next previous
Up: An abundance analysis

4. Results and discussion

4.1. The comparison stars

The chemical analyses of the program stars were carried out relative to the comparison stars tex2html_wrap_inline1707 (G8IIIab) and Procyon (F5IV-V). tex2html_wrap_inline1709 was chosen as a primary comparison standard, because the chemical composition of this star has been analyzed in detail relative to the Sun (see, for example, Cayrel & Cayrel 1963; Tomkin & Lambert 1986). The atmospheric composition of tex2html_wrap_inline1711 corresponds to the solar one within the probable error of determination and no systematic enrichment in heavy-element abundance can be detected. We adopted the following atmospheric parameters (tex2html_wrap_inline1713, tex2html_wrap_inline1715, tex2html_wrap_inline1717), and model metal abundance [A] for tex2html_wrap_inline1721: 5130 K, 3.0, tex2html_wrap_inline1723, 0.0. These parameters agree in general with those obtained by Tomkin & Lambert (1986) and McWilliam (1990). For Procyon, we have adopted tex2html_wrap_inline1725, tex2html_wrap_inline1727, tex2html_wrap_inline1729, which is the best value according to the compilation of Steffen (1985).

4.2. Stellar parameters

The final adopted atmospheric parameters (effective temperature, surface gravity, microturbulence velocity) and model metal abundances for the program stars are listed in Table 2 (click here). Some of the stars have previously published parameter determinations. We compared our results with those obtained by Edvardsson et al. (1993) for tex2html_wrap_inline1731, and by McWilliam (1990) for 6 Per, 5 Tau, 6 Boo, tex2html_wrap_inline1733, HR 6388, HR 6868, and HR 7180. We obtained an excellent agreement between our results and results obtained by Edvardsson et al. (1993) for tex2html_wrap_inline1735, 6068 K, tex2html_wrap_inline1737, tex2html_wrap_inline1739. The comparison between our results and those of McWilliam (1990) shows a good agreement for temperature (tex2html_wrap_inline1741 for 16 Per, 5 Tau, tex2html_wrap_inline1743, HR 6388, HR 6860, HR 7180), for gravity (tex2html_wrap_inline1745 for 5 Tau, 6 Boo, tex2html_wrap_inline1747), and for microturbulent velocity (tex2html_wrap_inline1749 for 5 Tau, 6 Boo, HR 6388, HR 6860, HR 7180). But for some stars there are disagreements between our results and those obtained by McWilliam (1990) for gravity (6 Per, HD 168532, HR 7180), turbulent velocity (6 Per), and effective temperature (6 Boo). Our gravity values for these three stars are lower than those derived by McWilliam (1990), who estimated gravity using the relation between temperature, mass, luminosity, and gravity.

We checked our spectroscopic gravities for dwarfs with those derived using temperature-mass-luminosity relation and good trigonometric parallaxes (tex2html_wrap_inline1751 for tex2html_wrap_inline1753, tex2html_wrap_inline1755 for HR 3579, tex2html_wrap_inline1757 for tex2html_wrap_inline1759). There is an excellent agreement for tex2html_wrap_inline1761, but for HR 3579 and tex2html_wrap_inline1763 spectroscopic gravities are somewhat lower than those obtained from parallaxes. The atmospheric parameters of binaries are found to be typical of single main-sequence or giant stars, respectively.

4.3. The relative abundances

The mean differential abundances of the light and iron group elements (Na, Mg, Si, Ca, Sc, Ti, V, Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu), obtained using neutral or ionized lines, and the mean abundances of the s-process elements (Y, Zr, Ba, La, Ce, Nd) for all program stars are given in Table 3 (click here), along with the standard deviations of averaged abundances estimated from individual lines, and the number of lines used in the analysis. In Table 4 (click here) the mean abundances of separate elements for all stars are given. In the literature there are previous abundance determinations available for some of the stars. We have found a generally good agreement (Fig. 8 (click here)) for the light and iron-peak elements, as well as for barium when we compare our results for tex2html_wrap_inline1771 to the results of Edvardsson et al. (1993). In the following we shall comment on some details of the abundance distributions.

