next previous
Up: Multi-spectral study of

4. Discussion

4.1. The surface brightness distributions

On the atlas of profiles, (Fig. 1 (click here)), a classical flat (disk) distribution of light, following the well-known exponential law, translates into a linear relation. Alternatively, a plot of the surface brightness versus the 0.25 power of the equivalent radius allows to recognize the objects having a light distribution of "spheroidal galaxy'' type. One would expect the occurrence of "mixed'' profiles indicating the probable presence of two dynamically different populations, the disk-like one and the spheroidal one, making such objects low luminosity equivalents of normal giant flattened galaxies.

The preliminary study of the brightness profiles allows us to sort out:

 

name tex2html_wrap_inline1910(R)[pc] tex2html_wrap_inline1910(B)[pc] tex2html_wrap_inline2204] tex2html_wrap_inline2206] tex2html_wrap_inline2208 tex2html_wrap_inline2210
sbs0940 308 5251.121.1121.7822.39
mrk1308 407 317 1.31 1.20 19.60 21.09
sbs1006 430 338 0.40 0.5120.0720.64
mrk1416 478 518 1.19 1.04 20.1120.61
sbs1428 555 597 1.030.98 18.9 20.37
sbs1533 684 - 0.97 -18.38-
mrk1423 779- 0.65 -15.06-
Table 3: Exponential profiles

 

In the following we discuss some characteristics of the derived surface brightness profiles.

4.1.1. Objects with an r1/4 law

Figure 3 (click here) shows, in (tex2html_wrap_inline1908, tex2html_wrap_inline2216) coordinates, the observed brightness distribution of the 10 objects exhibiting a linear r1/4 law across a substantial range of equivalent radius. We assume that the surface brightness profile follows the empirical law as given by De Vaucouleurs (1948, 1953)

equation548
where I is the intensity at a given r and tex2html_wrap_inline2224 is the intensity at the effective radius. This relation is more convenient to use in terms of surface brightness tex2html_wrap_inline1908

equation556

Genuinely fitting a linear relation on the (tex2html_wrap_inline1908 versus (tex2html_wrap_inline2230) plot of the surface brightness in the range of tex2html_wrap_inline2232 not affected by seeing effects, we get the slope and the deviation of the profile from the pure r 1/4 law. It appears that for some galaxies (Mk 1450, Mk 1480 and SBS 1147+520) the slope is different in the two bands. Note that the 8.327 slope is intrinsic to the r1/4 law, as written in terms of normalized coordinates (tex2html_wrap_inline2238, tex2html_wrap_inline2216). A value of the slope differing significantly from the canonical 8.327 usually implies that the adopted tex2html_wrap_inline1942 is not correct. Since the determination of tex2html_wrap_inline1942 is made through an extrapolation process (in order to derive the asymptotic magnitude from the cumulated magnitude growth curve) the errors are quite difficult to control, especially when the frames are insufficiently deep. However, another effect is also responsible for the deviation from a pure r1/4 law: if the galaxy houses a population dynamically different from an isothermal spheroid (King 1966) that contaminates the light of the latter, departure from the r1/4 law will be quickly visible. This is the obvious case for extended envelopes that show up as excess light above the r1/4 (e.g. SBS0136+328, Mk 324 and Mk 1426). It should be underlined that these outer envelopes differ in color from that of more central regions, suggesting a different stellar content. Also, if the [tex2html_wrap_inline1908, (tex2html_wrap_inline2230] relationship is linear but with a slope different from 8.327, on frames sufficiently deep such as to rule out significant errors on tex2html_wrap_inline1942, it could be suggested that a non-spherical population is quite continuously superimposed to the spherical one, (but with a moderate contribution to the total light) so that the scale length is changed (as could be the case for Mk 324).

  figure583
Figure 3: Reduced surface brightness distributions of the 10 galaxies obeying an r1/4 law. The abscissa is the quantity tex2html_wrap_inline2260, the ordinate is the surface brightness in magnitudes per square arc second. The tick marks in abscissa represent a 0.5 interval. The dashed line has a slope of 8.327 and represents the "pure'' de Vaucouleurs' law. The various curves, translated from each other to ensure legibility, are for: a) SBS 0136+328, b) SBS 1054+504, c) SBS 1147+520, d) Mk 324, e) Mk 996, f) Mk 1434, g) Mk 1450, h) Mk 1480, i) Mk 1418, j) Mk 1426

4.1.2. Exponential profiles

In most cases, the exponential law (de Vaucouleurs 1959) applies right after the seeing limit (tex2html_wrap_inline2264 to 3'').
equation603
or, in terms of surface brightness:
equation607
where 1/r0 is the scaling factor in tex2html_wrap_inline2270 and tex2html_wrap_inline2272 is the central value of the surface brightness. In other cases, there is a significant contribution of a small brighter central component. See also the case of SBS 1006+578 in Sect. 3.5. Table 4 (click here) gives the resulting numerical values of the linear regression.

