next previous
Up: V 700 Cygni

5. Discussion and conclusions

Although the available information about the systems V 700 Cyg and AW Vir is based only on photometry and spectral classification, the adopted spot models fit satisfactorily the observed light curves. The two minima have unequal depths, and a temperature difference of a few hundred degrees between the components is expected. The final solution yields a temperature difference tex2html_wrap_inline2218 between the components of V 700 Cyg, and tex2html_wrap_inline2220 between those of AW Vir. According to our W-type solution, the larger and more massive component of both systems is also the cooler one, while the smaller and less massive is the hotter component. The thermal-decoupling degree, defined as tex2html_wrap_inline2222 (Lipari & Sistero 1988), where tex2html_wrap_inline2224 corresponds to the temperature of the larger and more massive component and tex2html_wrap_inline2226 to that of the smaller and less massive one, yields values -0.07 and -0.05 for V 700 Cyg and AW Vir, respectively. These values place the two systems among the W-type systems in Figs. 2 (click here) and 3 (click here) of Lipari & Sistero (1988). In the previous expression for DT we have replaced, according to our W-type solution, tex2html_wrap_inline2234 and tex2html_wrap_inline2236.

We succeeded to model the light curves of V 700 Cyg by invoking two cool spots on the larger (cooler, more massive) component, while for AW Vir one cool spot on the larger (cooler, more massive) component, was sufficient to obtain a satisfactory fit to the observations. As far as the uniqueness of our model is concerned, it should be pointed out that solutions with different spot combinations may equally well fit the observations. According to Maceroni et al. (1990) and Maceroni & van't Veer (1993) this is a general problem of light curve fitting with spot models. On the basis of this argument, we tried to use the simplest model with a physical meaning.

Given that a unique solution can hardly be obtained for partially eclipsing systems with unknown spectroscopic mass-ratio, we can invoke an independent check of the quality of the derived (unspotted and spotted) solutions by considering the residuals for each light curve. Barone et al. (1993) pointed out that, according to the Chauvenet hypothesis, at least tex2html_wrap_inline2238 of the points should be in the band defined by the statistical error lines tex2html_wrap_inline2240, where tex2html_wrap_inline2242 is given by Eq. (7) of Barone et al. (1993). In the case of V 700 Cyg we find tex2html_wrap_inline2244 for B and tex2html_wrap_inline2248 for V. For the unspotted solution (with phase intervals 0.13 - 0.24 and 0.61 - 0.82 excluded) tex2html_wrap_inline2256 of the tex2html_wrap_inline2258 points in B and tex2html_wrap_inline2262 in V lie inside the statistical error lines. When the whole light curve is considered, the Chauvenet hypothesis is not fulfilled. In the spotted solution (where all the points are included) tex2html_wrap_inline2266 of the tex2html_wrap_inline2268 points in B and tex2html_wrap_inline2272 of the points in V are within the error lines. Therefore, both the unspotted and spotted solutions fulfill the Chauvenet hypothesis marginally making thus both solutions acceptable.

In the case of AW Vir, the error lines are tex2html_wrap_inline2276 in B and tex2html_wrap_inline2280 in V. Similarly, for the unspotted solution (with phase interval 0.60-0.78 excluded) tex2html_wrap_inline2286 of the tex2html_wrap_inline2288 points in B and tex2html_wrap_inline2292 in V lie inside the error lines: if we consider the whole light curve, the corresponding numbers are tex2html_wrap_inline2296 and tex2html_wrap_inline2298 in B and V, respectively. For the spotted solution tex2html_wrap_inline2304 of the tex2html_wrap_inline2306 points in B and tex2html_wrap_inline2310 in V are within the statistical error lines. These data indicate that both solutions, the unspotted and spotted one, are acceptable, since both fulfill the Chauvenet hypothesis.

