next previous
Up: Active region effects

1. Introduction

Helioseismology has a recent past, when the 5-minute solar oscillations, first observed in the sixties by Leighton, Noyes and Simon, were identified theoretically and observationally as the evanescent photospheric counterpart of the acoustic modes resonating in the underlying convection zone. At present, the oscillation frequencies are used to get information on the Sun's interior, like the extension of the convection zone and the internal rotation velocity, whilst other oscillation properties, like phase differences, can be used to diagnose the atmospheric layers. The future, which the successful launch of SOHO makes closer, will be probably dominated by the study of low frequency modes, in particular g-modes.

Very recently the detection of a number of g-modes in solar wind measurements done by Ulysses has been reported (Thomson et al. 1995). This kind of measurements needs to be confirmed before being widely accepted. In progress there are both ground and space based experiments to measure solar global modes (see e.g. Fig. 3 in Harvey 1995). In particular we will refer here to the IRIS and GOLF experiments. The IRIS (International Research on the Interior of the Sun) ground-based network for full disk helioseismology (e.g. Fossat 1991; Pallé et al. 1993) is measuring since 1991 the full disk line-of-sight velocity, from the Doppler shift of the sodium tex2html_wrap_inline1213 line, over a range of frequencies from 100 tex2html_wrap_inline1241, when the atmospheric conditions are good enough, up to about 10 mHz, limited by the photon statistical noise of the sodium resonance cell.

The GOLF (Global Oscillations at Low Frequency) experiment, on board of the satellite SOHO (Solar and Heliospheric Observatory), which was launched on December 2, 1995, will make a definite effort to detect and identify the solar g-modes. The measuring method involves an extension to space of the ground-based technique used by IRIS (Gabriel et al. 1995). The data will be collected continuously for a period of at least two years (hopefully six) over a range of frequencies from tex2html_wrap_inline1243 to 6 mHz, without limitations due to duty cycle and merging problems.

The possibilities of these experiments to detect solar oscillations in the low frequency domain and definitely identify the g-modes depend crucially on the contrast in power between the oscillation signal and other time dependent signals in the same frequency range. This "noise'' is partly instrumental and partly of solar origin, therefore the signal to noise ratio could be in principle increased by our ability to understand and remove solar sources of non-oscillatory signals.

Harvey (1985) made an estimate of the background Doppler-shift noise of solar origin in full-disk measurements assuming that it is due to the finite lifetime (evolution) of four velocity fields: granulation, mesogranulation, supergranulation and active regions. The parameters of this model, whose values were derived from high resolution observations, are the rms velocity amplitudes and the lifetimes of the motions. In this way, Harvey got a continuous noise spectrum in which active regions and supergranulation make the largest contribution to the power in the g-mode frequency band (tex2html_wrap_inline1245), whilst granulation dominates at higher frequencies. In subsequent works, observed power spectra have been used to fit the model parameters, getting different results according to the estimate Of the instrumental contribution to the observed background (Jiménez et al. 1988; Elsworth et al. 1993). A similar noise model has been used by Harvey et al. (1993) to study the solar noise spectrum of chromospheric oscillations, and a more complex model of the irradiance background due to granulation, mesogranulation and supergranulation, based on a numerical simulation of their time evolution, has been proposed by Andersen et al. (1994).

The solar noise spectrum has also a spectral line component. Claverie et al. (1982) established the existence of a 13.1 tex2html_wrap_inline1247 day signal of amplitude tex2html_wrap_inline1249 in measurements of the mean Doppler velocity shift of the integrated solar disk. This finding was confirmed by Isaak et al. (1984), who found also a second less prominent peak at a period of 27.2 days, and, later, by Jiménez et al. (1988) and Régulo et al. (1993).

Claverie et al. in their paper suggested a possible explanation of this phenomenon in terms of a rapidly rotating solar core (see also Dicke 1983). On the other hand, taking into account the effect of active regions passing over the solar disk, several authors (Durrant & Schröter 1983; Andersen & Maltby 1983; Edmunds & Gough 1983) have been able to reproduce the observations sufficiently well to establish that active region modulation is almost completely responsible for the observed signal. However, it is not yet clear if the spots or other parts of the active regions make the largest contribution to the velocity signal. Indeed, different simulations of the signal have been based on the plage area (Durrant & Schröter 1983; Herrero et al. 1984), on the sunspot area (Andersen & Maltby 1983; Régulo et al. 1993), on spot and plage area (Edmunds & Gough 1983; Jiménez et al. 1988) and, finally, based on daily magnetograms (Ulrich et al. 1993) and GONG modulation images (Beck et al. 1995).

The agreement with the observations is generally good, but not enough to consider any of these models a completely successful correction of the integrated sunlight observations for the effect of active regions.

The active region noise arises because they may introduce real local velocities contributing to the global average, and because, through both their magnetic fields and thermal structure, they change the integrated profile of the observed lines by an amount that is set by the active region distribution and modulated by solar rotation. In this paper, we model the latter effect, which originates from the different line shapes in magnetic and quiet solar areas. Both sunspots and plages appear darker than the quiet Sun in the sodium D lines at about tex2html_wrap_inline1251 from the line core, where the passbands of the resonant cell are centered, therefore Roger Ulrich has called this effect magnetic darkening velocity. We simulated the velocity and flux fluctuations produced by different active region distributions, using an analytical description of their action. Such an approach has proved to be successful in clarifying the formation of the spectral line component of the noise attributed to solar active regions.

We have applied our model to ground based velocity measurements, comparing our results with the data obtained by the IRIS network, and we plan to extend the simulation for calibrating the data coming from the GOLF experiment, whose level of background noise is expected to be one order of magnitude lower than it is on ground based measurements.

Preliminary results of our simulation have been presented by Marmolino et al. (1995, hereafter Paper I). In this paper we complete the analysis started in Paper I discussing in details the dependence of the simulation results upon a number of model parameters. Specifically, in Sect. 2 we recall the methods and describe the data which our simulation is based on; in Sect. 3 we review briefly on the calibration methods necessary to get velocities out of the observed photometric ratios; in Sect. 4 we show and discuss the results, and in Sect. 5 we summarize our main conclusions.


next previous
Up: Active region effects

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)
This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.