next previous
Up: Field #3 of

3. Discussion

The sample is too small to estimate reliably from the RR Lyrae the distance to the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy. Furthermore, we are looking at the edge of the dwarf galaxy and the RR Lyrae sample might be a mixture of stars from the galactic halo and the dwarf galaxy. An indication that we are possibly dealing with a mixed sample can be obtained as follows. Select from the sample those RRab stars for which extinction corrections are possible from their colours at minimum light (i.e. Q=0: both the period and the classification are correct). There are only four of those stars in the sample. If the extinction correction is done as described by Wesselink (1987) and Alard (1996) we have to discard two stars from our consideration, because one is too blue (#1371) and the other one is probably too faint (#1524). For the two remaining stars we apply the mean reddening correction mentioned in Sect. 2. This gives a mean distance modulus for these stars of tex2html_wrap_inline984 or a distance of tex2html_wrap_inline986 kpc. The distance modulus is in good agreement with tex2html_wrap_inline988 obtained by Mateo et al. (1995). The distance is within the uncertainties of tex2html_wrap_inline990 kpc, obtained by Alard (1996) from a much larger sample of stars. The mean distance of the RRab stars in Table 1 is about 32 kpc. This might be due to a contribution of stars from the galactic halo or it might be due to an extension along the line of sight of the dwarf galaxy. Radial velocities of the stars might help to distinguish the two scenarios from each other.

  figure269
Figure 2: Period-tex2html_wrap_inline992 relation for Mira (open square) and semiregular (triangle) variables in PG3. The open circle indicates a carbon star among these variables. The thick solid line is the relation obtained by Glass et al. (1995) for the Miras in Sgr I. The long dashed area shows the contribution in the galactic bulge and the dashed line is the relation from Glass et al., shifted tex2html_wrap_inline994 (i.e. 26 kpc)

The Mira and semiregular variables in our sample of possible members of the dwarf galaxy are best looked at in a period-luminosity diagram (Fig. 2 (click here)). Whitelock et al. (1991) demonstrated that the period-luminosity relation is independent of the metallicity of the Miras. This might also apply to the semiregulars. In Paper II it is argued that they are the short period extension to this relation. In Fig. 2 (click here) we plotted the variables in Table 1, together with the galactic contribution in PG3. We refer to Paper II for details about the galactic contribution. We also show the tex2html_wrap_inline996-relation of Glass et al. (1995) shifted tex2html_wrap_inline998, i.e. to a distance of 26 kpc. At this distance the stars are about 4 kpc out of the galactic plane, where one expects to find mainly old metal-poor stars, from the metal-poor thick disc and the halo (Ng et al. 1997). In these populations one does not expect to find long period variable stars, because they have not been found in the old metal-poor globular clusters. Therefore, the semiregular variables and Miras cannot be of galactic origin and should belong to a considerable younger population. But a dwarf galaxy, which has interaction with our Galaxy, can contain younger populations. This demonstrates that the long period variables could indeed be located in the dwarf galaxy, except for variables #192 and #1128 which might have a galactic origin. Additional photometry is required to determine this.

One of the variables (#283) is a carbon star, see Fig. 3 (click here). Details about the spectroscopic observations and the spectral classification of the Miras and the semiregular variables will be given in a forthcoming paper (in preparation). This star appears to be comparable with the carbon stars found in other dwarf galaxies (Aaronson et al. 1983; Azzopardi et al. 1985 & 1986) and some of the carbon stars found by Azzopardi et al. (1991). Unfortunately, the spectrum of variable #283 did not include the sodium D doublet and it is not clear if this star is comparable with those found in the "bulge" or the low-metallicity objects in the SMC and the dwarf galaxies. The "bulge" carbon stars have been a mystery (Lequeux 1990; Tyson & Rich 1991; Westerlund et al. 1991), because they are about tex2html_wrap_inline1000 in bolometric luminosity too faint to be regarded as genuine AGB stars, if located inside the metal-rich bulge. But if some or all of them are located in the dwarf galaxy, just like variable #283, there is no need for a metal-rich origin. They are in that case just ordinary metal-poor to intermediate metallicity carbon stars.

  figure287
Figure 3: Medium resolution spectrum smoothed to 2.6Å/pixel for variable star #283 (C 3,2), which has a period P = 137.39 days (Wesselink 1987)

Membership of the dwarf galaxy has important consequences. It implies that the carbon stars are at least younger than approximately 4 Gyr (Marigo et al. 1996 and references cited therein). It indicates that at least 2 major epochs of star formation occurred in the dwarf galaxy, just like the recurrent star formation epochs in the Carina dwarf spheroidal (Schmecker-Hane et al. 1996). It possibly traces the tidal star formation tail due to its passage through our Galaxy. This tail extends at least from tex2html_wrap_inline1004 to tex2html_wrap_inline1006, which is far more larger than previously thought. This tail most likely indicates that the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy has passed the galactic plane not so long ago. It would explain the rather blue colours and might also explain the large velocity dispersion of the carbon stars obtained by Tyson & Rich (1991).

Alksnis (1990) showed that the majority of the carbon stars are SRa-type long period variables. A detailed monitoring of the Azzopardi et al. (1991) carbon stars is required to determine if they are variable and to determine their periods. Together with the period-luminosity relation their membership to the dwarf galaxy can be secured. This can be compared with the properties of the carbon stars studied by Whitelock et al. (1996). Their study indicates the presence of two different groups. One group with tex2html_wrap_inline1008 is comparable with the carbon stars from Azzopardi et al. (1991), while another group has significantly redder colours tex2html_wrap_inline1010. The two groups could be an indication for two different star formation epochs from recent passages through the galactic plane.

AGB stars, like the carbon stars, are the progenitors of planetary nebulae (PN). Along the trail of the Azzopardi et al. (1991) carbon stars one would expect to find long period variables and PNs. The question arises if the PNs found at low galactic latitude with velocities near to that of the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy (Zijlstra & Walsh 1996) should be considered as true bulge members? Membership of the dwarf galaxy would support the proposition that some or all of the Azzopardi et al. carbon stars do indeed trace the tidal tail.

Acknowledgements

The research of MS is supported by a grant from the Austrian Science Fund under project number P9638-AST and S7308. YKN is supported by HCM grant CHRX-CT94-0627 from the European Community.


next previous
Up: Field #3 of

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)
web@ed-phys.fr