next previous
Up: The orbit of

5. Processing results

5.1. Observation residuals

Table 3 (click here) gives the postfit statistics for the observed-minus-computed residuals for the Earthbased observations grouped by data set. For each set the table indicates the type of observations and the number used versus the total number available. The statistics include the sample mean (tex2html_wrap_inline2285) of the residuals, the standard deviation (tex2html_wrap_inline2287) about the mean, and the root-mean-square (rms). The Arequipa, the 1904 Yerkes, and the USNO observations were not fit; however, statistics for them are included. To arrive at the statistics for the unused observations, we deleted all residuals greater than 30'' and applied a 3tex2html_wrap_inline2287 rejection criterion to the remainder.

   

Set Year Observer/Source Type No. tex2html_wrap_inline2285tex2html_wrap_inline2287 rmswrms No. tex2html_wrap_inline2285tex2html_wrap_inline2287 rmswrms
1 1898 Pickering P0 7/7-0tex2html_wrap318329 4tex2html_wrap_inline225116 3tex2html_wrap_inline225186 7/7 2tex2html_wrap318363 3tex2html_wrap_inline225176 4tex2html_wrap_inline225136
2 1899 Pickering P0 0/3 0/3
3 1900 Pickering P0 20/26 8tex2html_wrap318331 6tex2html_wrap_inline225124 10tex2html_wrap_inline22513 20/26 3tex2html_wrap318316 5tex2html_wrap_inline225187 6tex2html_wrap_inline225153
4 1902 Pickering P0 2/6-11tex2html_wrap31834 19tex2html_wrap_inline22518 18tex2html_wrap_inline22510 2/6-3tex2html_wrap318315 0tex2html_wrap_inline225131 3tex2html_wrap_inline225116
5 1904 Pickering P2 26/28 6tex2html_wrap318355 4tex2html_wrap_inline225155 7tex2html_wrap_inline225192 26/28-3tex2html_wrap318368 7tex2html_wrap_inline225142 8tex2html_wrap_inline225115
6 1904 Barnard V0 1/2 10tex2html_wrap31833 0tex2html_wrap_inline225100 10tex2html_wrap_inline22513 1/2-3tex2html_wrap318390 0tex2html_wrap_inline225100 3tex2html_wrap_inline225190
7 1904 Perrine P0 5/6 0tex2html_wrap318347 0tex2html_wrap_inline225199 1tex2html_wrap_inline225101 1.01 5/6-0tex2html_wrap318301 0tex2html_wrap_inline225158 0tex2html_wrap_inline225152 0.95
8 1905 Pickering P2 11/17-2tex2html_wrap318343 12tex2html_wrap_inline22511 11tex2html_wrap_inline22518 11/17-4tex2html_wrap318349 14tex2html_wrap_inline22512 14tex2html_wrap_inline22512
9 1905 Albrecht P0 11/11-1tex2html_wrap318303 0tex2html_wrap_inline225194 1tex2html_wrap_inline225136 1.01 11/11 1tex2html_wrap318352 1tex2html_wrap_inline225172 2tex2html_wrap_inline225124 0.99
10 1906 Perrine P0 8/8 0tex2html_wrap318308 1tex2html_wrap_inline225112 1tex2html_wrap_inline225105 0.96 8/8 0tex2html_wrap318354 0tex2html_wrap_inline225182 0tex2html_wrap_inline225194 0.94
11 1906 Pickering P2 6/6 4tex2html_wrap318306 3tex2html_wrap_inline225170 5tex2html_wrap_inline225128 6/6-5tex2html_wrap318326 9tex2html_wrap_inline225171 10tex2html_wrap_inline22513
12 1906 Pickering P2 9/9-1tex2html_wrap318393 8tex2html_wrap_inline225105 7tex2html_wrap_inline225183 9/9-3tex2html_wrap318345 5tex2html_wrap_inline225171 6tex2html_wrap_inline225139