  table343
Table 3: The averaged differential abundances of light and iron group elements, obtained from neutral (XI) and ionized (XII) lines, and of s-process elements for the program stars along with the standard deviation, and the number of lines. The last column indicate the Ba abundance scaled to the metallicity

  table348
Table 4: The mean differential abundances [X] of separate elements for all program stars, along with the standard deviation of abundances estimated from individual lines, and the number of lines used in the analysis

 table355
Table 4: continued

  figure359
Figure 8: The comparison of abundance determinations of this paper and others for tex2html_wrap_inline1775

4.3.1. Carbon and oxygen

Carbon abundances have been derived for 11 of the program stars using the neutral carbon line at tex2html_wrap_inline1787 or at tex2html_wrap_inline1789. Carbon appears to be enhanced only for HR 6860 and, possibly, slightly for HR 7180. We have found no indication of carbon processing from any other program star. The oxygen abundance has been derived only for 7 stars using the forbidden oxygen line at tex2html_wrap_inline1791. The analysis shows that oxygen may be slightly (tex2html_wrap_inline1793) overabundant in the atmospheres of six stars.

4.3.2. Na to Si and iron group elements

No significant deviations from the solar abundance pattern can be found among these elements. The mean abundance for 17 single lined binaries relative to the standards is tex2html_wrap_inline1795 with typical standard deviation tex2html_wrap_inline1797. Only the abundance of Mn shows a larger dispersion from star to star in the sample: tex2html_wrap_inline1799.

4.3.3. Heavy elements (Y to Eu)

The seven elements heavier than iron are traditionally identified with synthesis by the neutron capture s-process. The main sample of spectroscopic binaries includes seventeen stars (tex2html_wrap_inline1801, 6 Per, 5 Tau, HR 3579, HR 5053, 6 Boo, tex2html_wrap_inline1803, HR 6388, DR Dra, HD 166478, HR 6860, HD 170737, FN Aql, HR 7180, HD 179558, HD 181602, HD 204934). Detailed differential abundance analysis relative to the standard stars shows that no one from these barium star like binaries have a significant enhancement (tex2html_wrap_inline1805) of averaged s-process elements scaled to iron group elements (see Tables 2 (click here) and 3 (click here)). Taken together the mean abundance of these elements is solar. Only giant 5 Tau (K0II-III, tex2html_wrap_inline1807) and supergiant FN Aql (F8Ib, tex2html_wrap_inline1809) show a mild enhancement (tex2html_wrap_inline1811) of s-process elements, however, overabundance of heavy elements in these stars are small, different from those of certain BaII stars with similar orbital periods (Zacs 1994). Although direct evidence for WD companion has been confirmed only in the case of DR Dra, at least some of the analyzed systems contain a WD companion, because according to Jorissen & Boffin (1992) unevolved systems never populate the right-bottom corner on the (tex2html_wrap_inline1813) plane (Fig. 9 (click here)). Part of the analyzed single-lined primaries fulfill three constraints: 1) tex2html_wrap_inline1815, (2) tex2html_wrap_inline1817, and (3) tex2html_wrap_inline1819, where tex2html_wrap_inline1821 is the maximum eccentricity observed at period P among barium systems (Jorissen & Boffin 1992). Constraint (1) ensure that the considered systems followed the same binary evolution as barium stars. Constraint (2) allows to get rid of systems with massive main sequence companions, while systems not fulfilling constraint (3) are likely unevolved and therefore contain a main sequence rather than a WD companion. Thus the detailed abundance analyses show that the presence of WD companions in barium stars-like binaries is not sufficient to produce a strong barium star. This conclusion confirmed especially the chemical composition of DR Dra (K0III, tex2html_wrap_inline1825) with a directly confirmed WD companion from IUE spectra (Fekel & Simon 1985).

