next previous
Up: A photometric catalogue

2. The photographic plate data

2.1. Method for obtaining the catalogue

We decided to obtain a photometric catalogue of the galaxies in the direction of the Abell 85 cluster of galaxies by first processing the field 681 in the SRC-J Schmidt atlas. This blue glass copy plate (IIIaJ+GG385) was investigated with the MAMA (Machine à Mesurer pour l'Astronomie) facility located at the Centre d'Analyse des Images at the Observatoire de Paris and operated by CNRS/INSU (Institut National des Sciences de l'Univers). In order to also get information on the neighbouring galaxy distribution, the central tex2html_wrap_inline1067 area has been searched for objects using the on-line mode with the 10 tex2html_wrap_inline1069 step size available at that time. The involved algorithmic steps are well-known. They can be summarized as follows: first a local background estimate and its variance are computed from pixel values inside a 256 tex2html_wrap_inline1071 256 window, then pixels with a number of counts higher than the background value plus three times the variance are flagged, which leads to define an object as a set of connected flagged pixels; an overlapping zone of 512 pixels is used in both directions for each individual scan. Although this method may appear rather crude, its efficiency is nevertheless quite high for properly detecting and measuring simple and isolated objects smaller than the background scale. The region where ABCG 85 is located is not crowded by stellar images (tex2html_wrap_inline1073), so that most of the objects larger than a few pixels can indeed be detected this way. The result was a list of more than 105 objects distributed over the tex2html_wrap_inline1077 25 square degrees of the field bounded by tex2html_wrap_inline1079 and tex2html_wrap_inline1081 (equinox 2000.0, as hereafter), with their coordinates, their shape parameters (area, elliptical modelling) and two flux descriptors (peak density, sum of background-subtracted pixel values).

The astrometric reduction of the whole catalogue was performed with respect to 91 stars of the PPM star catalogue (Roeser & Bastian 1991) spread over the field, using a 3tex2html_wrap_inline1083-order polynomial fitting. The residuals of the fit yielding the instrumental constants were smaller than 0.25 arcsecond and the astrometry of our catalogue indeed appears to be very good, as confirmed by our multi-object fibre spectroscopy where the galaxies were always found to be very close (< 2.0 arcsec, i.e. 3 pixels) to the expected positions.

Since the required CCD observations were not available at that time, a preliminary photometric calibration of these photographic data has been done using galaxies with known total blue magnitude. The magnitude of stars is certainly much easier to define, but such high-surface brightness objects suffer from severe saturation effects on Schmidt plates when they are bright enough to be included in available photometric catalogues. So, 83 galaxies were selected from the Lyon Extragalactic Database (LEDA) in order to compare their magnitude to their measured blue flux. A small region around each of these objects was scanned and this image has been used: i) to identify the object among its neighbours within the coordinate list and ii) to assess the quality of the flux value stored in the on-line catalogue with respect to close, overlapping or merged objects. The 74 remaining undisturbed objects identified with no ambiguity came from eight different catalogues in the literature. Whatever the intrinsic uncertainties about the integrated MAMA fluxes are, systematic effects were found with respect to the parent catalogue in a flux versus magnitude plot, as well as discrepancies for some objects between the LEDA and the Centre de Données Astronomiques de Strasbourg (CDS) databases. Consequently, three catalogues including 12 objects were removed and the LEDA magnitude of 5 objects was replaced by a CDS value which seems in better agreement with their aspect and with the overall trend when compared to similar objects. Later, 7 objects far from the overall trend were discarded. These successive rejections resulted in a set of 55 objects distributed over a six magnitude range. The magnitude zero-point for our photographic catalogue was obtained by plotting the flux of these objects against their expected magnitude. A rms scatter of 0.34 mag was computed around the linear fit.