13 1906 Barnard V0 11/12-2tex2html_wrap318326 4tex2html_wrap_inline225125 4tex2html_wrap_inline225164 1.01 12/12-0tex2html_wrap318363 1tex2html_wrap_inline225152 1tex2html_wrap_inline225158 0.99
14 1907 Christie P0 16/16 0tex2html_wrap318320 0tex2html_wrap_inline225170 0tex2html_wrap_inline225171 1.01 16/16 0tex2html_wrap318318 0tex2html_wrap_inline225177 0tex2html_wrap_inline225176 0.96
15 1908 Perrine P0 2/2 1tex2html_wrap318391 0tex2html_wrap_inline225173 1tex2html_wrap_inline225198 0.99 2/2-0tex2html_wrap318380 0tex2html_wrap_inline225103 0tex2html_wrap_inline225180 1.01
16 1908 Christie P0 22/23 0tex2html_wrap318320 0tex2html_wrap_inline225163 0tex2html_wrap_inline225165 0.99 22/23 0tex2html_wrap318304 0tex2html_wrap_inline225172 0tex2html_wrap_inline225171 1.01
17 1909 Christie P0 12/12 0tex2html_wrap318330 1tex2html_wrap_inline225107 1tex2html_wrap_inline225107 1.02 12/12-0tex2html_wrap318304 0tex2html_wrap_inline225198 0tex2html_wrap_inline225194 0.99
18 1910 Christie P0 7/7-0tex2html_wrap318301 1tex2html_wrap_inline225140 1tex2html_wrap_inline225129 0.99 7/7 0tex2html_wrap318340 0tex2html_wrap_inline225168 0tex2html_wrap_inline225175 1.00
19 1912 Barnard V0 12/12 1tex2html_wrap318368 1tex2html_wrap_inline225120 2tex2html_wrap_inline225104 1.02 7/7-0tex2html_wrap318363 1tex2html_wrap_inline225124 1tex2html_wrap_inline225130 1.00
20 1913 Barnard V0 5/5 0tex2html_wrap318384 0tex2html_wrap_inline225166 1tex2html_wrap_inline225102 0.93 3/3-1tex2html_wrap318308 0tex2html_wrap_inline225132 1tex2html_wrap_inline225111 1.01
21 1922 VanBiesbroeck P0 4/5 3tex2html_wrap318341 0tex2html_wrap_inline225172 3tex2html_wrap_inline225147 0.99 4/5-1tex2html_wrap318345 1tex2html_wrap_inline225126 1tex2html_wrap_inline225182 0.98
22 1940 Nicholson P0 1/1-0tex2html_wrap318324 0tex2html_wrap_inline225100 0tex2html_wrap_inline225124 0.49 1/1 0tex2html_wrap318300 0tex2html_wrap_inline225100 0tex2html_wrap_inline225100 0.01
23 1942 VanBiesbroeck P0 7/8 1tex2html_wrap318366 0tex2html_wrap_inline225141 1tex2html_wrap_inline225170 0.97 7/8-0tex2html_wrap318324 0tex2html_wrap_inline225125 0tex2html_wrap_inline225134 0.67
24 1952 Bobone P0 7/7-0tex2html_wrap318302 1tex2html_wrap_inline225102 0tex2html_wrap_inline225195 1.00 7/7 0tex2html_wrap318302 0tex2html_wrap_inline225133 0tex2html_wrap_inline225131 0.61
25 1955 VanBiesbroeck P0 8/11 1tex2html_wrap318309 0tex2html_wrap_inline225173 1tex2html_wrap_inline225129 0.96 8/11 0tex2html_wrap318345 0tex2html_wrap_inline225148 0tex2html_wrap_inline225163 0.98
26 1955 VanBiesbroeck P0 3/3 2tex2html_wrap318313 0tex2html_wrap_inline225156 2tex2html_wrap_inline225118 0.97 3/3 0tex2html_wrap318379 0tex2html_wrap_inline225188 1tex2html_wrap_inline225107 1.02
27 1957 VanBiesbroeck P0 8/8 0tex2html_wrap318334 0tex2html_wrap_inline225169 0tex2html_wrap_inline225173 0.97 8/8 1tex2html_wrap318326 0tex2html_wrap_inline225170 1tex2html_wrap_inline225142 0.98
