next previous
Up: Be stars in

3. The data

3.1. An atlas of hydrogen lines

Measured line profiles are plotted in Figs. 1 (click here) through 14 with continua normalized to unity for 58 programme stars in 8 open clusters and associations. Htex2html_wrap_inline1737, Htex2html_wrap_inline1739 and Htex2html_wrap_inline1741 are shown for each star and, in separate figures, Htex2html_wrap_inline1743 and Htex2html_wrap_inline1745. Stars where only Htex2html_wrap_inline1747 was measured are shown following the first ones for each cluster. The horizontal axes (wavelength) have been drawn at the same scale for all the lines spanning 80 Å, so that relative changes in the line widths can easily be observed. The number in the upper right corner is the star identification number and is the same as in Paper I except for NGC 457 which are from Boden (1946). For the four stars of the Pleiades cluster for which spectra were recorded twice, the date of observations are included in the plot following the star number.

50% of our programme stars (29 of 58) show single peak emission at Htex2html_wrap_inline1749 while 26% (15 of 58) show double peaks. The remaining 14 stars show absorption lines. No shell type profiles have been detected in our sample.

We have decided to include lines in absorption as well because: 1) they all belong to stars previously classified as Be and it might be useful to compare them with previous ones in an emission phase, 2) the absorption lines seen in some stars, for example 1268 and 2371 in h & tex2html_wrap_inline1753 Per, have equivalent widths smaller than those for a normal B star (3.5-10 Å), denoting the presence of some emission filling-in, although no emission can be seen from the inspection of the Htex2html_wrap_inline1757 line profile.

As stated before, and following the line of Paper I, our main purpose here is to present the spectroscopic data along with a first analysis in order to guarantee their homogeneity. Thus we are going to test the quality of the data by applying some previously found relationships based on large samples of Be stars and higher resolution spectroscopy.

3.2. Relationship between equivalent widths and full widths at half maximum

It was found by Dachs et al. (1986) that the full width at half maximum of an emission line and its equivalent width are inversely correlated by a law of the form


equation300

The anticorrelation between tex2html_wrap_inline1759 and tex2html_wrap_inline1761 is in the sense that the higher the emission, the narrower the line. This is consistent with the picture in which large emission corresponds to large disk radius, thus slow velocity and small rotational broadening.

In order to check whether this relation holds for our data we have followed the method outlined by Hanuschik et al. (1988) and have written the equation in the form
equation311
These values are plotted in Fig. 15 (click here) and the best least squares fit yields:

eqnarray317
where r is the correlation coefficient as usual. These values are consistent with those obtained by Dachs et al. (1986) and Hanuschik et al. (1988). Considering only early type stars, in the sense established in Paper I, the parameters are:

eqnarray321
where both tex2html_wrap_inline1765 and r are distinctly better, while for late Be type stars there seems to be no correlation at all.

We also checked this method with Htex2html_wrap_inline1769 and obtained the following results:
eqnarray323
For Htex2html_wrap_inline1771 the few points available do not allow us to reach any conclusion.

3.3. Relationship between full widths at half maximum and tex2html_wrap_inline1773

It is known that a trend exists in the full widths at half maximum of the hydrogen series lines in the sense that FWHM(Hn) is equal or narrower than FWHM(Hn+1). This agrees with the model whereby higher members of the series are produced in more rapidly rotating regions of the circumstellar disk closer to the star, and are thus more affected by rotational broadening.

In Fig. 16 (click here) we have plotted the measured full width at half maximum for emission lines against published values of projected rotational velocity tex2html_wrap_inline1779 (Slettebak 1982, 1985).

We have computed the relation:
equation328
for tex2html_wrap_inline1781. It should be noted that the FWHM of those lines showing double peaks is roughly twice that presented by single lines. The former, therefore show high values of tex2html_wrap_inline1785. Taking this into account, the parameters obtained are the following:

lines tex2html_wrap_inline1787 tex2html_wrap_inline1789 tex2html_wrap_inline1791
all tex2html_wrap_inline1793 tex2html_wrap_inline1795 tex2html_wrap_inline1797
single tex2html_wrap_inline1799 tex2html_wrap_inline1801 tex2html_wrap_inline1803

These values are somewhat higher than those obtained by Slettebak et al. (1992). Those authors, apart from a larger sample of stars which improves the statistics, used corrected values of FWHM for emission profiles by subtracting computed photospheric lines taking into account rotational broadening, shape distortion, gravity darkening and change of spectral type due to rotation and then extrapolating mathematically the remaining emission profile. Our purpose in this paper, however, is to deliberately avoid imposing any kind of model.

