next previous
Up: Cold neutral gas

4. Discussion

4.1. Comparison with emission at other wavelengths

A comparison between the tex2html_wrap_inline1434 image of the Gum nebula as taken from Sivan (1974) with the giant HI disk (Fig. 1 (click here)) shows a good positional coincidence between the neutral gas disk and the optical emission, as well as a similar angular size. To the northwest, the HI emission slightly departs from the circular symmetry. The two optical wings between tex2html_wrap_inline1436 and tex2html_wrap_inline1438 lie outside the edge of the disk. The eastern wing depicts a good morphological correspondence with the HI contours. The other wing, however, appears detached from the giant HI disk.

The Puppis-Vela region between tex2html_wrap_inline1440, tex2html_wrap_inline1442 was thoroughly studied at 12, 25, 60 and tex2html_wrap_inline1444 by Sahu (1992) using IRAS data. At 25, 60 and tex2html_wrap_inline1446, the author finds a tex2html_wrap_inline1448 radius shell centered at tex2html_wrap_inline1450, which is called the "IRAS Vela Shell''. The center of this structure is coincident with tex2html_wrap_inline1452 Velorum and with the Vela OB2 association. Thus, it is assumed that the IRAS Vela Shell has the same distance as the Vela OB2 assocation, i.e. 450 pc. We checked the tex2html_wrap_inline1454 image presented by Sahu (1992) and found a remarkably good positional correspondence between the inner thick HI shell reported by Dubner et al. \ (1992) and the infrared emission. In both cases, the emission encloses a minimum at tex2html_wrap_inline1456. Therefore, the northern part of the IRAS Vela Shell seems to be the infrared counterpart of the thick HI shell. The IR emission is probably due to the presence of shock heated gas. The present results are consistent with Braun's (1985) findings in the SNR IC443. No HI counterpart is found for the IRAS Vela Shell as a whole.

The Gum nebula has also been studied in X-rays by Leahy et al. \ (1992), using the HEAO-1 data in the range 0.1 to 3 keV. In this study, the authors adjusted for the X-ray emission a single temperature model for a hot optically thick gas. The results were consistent with a uniform X-ray emitting plasma with tex2html_wrap_inline1458. The estimated temperature agrees with that expected from the interior of a SNR, according to Chevalier's model (1974). The observed X-ray source region is not completely coincident with the extent of the Gum nebula in tex2html_wrap_inline1460. Thus, Leahy et al. \ (1992) suggest that the origin of the X-ray emission may be ascribed to a SNR located within the Gum nebula but not filling it entirely.

4.2. Origin of the Gum nebula

4.2.1. The thick HI shell

Based on HI data, Dubner et al. (1992) have investigated the thick HI shell in connection with the Gum nebula. They have found that the strong stellar winds of tex2html_wrap_inline1462 Puppis, an O4If-type star, and tex2html_wrap_inline1464 Velorum, a Wolf-Rayet spectroscopic binary (WC8+O9I), may have provided enough energy to the ISM to equal the kinetic energy acquired by the thick HI shell. However, by applying the model of Chevalier (1974), they also show that the thick HI shell is consistent with a model of an old SN explosion occurred tex2html_wrap_inline1466 years ago. They suggest that this explosion could have originated the Gum nebula. Observations at other wavelengths also support the hypothesis of a SNR. In conclusion, Dubner et al. \ (1992) propose that the gas distribution was originally perturbed by a SN explosion and the hollowed shape is now maintained by the stellar winds of the hot massive stars tex2html_wrap_inline1468 Puppis and tex2html_wrap_inline1470 Velorum.

4.2.2. Stellar winds

In order to find out the origin of the giant HI disk shown in this paper, we first investigate the hypothesis of a wind-driven bubble blown by the massive stars present in the region. For this purpose, we have applied the model of Weaver et al. (1977) using typical parameters for O and WR stars, since it is well known that these type of stars have very powerful stellar winds capable of creating large cavities surrounded by HI shells (Cappa de Nicolau \ & Niemela 1984; Cappa de Nicolau et al. \ 1988; Dubner et al. 1990; Niemela & Cappa de Nicolau \ 1991).