28 1960 Roemer P0 2/2 0tex2html_wrap318390 0tex2html_wrap_inline225116 0tex2html_wrap_inline225191 1.01 2/2 0tex2html_wrap318340 0tex2html_wrap_inline225117 0tex2html_wrap_inline225142 0.84
29 1968 Chernykh P0 2/2 0tex2html_wrap318373 1tex2html_wrap_inline225191 1tex2html_wrap_inline225153 0.99 2/2-1tex2html_wrap318316 0tex2html_wrap_inline225151 1tex2html_wrap_inline225122 0.97
30 1969 VanBiesbroeck P0 1/3 1tex2html_wrap318352 0tex2html_wrap_inline225100 1tex2html_wrap_inline225152 0.98 1/3 0tex2html_wrap318338 0tex2html_wrap_inline225100 0tex2html_wrap_inline225138 0.77
31 1969 VanBiesbroeck P0 1/1-0tex2html_wrap318313 0tex2html_wrap_inline225100 0tex2html_wrap_inline225113 0.26 1/1 0tex2html_wrap318385 0tex2html_wrap_inline225100 0tex2html_wrap_inline225185 1.00
32 1975 Mulholland P1 4/5-0tex2html_wrap318326 0tex2html_wrap_inline225127 0tex2html_wrap_inline225135 0.99 4/5-0tex2html_wrap318306 0tex2html_wrap_inline225107 0tex2html_wrap_inline225109 0.45
P0 2/3-0tex2html_wrap318328 0tex2html_wrap_inline225181 0tex2html_wrap_inline225164 0.98 2/3-0tex2html_wrap318316 0tex2html_wrap_inline225119 0tex2html_wrap_inline225121 0.42
33 1981 Bowell P1 8/10 1tex2html_wrap318308 0tex2html_wrap_inline225166 1tex2html_wrap_inline225124 0.99 8/10-0tex2html_wrap318357 0tex2html_wrap_inline225185 0tex2html_wrap_inline225198 0.98
P0 2/2-0tex2html_wrap318341 0tex2html_wrap_inline225157 0tex2html_wrap_inline225158 0.96 2/2-1tex2html_wrap318303 0tex2html_wrap_inline225120 1tex2html_wrap_inline225104 0.99
34 1981 Debehogne P1 20/21 0tex2html_wrap318344 0tex2html_wrap_inline225143 0tex2html_wrap_inline225161 0.94 20/21 0tex2html_wrap318300 0tex2html_wrap_inline225158 0tex2html_wrap_inline225157 0.95
35 1982 Bowell P1 2/2-0tex2html_wrap318329 0tex2html_wrap_inline225163 0tex2html_wrap_inline225153 0.96 2/2-0tex2html_wrap318395 1tex2html_wrap_inline225114 1tex2html_wrap_inline225125 1.00
36 1982 Debehogne P1 18/21-0tex2html_wrap318334 0tex2html_wrap_inline225148 0tex2html_wrap_inline225158 0.96 18/21-0tex2html_wrap318308 0tex2html_wrap_inline225160 0tex2html_wrap_inline225159 0.98
37 1992 Rohde P0 22/22 1tex2html_wrap318389 0tex2html_wrap_inline225136 1tex2html_wrap_inline225193 22/22-0tex2html_wrap318326 0tex2html_wrap_inline225123 0tex2html_wrap_inline225134
38 1992 Whipple P0 12/12-0tex2html_wrap318310 0tex2html_wrap_inline225125 0tex2html_wrap_inline225126 0.52 12/12-0tex2html_wrap318306 0tex2html_wrap_inline225150 0tex2html_wrap_inline225149 0.97
39 1993 Rohde P0 9/9 0tex2html_wrap318315 0tex2html_wrap_inline225126 0tex2html_wrap_inline225128 9/9-1tex2html_wrap318311 0tex2html_wrap_inline225113 1tex2html_wrap_inline225112
40 1994 Whipple P0 2/2-0tex2html_wrap318315 0tex2html_wrap_inline225172 0tex2html_wrap_inline225153 1.07 2/2-0tex2html_wrap318340 0tex2html_wrap_inline225134 0tex2html_wrap_inline225147 0.93
41 1996 Whipple C0 21/21-0tex2html_wrap318337 0tex2html_wrap_inline225121 0tex2html_wrap_inline225142 1.06 21/21 0tex2html_wrap318311 0tex2html_wrap_inline225129 0tex2html_wrap_inline225130 0.75