  figure376
Figure 9: Diagram (tex2html_wrap_inline1827) for single-lined spectroscopic binaries with barium star like orbital elements. Filled circles (tex2html_wrap_inline1829): barium stars from Jorissen & Boffin (1992); open circles (tex2html_wrap_inline1831): giants showing normal barium abundance; crossed circles (tex2html_wrap_inline1833): giants showing mild barium enhancement; squares (tex2html_wrap_inline1835): dwarfs

At the same time five of the analyzed giants (5 Tau, DR Dra, HD 166478, HD 168532, HD 176524) show a mild enhancement (tex2html_wrap_inline1837) of the s-process element barium (see Table 3 (click here)). Although the barium abundance is based only on three BaII lines, a careful analysis shows that this effect has not a methodical nature, because:
1) The Ba II lines have a medium intensity (tex2html_wrap_inline1839);
2) The standard deviation of barium abundances obtained from three BaII lines does not exceed usually 0.1 dex (0.08 for 5 Tau, 0.03 for DR Dra, 0.06 for HR 6860, and 0.09 for HR 7180);
3) Non-LTE effects in BaII lines are small (Mashonkina & Zacs 1996) and our differential line by line analysis relative to the similar standard canceled possible slight (tex2html_wrap_inline1841) non-LTE deviations;
4) Some of the analyzed BaII star like giants (with similar atmospheric structure) show a normal barium abundance.

This conclusion support the location of the barium enhanced binaries on the (e, tex2html_wrap_inline1845) plane (see Fig. 9 (click here)). As can be seen, barium enhanced giants occupy a place on the diagram similar to BaII stars. In the right-bottom corner only dwarfs and one giant HR 5053 (K0III, tex2html_wrap_inline1847) from our program stars have a normal barium abundance. However, the unseen companion of HR 5053 is a G-dwarf (f(M)=0.47, Batten et al. 1989). We included this star in the observations program to test the possible influence (due to tidal mixing, as has been sometimes suggested) of a main sequence companion on the atmospheric structure (chemical composition) of the primary (giant) star in BaII star like systems. Since the atmosphere of HR 5053 does not show any peculiarities of chemical composition we concluded that the main sequence companion does not have a significant influence on the internal structure of the primary star. On the other hand, on the (e, tex2html_wrap_inline1853) plane outside the region occupied by barium star we do not find any peculiar (barium enhanced) primary in our sample of barium stars like binaries. Therefore, we come to the conclusion that a mild barium enhancement in five giants is, presumably, a result of mass transfer from the companion during its late phases of evolution. Thus it seems likely that all red giant spectroscopic binaries (primaries) in barium star like systems with WD secondaries have chemical peculiarities of barium (s-process elements). The degree of chemical peculiarities of the primary depends, apparently, on the efficiency of mass transfer in a specific binary system.

We certainly do not apply this conclusion to the supergiant FN Aql because:
1) The BaII lines in the spectra of this star are substantially stronger than for giants (269 mÅ for BaII line at tex2html_wrap_inline1855);
2) The atmospheric structure of supergiants is significantly different from the standard giant, therefore, differential analysis might not cancel possible (greater) non-LTE effects.

Our observational program includes also two mild barium stars HD 119185 (Ba 1.0) and HD 130255 (Ba 1.0) from Jorissen's (1994) list, that did not show radial velocity (RV) variations. We obtained tex2html_wrap_inline1857 for HD 130255 and tex2html_wrap_inline1859 for HD 119185. The significant enhancement of s-process elements is shown by both stars. However, we would like to note that due to the higher dispersion of the chemical abundances obtained from different lines, the error of the derived atmospheric parameters and abundances for HD 130255 is higher than for other program stars. The s-process enhancement of RV non-variable barium stars confirms a previous conclusion (Zacs 1994) that these barium stars, probably, have either velocity variations below the limit of detection (very long orbital period), or high inclined orbital planes.

Acknowledgements

We are indebted to referee Prof. E. Böhm-Vitense for her constructive comments on the paper. This research was supported in part by the ESO C&EE Programme (Grant No. B-01-012) and by the Russian Foundation of Fundamental researches (RFFI grant No. 95-02-04276).


next previous
Up: An abundance analysis

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)
web@ed-phys.fr