2.2. Classification of the objects

Most of the diffuse objects included in our main catalogue were automatically selected according to their lower surface brightness when compared to stars. As usual for glass copies of survey plates, the discrimination power of this brightness criterion drops sharply for objects fainter than approximately 19tex2html_wrap_inline1087 magnitude, and so does the completeness of the resulting catalogue if no contamination is allowed for. The number of galaxy candidates brighter than this limit within the investigated area appeared, however, to be already large enough to get a much better view of the bright galaxy distribution than using the deeper but very incomplete catalogue published by Murphy (1984). Moreover, including faintest objects was not necessary for the redshift survey of the Abell 85 cluster of galaxies we were planning (see Durret et al. 1997). Hence, no attempt was done to reach a fainter completeness limit. Nonetheless, in order to select galaxies, the decision curve which has been computed in the Flux vs. Area parameter space was fitted to the data so that some objects identified by Murphy from CCD frames as faint galaxies were also classified as galaxies by us. Next, a further test based on the elongation was performed in order to reject linear plate flaws or artefacts, as well as to pick bright elongated galaxies first classified as stars due to strong saturation effects. Finally, spurious detections occuring around very bright stars (area greater than 103 pixels) due to a wrong estimate of the local background were tentatively removed by checking their location with respect to these bright objects. In this way, a list of more than 25000 galaxy candidates over the 25 square degrees of our SRC-J 681 blue field was obtained.

  figure238
Figure 1: Spatial distribution of the 11862 galaxies brighter than tex2html_wrap_inline1091 in the SRC-J 681 field. The large overdensities are indicated by superimposed isopleths from a density map computed by the method introduced by Dressler (1980) with N=50; eleven isopleths are drawn from 850 to 2850 galaxies/square degree

The distribution of these galaxies is displayed in Fig. 1 (click here) for objects brighter than tex2html_wrap_inline1091. The Abell 85 cluster is clearly visible, as well as several other density enhancements which are mostly located along the direction defined by the cluster ellipticity.

2.3. Completeness and accuracy of the classification

The differential luminosity distribution of the galaxy candidates indicates that the sample appears quite complete down to the tex2html_wrap_inline1099 19.75 magnitude (see Fig. 2 (click here)). To go further, we first tested the completeness of this overall list by cross-identifying it with three catalogues from the literature (Murphy 1984; Beers et al. 1991; Malumuth et al. 1992) with the help of images obtained from the mapping mode of the MAMA machine.

  figure252
Figure 2: Differential magnitude distribution of the 25 103 galaxy candidates in the SRC-J 681 field

It appeared that: i) all but one galaxy of the Malumuth et al. (1992) catalogue of 165 objects are actually classified as galaxies, with a mean offset between individual positions equal to 1.10 tex2html_wrap_inline1103 0.06 arcsecond; ii) 94% of the 35 galaxies listed by Beers et al. (1991) inside the area are included in our catalogue, only 2 bright objects which suffer from severe saturation being misclassified. Note that such an effect also caused 5 of the 83 galaxies chosen as photometric standards to be misclassified, which gives the same percentage as for the sample by Beers et al. The comparison with the faint CCD catalogue built by Murphy (1984) in the so-called tex2html_wrap_inline1105 band (quite similar to that obtained using a photographic IIIaF emulsion with a R filter) was performed only for objects which were visible on the photographic plate with secure identification (only uncertain X and Y coordinates are provided in the paper) and classified without any doubt as galaxies from our visual examination. There remained 107 objects out of 170, among which 88 are brighter than tex2html_wrap_inline1113 19.75 (tex2html_wrap_inline1115 18.5). Down to this flux limit, 82 objects (tex2html_wrap_inline1077 93%) are in agreement, thereby validating the choice of our decision curve in the Flux vs. Area parameter space. These cross-identifications therefore indicate that the completeness limit of our catalogue is about 95% for such objects, as expected from similar studies at high galactic latitude.