Table 3: Astrometric observation residual statistics. The column entitled "Type'' gives the observation type: the letter V denotes visual, P denotes photographic, and C denotes CCD. The digit gives measurement type: 0 - absolute tex2html_wrap_inline2265 and tex2html_wrap_inline2269; 1 - tex2html_wrap_inline2267 and tex2html_wrap_inline2271; 2 - angular separation and tex2html_wrap_inline2271. The column entitled "No.'' gives the number of observations included in the solution/number of available observations, tex2html_wrap_inline2285 denotes the sample mean, tex2html_wrap_inline2287 denotes the standard deviation about the mean, rms denotes the root-mean-square, and wrms denotes the root-mean-square of the weighted residuals

The mean for each set gives an indication of systematic errors. For example, a large mean in the right ascension residuals could be attributed to an equinox offset. The standard deviation measures the scatter of the residuals about the mean and characterizes the noise level of the observations, and the root-mean-square represents the overall quality of the fit. Also included is the weighted root-mean-square (wrms), i.e., the rms of the residuals multiplied by their weights. The wrms measures the quality of the fit relative to the assumed accuracy of the observations. The weights can be recovered from the ratio of the wrms to the rms.

Overall, the orbit fits the Earthbased observations at the 1tex2html_wrap_inline225119 level. The rms for the "old'' (pre-1940) sets is 1tex2html_wrap_inline225148 and for the "modern'' (post-1940) sets is 0tex2html_wrap_inline225178. Among the sets used, the poorest fit is to Barnard's 1906 micrometer measures, and the best fits are to Whipple's 1992 photographic data, Whipple's 1996 CCD data, and Mulholland's 1975 relative photographic data. Also, Nicholson's isolated 1940 observation has a surprisingly small residual. Figure 1 (click here) displays the right ascension residuals for the observations that were fit, and Fig. 2 (click here) displays the declination residuals. The figures give an indication of the time distribution of the observations and the overall quality of the fit. Considerable scatter is evident as well as some suggestion of systematic errors.

  figure324
Figure 1: Right ascension residuals

  figure331
Figure 2: Declination residuals

The residuals for the Voyager imaging data range in magnitude from 7 to 235 km; the rms for all eight is 104 km.

The rms for residuals of the Saturn observations from Greenwich are 0tex2html_wrap_inline225142 and 0tex2html_wrap_inline225128 in right ascension and declination, respectively. Table 4 (click here) gives the biases found for each observation set.

   

Year Rt. Asc. Dec.
1907 2tex2html_wrap_inline225188 0tex2html_wrap_inline225156
1908 1tex2html_wrap_inline225189 0tex2html_wrap_inline225157
1909 1tex2html_wrap_inline225162 -0tex2html_wrap_inline225120
1910 0tex2html_wrap_inline225178 0tex2html_wrap_inline225128

Table 4: Corrections to the mean equator of epoch Greenwich observations

5.2. Epoch state vector

The epoch state vector obtained from the fit appears in Table 5 (click here), and the Saturnian system dynamical constants needed for the integration appear in Table 6 (click here). Two state vectors are provided: the first is a from a fit which used the complete dynamical model in post-1966 integration; the second is from a fit which used the simplified model. The simplified model was used in the pre-1966 integration in both cases. The root-mean-square of the differences between the two models over the time period 1900 to 2013 are 7.4 km in the radial direction, 50.5 km in the in-orbit direction, and 17.2 km in the out-of-plane direction.

