next previous
Up: Nonvariability among Bootis

5. Results

5.1. Noise level of our survey

The detection threshold is depending on the quality of the night, the star's brightness, the telescope size and the duration of the observations. Consequently, for a faint star and/or a poor night this threshold can be as high as 10mmag whereas for the best cases we find a few mmags (Fig.1 (click here)). There can be several reasons why a candidate star yields a null result, e.g. the internal stellar structure, or atmospheric and instrumental effects. Also beating of several independent pulsation modes together with a small time base could simulate constancy. Nevertheless we consider a star to be constant, if the Fourier spectrum of the differential light curve does not contain a statistically significant peak in the frequency range up to the Nyquist frequency. Of course, we cannot exclude variability on a lower amplitude level.
For 5 stars (HD31295, HD74873, HD91130, HD125162 and HD179791) of the presumably constant stars one might be tempted to assume low amplitude variability. But based on the noise level in the amplitude spectra of the respective stars, the highest peak is not statistically significant. Figure1 (click here) shows the distribution of upper limits for nonvariability, merging the results of Strömgren v and b photometry (Table1 (click here)). Models and observations (Matthews et al. 1996) indicate an amplitude scaling for A-type stars of Amplitudetex2html_wrap_inline1179 Amplitude[b], justifying our merging procedure. A typical noise level of 3mmag was achieved for the relevant frequency domain up to 100dtex2html_wrap_inline1183 (Fig.1 (click here)). The distribution of the frequencies with the highest (but statistically insignificant) amplitudes shows a maximum at 10dtex2html_wrap_inline1185 (Fig.2 (click here)), perhaps caused by insufficiently corrected sky transparency variations, with no other significant trends.

  figure329
Figure 1: Distribution of the upper levels for nonvariability for all observed stars

  figure334
Figure 2: Distribution of the frequencies for the highest derived amplitudes

Location in the Hertzsprung-Russell-diagramme

After establishing nonvariability among the observed candidate stars within a given limit, we have investigated their location in a (b-y) vs. tex2html_wrap_inline1189 diagramme. Strömgren colours were taken from Hauck & Mermilliod (1990) and Handler (1995). No photometric indices are available for HD171948 and HD192424. The dereddening procedure and calibration in the Strömgren system uses the results given by Crawford (1979) and comprises the iteration procedure described by Hilditch et al. (1983). The reddening for all stars is small (E(b-y) < 0.015), except for the two cases HD145782 (E(b-y) = 0.03) and HD193281 (E(b-y) = 0.025) indicating that all stars are within the solar neighbourhood. Gray (1988) showed that peculiar hydrogen line profiles and very high tex2html_wrap_inline1197 values, as found in some tex2html_wrap_inline1199Bootis stars, influence tex2html_wrap_inline1201 and hence tex2html_wrap_inline1203. We have to stress again that all calibrations are derived for "normal" type stars. Since the intrinsic error in tex2html_wrap_inline1205 is about tex2html_wrap_inline1207 mag (Crawford 1979), we completely neglect those effects.
Figure3 (click here) shows the location of all observed tex2html_wrap_inline1209Bootis stars with the typical error bars for both parameters indicated. The variable stars were taken from Paunzen et al. (1997) and calibrated as just described.
Taking into account the given errors, only 11 "constant" stars lie within the instability strip (although its hot border is not unambiguously defined), namely:
HD319, HD74873, HD79025, HD141851,
HD143148, HD154153, HD156954, HD188164,
HD193256, HD193281, HD204041.
On the other hand 12 variable tex2html_wrap_inline1211Bootis stars are placed there, suggesting that at least 50% of all investigated members inside the instability strip are pulsating. If we exclude HD79025, HD154153 and HD188164, since they are not yet definitely established members of the tex2html_wrap_inline1213Bootis group, the ratio increases to 2/3.
This is a remarkable result compared to "normal" type stars in the same region of the Hertzsprung-Russell-diagramme. Previous surveys for pulsating stars in clusters indicate that the incidence of tex2html_wrap_inline1215Scuti variables is not larger than 35 percent of all stars within the instability strip (Breger 1975; Slovak 1978). These results were achieved with limits for nonvariability comparable to this paper. On the other hand, we have investigated a biased sample of stars, based on metallicity. Nevertheless, since variable and constant members of open clusters generally have also the same metallicity, there is strong evidence that our result is significant compared to "normal" type stars. The metallicity measured spectroscopically for chemically peculiar stars very probably is restricted to the surface only, but the average metallicity for the entire star is "normal".

  figure356
Figure 3: The location of tex2html_wrap_inline1217Bootis stars in a (b-y) vs. tex2html_wrap_inline1221 diagramme. The standard line is taken from Crawford (1979), the borders of the instability strip are from Breger (1979)


next previous
Up: Nonvariability among Bootis

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)
web@ed-phys.fr