 

Cluster Star tex2html_wrap_inline1811 tex2html_wrap_inline1813 rem.
NGC 457 14 2.1 2.9
91 3.1 4.2
153 0.9 1.9
198 2.9 3.8
NGC 663 21 2.8 3.8
92 2.9 3.8
141 2.2 3.2
194 2.2 3.0 1
243 3.0 3.6
Pleiades 486 6.5 6.8
(Aug. 93) 980 5.5 5.8
1432 5.4 5.7 3
2181 6.7 6.6 4
NGC 7654 778 5.6 6.2 5
782 5.4 6.0 5
928 2.6 7.0 5
Table 2: Equivalent widths (Å) for tex2html_wrap_inline1807 and tex2html_wrap_inline1809. Remarks are the same as in Table 1

 

These values, as well as those given in the preceding Section, are all consistent with those presented in similar discussions of earlier works based on higher resolution spectroscopy of large samples of Be field stars. We can interpret this fact in the sense that the spectroscopic behavior of Be stars in clusters is, within the limits of our resolution, similar to that presented by field Be stars.

3.4. Relationship between tex2html_wrap_inline1815 and tex2html_wrap_inline1817

According to Huang (1972), a rotating envelope with velocity tex2html_wrap_inline1819 and outer radius tex2html_wrap_inline1821, surrounding a star of radius tex2html_wrap_inline1823, is expected to produce double peaked lines whose separation tex2html_wrap_inline1825, is given by
equation354
with j=0.5 for Keplerian rotation and j=1 for angular momentum conservation.

In Table 3 (click here) we present measured values of the velocity peak separations for those stars showing double peaks. The mean velocity peak separation ratio for the first two Balmer lines is:


equation361
fully compatible with the result obtained by Hanuschik et al. (1988), and slightly above that presented by Dachs et al. (1992). The relation between velocity peak separations and corresponding values of tex2html_wrap_inline1831 yields tex2html_wrap_inline1833 for Htex2html_wrap_inline1835 and tex2html_wrap_inline1837 for Htex2html_wrap_inline1839. These values differ somewhat from those given by Hanuschik et al. (1988) and the correlation here is in the sense that larger peak separations correspond to larger values of tex2html_wrap_inline1841. This supports the axial symmetry of the emitting envelope being tex2html_wrap_inline1843 systematically larger than tex2html_wrap_inline1845 which, according to Eq. (5), means that Htex2html_wrap_inline1847 emission originates closer to the star.

 

Cluster Star tex2html_wrap_inline1849 tex2html_wrap_inline1851
NGC 457 91 260 670
198 260
NGC 663 8 250
21 180 260
51 290
92 320
121 130
124 190
130 190
243 250
h & tex2html_wrap_inline1853 Per 2088 150 260
2138 130 210
2402 160 250
Pleiades 486 280
(Dec. 92) 980 130 220
Pleiades 486 250
(Aug. 93) 980 120 190
NGC 2422 45 170
125 220
NGC 7654 778 170
928 250
Table 3: Velocity peak separation (km/s)

 

We also checked the relationship between peak separation in velocity units and equivalent widths using the equation
equation391
for which the best least squares fit yields:

eqnarray398

These values agree with those given by Hanuschik et al. (1988) and are plotted in Fig. 17 (click here) . As stated in their work, this inverse correlation can be explained in terms of a velocity field decreasing with increasing radius of the emitting envelope. Our data would indicate some preference for values of tex2html_wrap_inline1855 (Eq. (8b) of that reference). We did not try to check this correlation for Htex2html_wrap_inline1857 since, as stated before, the equivalent widths have been measured from the continuum and the emission is almost always embedded in the broad wings of the underlying photospheric absorption. This prevent us to consider the tex2html_wrap_inline1859 as an effective measure of the amount of circumstellar emission.

3.5. Comments on some individual stars

Some stars from the Pleiades cluster were observed twice, thereby allowing some discussion of their variability.

The star Hz 486 showed a significant augmentation of the emission level which is reflected in slightly shallower lines. On the other hand some enhancement appears for the Htex2html_wrap_inline1861 wings. See Fig. 7 (click here).