As an aid to those wishing to reproduce the integration, Table 7 (click here) contains the state vector for the simplified model at the end of the integration.

   

Component Position (km) Velocity (km/s)
complete model
x -12049661.9430915500 -0.5851428400610138
y -2354538.7543550990 1.5137695265625980
z 298437.1979645121 0.7872087168834739
simplified model
x -12049676.2666544100 -0.5851329248090125
y -2354463.3515782810 1.5137727228222640
z 298451.8787930112 0.7872099536417393

Table 5: Barycentric state vector at Julian ephemeris date 2439440.50 (1966 Nov. 11.0) referred to the Earth mean equator and equinox of J2000

   

Name ValueUnits
Saturn system GM 37940629.764 km3/s2
Mimas GM 2.500 km3/s2
Enceladus GM 4.900 km3/s2
Tethys GM 41.808 km3/s2
Dione GM 73.156 km3/s2
Rhea GM 154.000 km3/s2
Titan GM 8978.200 km3/s2
Iapetus GM 106.000 km3/s2
Saturn radius 60330.0 km
Saturn J2 162.98tex2html_wrap_inline2233
Saturn Jtex2html_wrap_inline3789 213.74tex2html_wrap_inline2233
Saturn J4 -9.15tex2html_wrap_inline2233
Saturn J6 1.03tex2html_wrap_inline2233
Saturn pole right ascension 40.58 deg
Saturn pole declination 83.54 deg

Table 6: Saturnian system dynamical constants. These are the constants currently being used in the major Saturnian satellite ephemerides, see Jacobson (1996b)

   

Component Position (km) Velocity (km/s)
x -10039870.733667480 -1.2513317541446060
y -6590801.243860413 1.1142229491687150
z -2664829.368414232 0.6536617058933396

Table 7: Barycentric state vector for the simplified model at Julian ephemeris date 2414640.5 (1898 Dec. 17.0) referred to the Earth mean equator and equinox of J2000

5.3. Mean elements

Because an integrated orbit in terms of cartesian coordinates is difficult to interpret geometrically, an alternative representation in the form of mean orbital elements is often useful. Table 8 (click here) provides mean elements derived by fitting a precessing ellipse model to the integration over the period 1900 to 2013. The reference plane is the Phoebe Laplacian plane, the plane on which the orbit precesses almost uniformly. The orientation angles for the Laplacian plane pole are with respect to the Earth mean equator and equinox of J2000 system; the tilt of the plane off the Saturn equator is 26tex2html_wrap_inline3823183. The epoch mean longitude tex2html_wrap_inline3825, longitude of periapsis tex2html_wrap_inline3827, and longitude of the ascending node tex2html_wrap_inline3829, are measured from the ascending node of the Laplacian plane on the Earth mean equator of J2000. The elements may be used as replacements for those provided by Rohde & Sinclair (1992) for computing an approximate orbit. We should comment that the latter element set is referred to the ecliptic and equinox of 1950.0, hence the angular elements cannot be compared directly with ours. The root-mean-square of the differences between the integrated and the approximate orbits over the 1900 to 2013 period are 127236 km in the radial direction, 244253 km in the in-orbit direction, and 15438 km in the out-of-plane direction. These differences give an indication of the magnitude of the periodic perturbations (mostly due to the Sun) affecting the orbit.

   

Element Value Units
semi-major axis 12944346 km
eccentricity 0.16435
inclination 174.751 deg
tex2html_wrap_inline3825 390.742 deg
tex2html_wrap_inline3827 203.958 deg
tex2html_wrap_inline3829 233.037 deg
orbital period 548.2122790 days
tex2html_wrap_inline3837 1.19141 deg/yr
tex2html_wrap_inline3839 0.45631 deg/yr
Laplacian plane pole 275.631 deg
right ascension
Laplacian plane pole 68.031 deg
declination

Table 8: Planetocentric mean orbital elements at Julian ephemeris date 2447892.5 referred to Phoebe's Laplacian plane


next previous
Up: The orbit of

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)