry seems to be distortedgif by the interaction with the interstellar medium. The diameter measured on the tex2html_wrap_inline1126 image (tex2html_wrap_inline1230) agrees with the value of 174'' reported by Cahn & Kaler (1971) (CK71). [NII]6583 emission was not detected. At the distance of 1200 pc (CKS92), the observed diameter corresponds to a linear value of 1.0 pc.

3.2. Sh 1-89: PN 089.8 - 00.6

This object was not detected with the filter [OII]3727 (1800 s), and curiously HeII (600 s) as well, but we strongly suspect the effets of the bad weather conditions during these observations. The tex2html_wrap_inline1174 images are not usable for investigating internal absorption. Nevertheless, all the other images (Figs. 2 (click here)) display outstanding peripheral features, the nebular dimensions being definitely larger than 35'' quoted. The observed (tex2html_wrap_inline1126 and [NII]) images show a rather complex structure. Even the bright core actually spreads over 60''. Bubbles and wisps extend over 6 arcminutes. Due to the faint jet-like emissions on both sides of the bright waist, we can hardly assign to Sh 1-89 any of the available models (bubble, butterfly, jet?) to explain such a peculiar morphology. The overall dimensions are tex2html_wrap_inline1248 along the major axis. Sh 1-89 would be one of rare planetary nebulae which have linear diameter larger than 1 pc, since its main bubble-like structure spreads over 230'' (tex2html_wrap_inline1254).

  figure273
Figure 1: a) Top: Htex2html_wrap_inline1256. The planetary nebula shows a nearly circular shape. At the distance of 1200 pc, A 39 has a linear diameter of tex2html_wrap_inline1258. The overall field of view covers tex2html_wrap_inline1260 arcseconds. North is towards the top and East at left for all figures. b) Bottom: The [OIII] emission is much stronger than that in tex2html_wrap_inline1126

  figure280
Figure 2: a) Top left: The tex2html_wrap_inline1126 image was obtained with a RCA-CCD. Due to the limited dimensions of the detector (tex2html_wrap_inline1266 i.e. tex2html_wrap_inline1268) the extended western filament is not shown here. A substantial contribution from the nitrogen emission line should be taken into account into the 48 Å wide bandpass. b) Bottom: Obtained with a Tektronic tex2html_wrap_inline1270 CCD: the bright centre spreads over tex2html_wrap_inline1272. The total field of view covers tex2html_wrap_inline1128 square arcseconds. Note the "jet-like'' structure on both sides of the main bubbles marked by filamentary network. The major axis extends up to tex2html_wrap_inline1276, whereas the main bubble-like nebula spreads over 230'' (2.16 pc). c) Top right: Only the bright centre is seen here, surrounded by a rather diffuse emission

  figure289
Figure 3: a) Top: Htex2html_wrap_inline1256. The overall dimensions spread over 250'' or 1.2 pc. The bright elongated core is surrounded by a faint envelope. b) Bottom: The outer [NII]6583 emission is more conspicuous than that seen in tex2html_wrap_inline1126



 figure298
Figure 3: c) Top: [OIII]5007. The outer halo seen in the two previous emission lines is not detected in [OIII]. d) Bottom: [SII]. A faint emission is detected southwards

  figure304
Figure 4: a) Top left. The limited dimensions of the RCA-CCD detector did not allow to display the eastern region of NGC 650-1. b) Top right: ([NII]). Same remarks as for tex2html_wrap_inline1126. c) Bottom: The [OIII] image displays the same morphology as in tex2html_wrap_inline1126

  figure313
Figure 5: a) Top: Htex2html_wrap_inline1256. NGC 6302 was observed at the MJUO 1-m telescope. North is towards the right and east is at the top. b) Middle: [NII]6583. Same orientation as for tex2html_wrap_inline1126. The knotty westward emission is more extended in [NII]. c) Bottom: Only the bright core is seen in [OIII]

  figure322
Figure 6: The low and high ionisation potential ions apparently occupy the same volume. a) Top left: Htex2html_wrap_inline1256. b) Middle left: [NII] emission shows a more conspicuous filamentary structure. c) Top right: The [OII] emission region is similar to the [OIII] ones. d) Middle right: tex2html_wrap_inline1296 ions are seen in the same region as for [OII] and [SII]. The inner ring in the left side is the ghost image of the bright centre. e) Bottom: The [SII] emission is fairly weak in comparison with the other ionic species

  figure336
Figure 7: a) Top: Htex2html_wrap_inline1256 The overall dimensions of the Ring nebula are tex2html_wrap_inline1300 square arcseconds. The tex2html_wrap_inline1126 image shows an outer circular "ring'' not seen in [NII]. b) Bottom: The outer [NII] emission is more diffuse than in tex2html_wrap_inline1126