The star Hz 980 maintains its emission level but clearly shows a V/R inversion. The star changes from V/R> 1 to V/R< 1 visible both in tex2html_wrap_inline1869 and tex2html_wrap_inline1871 (Fig. 7 (click here)).

A change in the core of Htex2html_wrap_inline1873 line of the star Hz 1432 can clearly be seen. Unfortunately we could not take the corresponding tex2html_wrap_inline1875 spectrum. See Fig. 7 (click here).

The well known Be-Shell star Hz 2181 (Pleione, B7-8IV-Ve) shows here an augmentation of the emission level. As was shown in Paper I, despite the high emission level observed in its spectrum, the position in the photometric diagrams is not abnormal. This effect can be observed in Slettebak (1985) for the UBV colors too. Therefore, some mechanism working in this star, makes their photometric colors to mimic those for a regular B type star. There may however be another explanation: early Be stars move towards redder values in the tex2html_wrap_inline1879 plane and to bluer colors in tex2html_wrap_inline1881 plane while late type Be stars, beyond B5V, remain in their usual positions despite the emission strength, as was shown in Paper I. Recently, Cramer et al. (1995) have pointed out the difficulty of distinguish this star from other normal stars by means of photometric diagrams.

The Be nature of two stars in the cluster NGC 663 is still controversial. W 107 was observed by Merrill & Burwell (1949) with mild emission in the interval 1945 - 1948. However, no emission was observed by Schild & Romanishin (1976) nor by Sanduleak (1979, 1991) during his survey in the interval 1946 - 1990. Sanduleak (1979) suggest a possible identification error in the Merrill & Burwell (1949) catalogue. W 110 was reported as showing weak emission (tex2html_wrap_inline1883) by Schild & Romanishin (1976), but this observation was not confirmed by Schild (1978). Sanduleak (1979, 1991) never observed this star in emission during his survey spanning between 1946 and 1990. In our spectra both stars present their Balmer lines in absorption, though its equivalent width is well outside the limits for normal B type stars which would imply some amount of undetectable emission filling in the photospheric absorption line. Thus we can conclude that both stars are indeed Be stars, usually showing low levels of activity, which would explain the lack of detection in prism objective surveys like that conducted by Sanduleak.

In addition to the stars previously classified as Be, we have included in our spectroscopic survey some stars in which line emission has not previously been detected, but which several authors marked as possible Be stars. Among them we have found a new Be star, Oo 717 (BD +56 502) in the h Persei cluster (Fabregat et al. 1994b). This star was signaled as a possible Be by Waelkens et al. (1990) on the basis of its photometric variability. In Fig. 6 (click here) we can see its Htex2html_wrap_inline1887 line clearly in emission, with an equivalent width of tex2html_wrap_inline1889. It should be noted that this star was observed in September 1990 by Kaufer et al. (1994). In the Kaufer et al. spectrum the Htex2html_wrap_inline1891 line was observed in almost pure absorption (only a slight filling-in is discernible). This means the strong emission line in Fig. 6 (click here) has developed in less than two years, indicating that the spectral characteristics of Oo 717 are highly variable. We have also observed Oo 245 and Oo 864, also marked by Waelkens et al. (1990) as suspected Be stars. Both stars present the Balmer lines in absorption.

 

Cluster Star tex2html_wrap_inline1893 tex2html_wrap_inline1895 tex2html_wrap_inline1897
NGC 663 11 10.3
15 6.4
25 4.4
27 4.8
35 6.8
85 7.0
91 2.7
106 4.2
147 3.0
h & tex2html_wrap_inline1899 Per 245 2.7 3.1 3.6
864 3.1
NGC 2422 65 8.5 10.5 8.7
68 8.7
70 10.0 12.6 10.6
71 4.7 6.2 5.7
73 7.0
83 5.0 6.4 5.9
Table 4: EW for regular B type stars

 

Stars 65 and 73 in NGC 2422 are also marked as suspected Be stars by Shobbrook (1984), because in their photometric diagrams they occupy positions similar to the cluster Be stars. Our spectra, however, show their Balmer lines in absorption and in our photometric diagrams (Paper I), both stars are placed among the normal absorption line stars, and do not show the anomalous position claimed by Shobbrook.


next previous
Up: Be stars in

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)
web@ed-phys.fr