 

Object name d [Mpc] MB tex2html_wrap_inline1942[pc](B)r24[pc](B)
tex2html_wrap_inline1942[pc](R)r24[pc](R)
SBS 0136 84.5 -17.72 1910 2181
11843472
SBS 0940 23.0 -14.34 643 577
503 638
SBS 1006 18.6 -14.80362 655
473 864
SBS 1054 18.6 -15.16348 661
4111070
SBS 1147 15.0 -13.60 197 332
205559
SBS 1331 10.8 -15.14 616 761
635 988
SBS 1413 11.1 -13.83 803 505
505512
SBS 1428 32.1 -16.51653 1376
665 1948
SBS 1533 44.2 - - -
825 2065
Mk 324 23.9 -16.98 1131 1041
536 1405
Mk 900 17.5 -16.83 1286 1137
1729 2888
Mk 996 21.4 - 558 1532
14541913
Mk 1131 27.3 -17.242453 1316
911 2808
Mk 1308 13.6 -15.80 505 931
460 1392
Mk 1416 28.7 -15.31 541 881
586 1281
Mk 1418 6.3 -14.62 223 484
260 803
Mk 1423 15.5 - - -
-17.17948 1441
Mk 1426 25.2 - - -
-17.23561 1658
Mk 1434 27.6 -14.84 251 601
264866
Mk 1450 12.6 -13.52 127 306
141 641
Mk 1480 24.3 -15.36 358 738
465 1144
Mk 1481 25.1 -15.21 737 917
812 1154
Mk 1499 36.7 -16.29 650 1138
926 2068
Table 4: Absolute magnitudes and linear radii

 

4.1.3. Mixed law profiles

4 galaxies show a profile reminiscent of the classical superimposition of a central bulge component with an underlying exponential law extending to the outer parts where this latter becomes dominant. The exponential is easily interpreted as showing up the presence of a disk. Only 2 cases show a slight systematic blueing outwards. (SBS 1413+495 and SBS 0940+544C)

4.2. Integral relationships

Table 4 (click here) lists the integrated parameters on the observed galaxies together with metric observables deduced from the photometry. The distance dependent quantities have been derived using tex2html_wrap_inline2376, the redshifts of Table 2 (click here) corrected from Galactic rotation (using tex2html_wrap_inline2378) and from the Virgo-centric infall model of Aaronson et al. (1981) as reformulated by Bottinelli et al. (1986) using the recent Virgo distance based on Cepheid photometry by Freedman et al. (1994).

Table 4 (click here) is arranged as follows:
Column 1: Name of the galaxy
Column 2: Distance in Mpc.
Column 3: Absolute B magnitude from our asymptotic magnitude.
Column 4: Effective equivalent radius in pc, in B and R colors.
Column 5: Isophotal equivalent radius at tex2html_wrap_inline2386 in pc, in B and R colors.

4.2.1. Color distributions

Figure 4 (click here) displays the histogram of the asymptotic B-R colors.

The asymptotic B-R color ranges from 0.22 to 2.16. The mean color of the sample is 1.09 (with no correction for reddening due to Galactic or internal absorption) which places the sample among the blue galaxy population. Fukugita et al. (1995) have recently revised the integrated colors of various galaxy types and show that normal field galaxies of elliptical types have B-R = 1.6 while the bluest spirals of type Scd have B-R = 1.0 (from synthetic color computation, perhaps a little redder from observations). 2 objects in our sample are very blue with tex2html_wrap_inline2400: SBS 1413+495 (B-R = 0.22) and Mk 324 (B-R = 0.44). We note that the galaxies whose brightness distribution obey an r1/4 law follow the same distribution of colors as that of the whole sample.

4.2.2. Radius-luminosity relations

Figure 5 (click here)a shows relations between the logarithm of the effective radius and the absolute magnitude in B, uncorrected for Galactic and internal absorption. The two quantities are correlated (correlation coefficient of 0.82 in B and 0.66 in R) as expected, with a slope of tex2html_wrap_inline2414 in B and tex2html_wrap_inline2418 in R.