After our study had been submitted, a photometric analysis of AW Vir was published by Lapasset et al. (1996). They used the WD code to analyse their B,V light curves, which do not show noticeable asymmetries or irregularities. An unspotted solution was found on the basis of the best fit, which formally corresponds to an A-type configuration, although the values of some physical parameters - mass-ratio, degree of contact and spectral type - are typical for W-type systems. The authors conclude they are unable to assess unambiguously the subtype of this system by photometric evidence only. Since their identification of minimum I and II is the same as in the present paper, we are confident to say that AW Vir oscillates between states of DT between 0 and a negative value.

Our solution is based on B,V light curves, obtained 7 years before the observations of Lapasset et al. They clearly show a brightness deficiency in the phase interval 0.60 - 0.78, and require the application of a spot model. Our W-type solution is based not only on the best fit, but also on the similarity of some basic physical parameters of AW Vir to those typical for W-type systems. Despite the different subtypes found in the two analyses, the geometrical elements (inclination and relative radii) are very similar in the two solutions (see Table 5 (click here)). Lapasset et al. assumed a spectral type G0 for the primary component on the basis of UBV colours; since the photometric data given in their Table 2 are apparently misprinted, it is difficult to judge whether this spectral type is to be preferred over MacDonald's (1964) spectral classification.

Three-dimensional pictures of the spotted models of V 700 Cyg and AW Vir are shown in Figs. 9 (click here) and 10 (click here). Cross-sectional surface outlines of the two systems with their inner and outer critical Roche surfaces are shown in Figs. 11 (click here) and 12 (click here).

  figure822
Figure 9: A three-dimensional model of V 700 Cyg for phases 0.25 (upper plot) and 0.75 (lower plot)

  figure827
Figure 10: A three-dimensional model of AW Vir for phases 0.25 (upper plot) and 0.75 (lower plot)

  figure832
Figure 11: Cross-sectional surface outline of V 700 Cyg (dashed line). The solid lines are the Roche critical surfaces.

  figure837
Figure 12: Cross-sectional surface outline of AW Vir (dashed line). The solid lines are the Roche critical surfaces

The present results are based on photometry only, since no radial velocities of the systems exist so far. Nevertheless it is interesting to speculate on the evolution status by using the absolute parameters of the systems. These were computed by the LC program of the WD code and standard relations, where the parameters found in the spotted solutions were used as input parameters, and are listed in Table 5 (click here).

The absolute elements were used to estimate the evolutionary status of the two systems by means of the mass-radius (MR), mass-luminosity (ML) and HR diagrams of Hilditch et al. (1988), who showed that the mass-radius diagram is the principal indicator of the evolutionary state. The primary components of V 700 Cyg and AW Vir lie in the region between ZAMS and TAMS, which is occupied by the primaries of other W-type W UMa systems. The position of V 700 Cyg, quite close to the TAMS, indicates that this system is somewhat evolved while AW Vir is rather unevolved. In both cases, the secondary component lies in the region where other secondaries of W-type W UMa systems are found, and has a larger radius than expected for the ZAMS mass (Hilditch et al. 1988).

The derived W-type solutions, supported by the thermal-decoupling degree of the systems, successfully reproduce the observations and are consistent with the MR, ML and HR diagrams of Hilditch et al. (1988). But more definite conclusions about the evolutionary status of V 700 Cyg and AW Vir can only be drawn by means of additional photometric and spectroscopic observations of the systems.

Acknowledgements

We are especially grateful to Wenxian Lu for taking a spectrum of V 700 Cyg on short notice. We thank W. Van Hamme for useful discussions, the referee, F. van't Veer, for his comments on the manuscript, and H. Busch for communicating data from the Hartha Circular. The 3-D pictures and cross-sectional surface outlines were made by D.H. Bradstreet's Binary Maker 2.0. H.W.D. was supported by a ESO Senior Visitor fellowship.


next previous
Up: V 700 Cygni

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)
web@ed-phys.fr