To estimate the original ambient density, it was assumed that the present swept-up mass was uniformely distributed into a spherical volume of 150 pc in radius. Thus, an initial density of tex2html_wrap_inline1472 tex2html_wrap_inline1474 was derived. Combining this parameter with the typical mass loss rate and terminal velocity of O stars, it follows that a bubble could have reached that extent after tex2html_wrap_inline1476 years. This value is almost twice the typical lifetime of tex2html_wrap_inline1478 yrs of an O star. If we assume that the star blowing the bubble was a WR star, the same estimate yields an age of tex2html_wrap_inline1480 years old for the bubble, again much older than the lifetime of a WR star, typically tex2html_wrap_inline1482 yrs (Maeder 1991). In this latter case, the numbers can be reconciled if we assume that both the WR star and its O-type precursor are responsible for the creation of the big bubble.

The energy provided by O and WR stars during their entire lives is of the order of tex2html_wrap_inline1484 ergs, as can be computed using typical values for their mass loss rates, terminal wind velocities and mean lifetimes (Abbott 1982; Garmany et al. 1981). By applying the energy conserving model for wind driven bubbles (McCray 1983), it can be assumed that up to 20% of the total energy could have been deposited into the surrounding medium as kinetic energy. In both cases, the estimated kinetic energy originating in the star is higher than the kinetic energy associated with the giant HI disk.

As for the candidate massive early-type stars, together with the two well known massive stars tex2html_wrap_inline1486 Pup and tex2html_wrap_inline1488 Vel, which lie near the center of the Gum nebula and at the same distance, there is another O-type star: CD-474551, at a distance of 460 pc, placed at tex2html_wrap_inline1492 (Cruz-González et al. 1974). Based on the above calculation, we conclude that the combined action of these stars can plausibly explain the origin of the giant HI disk. As an alternative explanation, we will also analyze the disk as being created by repeated supernova explosions from an OB association.

4.2.3. A "supershell''?

Multiple explosions can act in concert to compress the ambient interstellar gas into giant expanding shells called "supershells''. Supershells have typical radii of tex2html_wrap_inline1496 and ages of the order of tex2html_wrap_inline1498 years. McCray (1988) estimates that if a typical OB cluster has initially tex2html_wrap_inline1500 stars with tex2html_wrap_inline1502 (i.e., massive stars capable of exploding), then, after explosions have started, a supershell will begin to be created with a radius evolving as
displaymath1494
where tex2html_wrap_inline1504 is the energy of a SN explosion in units of tex2html_wrap_inline1506 ergs, tex2html_wrap_inline1508 is the initial ambient density and tex2html_wrap_inline1510 is the age of the supershell in units of tex2html_wrap_inline1512 years. Application of McCray's model to the giant HI disk produces an age of tex2html_wrap_inline1514 yrs. This model would be compatible with an expansion velocity of about 14 .

According to this model, our giant HI disk is far from becoming gravitationally unstable, since it should be at least tex2html_wrap_inline1516 years old. On the contrary, it is possible that hydrodynamical Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities have occurred. Tenorio-Tagle et al. \ (1990a) have found that in the presence of a hot halo, the upper part of the remnants will "blowout'' because of Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities, and the blowout will result in the formation of chimneys from which ejecta will stream into the halo. As a consequence, the shell as a whole would decelerate due to the loss of internal pressure. The age at which the blowout is produced, about tex2html_wrap_inline1518 years (Tenorio-Tagle et al. 1990b), is consistent with the age we have estimated for the supershell. A blowout would also explain the fact that the observed expansion velocity is lower than the 14 predicted by McCray's (1988) model.

In the maps shown in Fig. 2 (click here), a feature quite similar to a chimney at tex2html_wrap_inline1520 can be seen between +10 and +20 . If this feature is actually related to the giant HI disk, there is an inconsistency with the kinematic velocity, since it appears at velocities higher than the systemic velocity. However, this apparent incompatibility can be explained with the following argument: the gas streaming upwards through an aperture in the shell to the halo will have a velocity V substantially higher than the expansion velocity of the supershell. If the apperture is located at a latitude b from the galactic plane, the observer will only detect the radial component tex2html_wrap_inline1526 of the escape velocity V, given by tex2html_wrap_inline1530. Since the feature is most clearly seen between v=+12 and +18 , an LSR velocity tex2html_wrap_inline1534 can be adopted, from which tex2html_wrap_inline1536 , assuming that the systemic velocity is exactly known. The location of the apperture is tex2html_wrap_inline1538. Thus, the escape velocity can be estimated to be tex2html_wrap_inline1540 , consistent with the predictions of Tenorio-Tagle et al. \ (1990a).