In B, there is a clear deviation from the expected slope of -5 implied by a dependence of the luminosity on the square of the radius. It should be remembered that Heidmann (1969) found a dependence of the luminosity on rk with k = 1.9 for giant ellipticals and k = 2.8 for giant spirals. However Fraser (1977) found k = 2.1 for Virgo spirals). The tendency in our sample is towards an excess B luminosity for the less luminous objects, for a given effective radius. Although the dispersion in both colors may be explained partly by the extrapolation errors in the determination of tex2html_wrap_inline1942 (see Sect. 4.1.2) and the errors on the distance moduli, the trend would rather be due to the selection bias of the sample. The most extreme blue compact dwarfs are selected in the Byurakan surveys because their central surface brightness in the blue part of the spectrum, reinforced by the starburst, is intrinsically high. The use of tex2html_wrap_inline1942 favours the weight of the central regions where the burst dominates the light (see Table 4 (click here)), and this bias is stronger on the intrinsically faint objects.

  figure657
Figure 4: Distribution of asymptotic B-R colors

In R band, there is a large dispersion of the representative points, but, as expected, the "blue'' selection bias as explained above is much less apparent.

figure662

  figure665
Figure 5: Absolute magnitude-radius relations: a) at tex2html_wrap_inline2444, (effective) in B band, b) at r = r24, (isophotal at tex2html_wrap_inline2450) in B band

Figure 5 (click here)b shows the same relationship using the isophotal radius r24. This radius is systematically larger than tex2html_wrap_inline1942, and therefore integrates light largely emitted by the underlying evolved population, hence reducing the weight of the starburst component. The dispersions are much reduced, the slopes are tex2html_wrap_inline2458 in B and tex2html_wrap_inline2462 in R with respective correlation coefficients of 0.90 and 0.96. The slope in B is significantly different from -5, but in the opposite sense as observed in the (MB, tex2html_wrap_inline2472) plot. Most of the discrepancy comes from Mk 324 and Mk 1131 which both exhibit an extended envelope that contributes significantly to the light beyond r24. Excluding these galaxies, we find a slope of tex2html_wrap_inline2476 (correlation coefficient: 0.97) for the (MB, r24) diagram, and hence an almost identical behaviour in B and R, and consistency with a luminosity proportional to the square of the isophotal radius.

Huchra (1977) found that the luminosity of Markaryan galaxies, irrespective of their morphological type, closely follows a r2 dependence (r being an estimate of the isophotal radius), "indicating approximate constancy of mean surface brightness over the absolute magnitude interval studied''. However, there is only a small number of dwarf Markaryan (tex2html_wrap_inline2490) in Huchra's study, and the selection effects towards compact, i.e. high surface brightness objects, in our sample are certainly different from those present in an all-type Markaryan galaxy sample.

4.2.3. Compactness

Compact galaxies were defined by Zwicky (1967, 1971) as being galaxies for which the central surface brightness is brighter than tex2html_wrap_inline2498 in B. But this definition applies, at least partly, to almost all galaxies having giant star-forming regions and/or a bright nuclear component. It is usually assumed that a dwarf "compact'' galaxy associates two basic features: a short scale length of the brightness distribution and a high "average'' surface brightness, this latter being the observable translation of a higher than normal stellar luminosity density.

Figure 6 (click here) displays the histogram of the mean surface brightness inside the effective radius measured in B band. The average surface brightness of the night sky is around tex2html_wrap_inline2504. The median value, (uncorrected for Galactic foreground extinction) observed for our sample is tex2html_wrap_inline2506 and several objects have especially bright values (namely Mk 996, Mk 1418, Mk 1434 and Mk 1450). Compared to a sample of DDO dwarf galaxies (de Vaucouleurs et al. 1981) that exhibit low or moderate star formation rates in the average, and is largely dominated by disk late-type systems, the Byurakan dwarf blue compacts are brighter in tex2html_wrap_inline2508 by some two magnitudes. From Ichakawa et al. (1986), we get that the average of tex2html_wrap_inline2508 in 69 dwarf ellipticals of the Virgo Cluster is tex2html_wrap_inline2512. The Byurakan BCDGs among which we find a high proportion of dwarf elliptical galaxy analogs (but with r1/4 laws while dE's of Virgo are claimed to have exponential brightness distributions: Ichikawa et al. 1986) are again some two magnitudes brighter.

Figure 7 (click here) displays the histogram of the concentration index C21(B) as defined in Sect. 3.4.1. This index averages from 1.6 to 1.9 for diffuse late-type spirals, and reaches about 2.5 to 2.8 for normal ellipticals (Fraser 1972, 1977; de Vaucouleurs & Aguero 1973) while diffuse dwarf magellanic have tex2html_wrap_inline2518 (Ables 1971). The present sample peaks at 1.9 and one may notice three anomalously "concentrated'' objects (namely Mk 324, Mk 900 and Mk 1308).

Finally, Fig. 7 (click here) shows the histogram of the effective radii in pc measured in B band. The bulk of our galaxies have indeed small effective radii with 9 objects below 500 pc.

  figure703
Figure 6: Distribution of the mean surface brightness inside tex2html_wrap_inline1942

  figure708
Figure 7: Distribution of the concentration index C21 in B light

  figure713
Figure 8: Distribution of effective radii in pc (B band)


next previous
Up: Multi-spectral study of

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)
web@ed-phys.fr