3.3. Sh 2-71: PN 035.9 -01.1

The tex2html_wrap_inline1126, [NII]6583 Å, [OIII]5007 Å (Figs. 3 (click here)), tex2html_wrap_inline1174, and 39 Å-wide [SII]6737 Å images show a rather elongated and bright central nebula (tex2html_wrap_inline1360), whereas an outer faint emission spreads over a larger area tex2html_wrap_inline1362 than previously quoted (100'', CK71). The extensions reported in this study are even much larger than that reported by Jewitt et al. 1986 who considered Sh 2-71 as an excellent example of PN with halo even though these authors observed only the bright elongated core. The nitrogen emission is more prominent along the radial structures outwards. The tex2html_wrap_inline1126, [NII]6583 Å images display a bright elongated nebula (tex2html_wrap_inline1370), with faint emission spreading over a more extended area tex2html_wrap_inline1372 at the distance of 997 pc - (CKS92, tex2html_wrap_inline1374), much larger than quoted so far. The [OIII]5007 image is smaller, limited to the bright (tex2html_wrap_inline1376) elliptical ring, without the outer emission detected in the tex2html_wrap_inline1126 and [NII] images.

3.4. NGC 650-1: PN 130 -10.1

This planetary nebula (Figs. 4 (click here)) was imaged with the tex2html_wrap_inline1266 RCA-CCD. The images in tex2html_wrap_inline1126, [NII]6583 Å and [OIII]5007 Å display an apparent morphology which shows strong similarities with Sh 1-89. The overall extension is certainly larger than the dimensions revealed by the CCD in use (tex2html_wrap_inline1390).

3.5. NGC 6302: PN 349.5+01.0

This young bipolar PN is characterized by a high interstellar absorption since the tex2html_wrap_inline1394) ratio implies E(B-V) = 0.96. The excitation is very high (class 10+); the helium abundance He/H is twice (0.182) the average value for known PN. Furthermore, nitrogen (tex2html_wrap_inline1400) has 10 times the average abundance (CKS92).

Our monochromatic images (Figs. 5 (click here)) in tex2html_wrap_inline1126, tex2html_wrap_inline1174, [NII]6583 Å and [OIII]5007 Å obviously reveal a butterfly shape with an "explosive'' structure around a bright compact central core separated into two areas by an absorbing lane. The tex2html_wrap_inline1126 and [OIII]5007 images display similar structures, whereas the [NII]6583 image shows a more knotty morphology. The present observations have detected even larger dimensions (> 250'') than that reported by Ashley (1990) (Proc. ASA, 8, 360). The narrowband [NII]6583 filter helps to outline conspicuous filaments more extended (NW) than in tex2html_wrap_inline1126.

3.6. NGC 6543: PN 096.4 +29.9

This is one of the most outstanding PN among the so-called multiple-shell planetary nebulae, displaying a large faint envelope (tex2html_wrap_inline1414 in diameter). It is obviously of interest to investigate the morphological nature of the surrounding giant halo. We have observed (Figs. 6 (click here)) this PN through the tex2html_wrap_inline1126, [NII]6583 Å, [OIII]5007 Å, [OII]3727 Å, and 39 Å-wide [SII] filters. All images show conspicuous ejecta far from the main nebula. The global filamentary structure appears up to 270'' from the bright core, in agreement with Middlemass et al. (1989) who considered them as low surface brightness areas and probable density enhancements, illustrating the point that ionizing photons are escaping from the system.

The overall diameter in the observed images is 340'' including the faint outermost structures. This dimension corresponds to tex2html_wrap_inline1422 at the distance given by CKS92 (982 pc). This overall extension raises the question of the age of the nebula. The present estimated value of 3000 years probably involves solely the bright central nebula of tex2html_wrap_inline1424 wide. The actual dimensions of NGC 6543, along with the expansion velocity in the outer region, tex2html_wrap_inline1426, would infer a much larger age (tex2html_wrap_inline1428). Presumably, we see previous ejecta by the AGB progenitor.

3.7. The Ring Nebula: NGC 6720 - PN 063.1 +13.9

The Ring Nebula is certainly one of the most extensively investigated planetary nebula since its discovery (Duncan 1937). Moreno & Lopez 1987 showed that the Ring Nebula has dimensions definitely larger than the optical 76'' of the bright elliptical core (Moreno & Lopez 1987; Bryce et al. 1994). Our monochromatic observations (Figs. 7 (click here)) through narrow (tex2html_wrap_inline1126, [NII]6583, [OIII]5007) and moderate (tex2html_wrap_inline1174, tex2html_wrap_inline1440, [SII]tex2html_wrap_inline1442, tex2html_wrap_inline1444) bandwidth filters confirm these outermost features surrounding the filamentary network.


next previous
Up: Deep morphologies of

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)
web@ed-phys.fr