In order to confirm this statement and to study the homogeneity of our galaxy catalogue, we then decided to verify carefully its reliability inside the region of the Abell 85 cluster of galaxies itself. The centre of ABCG 85 was assumed to be located at the equatorial coordinates given in the literature, tex2html_wrap_inline1119 and tex2html_wrap_inline1121, and a square region of tex2html_wrap_inline1020 around this position was defined; such an angular distance corresponds to tex2html_wrap_inline1077 2.7 Mpc h100-1 at the redshift of the cluster (z=0.0555). However, let us remark that the position of the central D galaxy is slightly different, tex2html_wrap_inline1133 and tex2html_wrap_inline1135, and so is the centre we found from our X-ray analysis of the diffuse component of this cluster, i.e.: tex2html_wrap_inline1137 and tex2html_wrap_inline1139 (Pislar et al. 1997). For all our future studies, we then chose to define the cluster centre as that of this X-ray component.

The distribution of the tex2html_wrap_inline1141 candidates within the area has been first of all visually inspected to remove remaining conspicuous false detections around some stars as well as some defects mainly due to a satellite track crossing the field. This cleaned catalogue contains a little more than 4000 galaxy-like objects, half of which brighter than tex2html_wrap_inline1091. The intrinsic quality of this list has then been checked against a visual classification of all the recorded objects within a tex2html_wrap_inline1145 area covering the region already observed by Murphy (1984) around the location tex2html_wrap_inline1147 and tex2html_wrap_inline1149. The inspection of the corresponding MAMA frame of tex2html_wrap_inline1151 pixels enabled us to give a morphological code to each object, as well as to flag superimposed objects and to deblend manually 10 galaxies (new positions and flux estimates for each galaxy member). Of course, the discrimination power of this visual examination decreases for star-like objects fainter than tex2html_wrap_inline1153 due to the sampling involved (pixel size of 0.67''), and an exact classification of such objects appeared to be hopeless above the a priori completeness limit of our automated galaxy list guessed to be tex2html_wrap_inline1091. Down to this limit, our results can be summarized as follows: i) tex2html_wrap_inline1159 of the selected galaxies are true galaxies (including 7 multiple galaxies and 2 mergers with stars), while 4% may be galaxies; ii) 7 genuine galaxies are missed (4%). Since these contamination and incompleteness levels of tex2html_wrap_inline1161 were satisfactory, we decided to set the completeness limit for our automated galaxy catalogue at this magnitude tex2html_wrap_inline1091.

2.4. The photographic plate catalogue

For objects fainter than our completeness limit, the visual check of the inner tex2html_wrap_inline1167 part of our object list has enabled us to confirm the galaxy identification of 135 galaxy candidates as well as to select 214 misclassified faint galaxies. The total number of galaxies included in the visual sample down to the detection limit is 541, whereas the initial list only contains 338 candidates within the same area. Keeping in mind that both catalogues are almost identical for objects brighter than tex2html_wrap_inline1091, we decided to replace the automated list by the visual one inside this tex2html_wrap_inline1145 central area. Note that about 150 objects remained unclassified, including 26 galaxies from the CCD list by Murphy. We added these 26 galaxies to the final catalogue whose galaxies are plotted in Fig. 3 (click here).

  figure292
Figure 3: Positions of the 4232 galaxies detected on the photographic plate relative to the centre of the cluster defined as the centre of the diffuse X-ray component. North is to the top and East to the left

Table 1 lists the merged catalogue of 4,232 galaxies obtained from the SRC-J 681 plate in the tex2html_wrap_inline1020 field of ABCG 85, with V and R magnitudes computed using the transformation laws obtained from our CCD data (see Sect. 3.3). This table includes the following information: running number; equatorial coordinates (equinox 2000.0); ellipticity; position angle of the major axis; tex2html_wrap_inline1022, V, and R magnitudes; X and Y positions in arcsecond relative to the centre defined as that of the diffuse X-ray emission of the cluster (see above); cross-identifications with the lists by Malumuth et al. (1992); Beers et al. (1991) and Murphy (1984).


next previous
Up: A photometric catalogue

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)