The two upper wings in the tex2html_wrap_inline1542 image of the Gum nebula converge to the feature possibly associated with a chimney. This coincidence supports the hypothesis that the giant HI disk can be explained as a supershell, and reinforces the contention of the existence of a physical association of the giant HI disk with the Gum nebula. The tex2html_wrap_inline1544 emission probably arises from the ionization of the hydrogen contained in the shell, where the ionization flux would have been provided by tex2html_wrap_inline1546 Pup, tex2html_wrap_inline1548 Vel and the O star CD-474551. Concerning the origin of the explosions which created the supershell, they can be atributed to the stars belonging to the relatively aged OB association Vela OB2, located at tex2html_wrap_inline1552 pc, which is on the verge of disintegration (Sahu 1992).

A signature of the multiple SN explosions occurred in the past within the Gum nebula can be given by the presence of five pulsars with distances between 0.44 and 0.66 kpc (Manchester & Taylor 1981), although two of them are older than the supershell, according to the age obtained using the model of McCray (1988).

In summary, we propose that the Gum nebula may be a supershell created by the multiple explosions undergone by stars belonging to the Vela OB2 association. The thick HI shell fits in this context as the remnant of a late explosion which also contributed to the creation of the Gum nebula. The Vela SN explosion cannot have entered into the formation of the Gum nebula because of its young age, but on the contrary, its evolution may have been influenced by inhomogenities created in the interstellar medium by the past explosions, like the thick HI shell.

4.3. The southern shell

It has already been mentioned in Sect. 3 that the southern part of the giant HI disk has been distorted by the presence of a tex2html_wrap_inline1554 diameter shell, centered at tex2html_wrap_inline1556. The expansive effects of this shell can be seen between -10 and +14 , and the maximum size is reached at tex2html_wrap_inline1562 . In Fig. 5 (click here), a map of this structure integrated between v=-10 and +14 is shown. At tex2html_wrap_inline1566, the galactic rotation model of Fich et al. \ (1989) predicts a distance of 240 pc for a systemic velocity of +4 . However, it should be borne in mind that a 1 difference in the systemic velocity produces a change of nearly 150 pc in distance at this longitude. Thus, since the usage of galactic rotation models may not yield a precise result, we will try to get an independent estimate for the distance, based on the search of an agent capable of having evacuated the cavity. The only powerful nearby star located in the inner region of the HI hole is the O5/7-type star HD 49798, lying at a distance of 570 pc (Cruz-González et al. \ 1974). This star is indicated in Fig. 5 (click here) as a star. We will suppose that the shell has been created by the star HD 49798 and therefore lies also at a distance of 570 pc. Under this assumption, the radius of the shell can be estimated to be tex2html_wrap_inline1568 pc. The reliability of our hypothesis will be tested below using the model of Weaver et al. (1977).

  figure348
Figure 5: Integrated map between -10 and +14 of the shell lying to the south of the Gum nebula. Contours are at 90, 120, 150, 180, 210, 240 270, 300, 400 and 500 K. The greyscale is shown in the edge on top of the image. The star indicates the position of the O-type star HD 49798

The shell is open towards the lower density region, opposite to the galactic disk, while the expansion has obviously been slowed down in the direction of the denser region. The eccentric position of the star agrees with such an anisotropic expansion, though optical measurements should reveal if the eccentricity is rather due to a proper motion of the star. The southern part of the shell extends beyond the area surveyed in this paper, thus the mass estimates will be based on the available data and considered as a lower limit.

The amount of matter present in the shell is tex2html_wrap_inline1572. Assuming that tex2html_wrap_inline1574 kpc, then tex2html_wrap_inline1576. Adopting an expansion velocity of tex2html_wrap_inline1578 , the expansion kinetic energy is above tex2html_wrap_inline1580 ergs. According to the calculations carried out in the previous section, an O star could have provided this energy to the interstellar medium through stellar winds. If it is assumed that the mass contained in the shell was initially uniformely distributed throughout a sphere of 142 pc radius, the initial ambient density should have been higher than 0.16 tex2html_wrap_inline1582 . Application of the model of Weaver et al. (1977) implies that the O star HD 49798 should have spent more than tex2html_wrap_inline1584 yrs blowing the bubble. This time is compatible with a typical O-star lifetime.

There has not been found any correlation between this HI structure and the tex2html_wrap_inline1586 emission. In particular, no optical filaments appear towards the most dense regions, as would be expected if there were important energy dissipation due to the interaction between the HI shell and the Gum nebula.

Based on the above results, it can be concluded that the southern HI shell was probably created by the stellar winds of the O-type star HD 49798, and that its age is close to the age of the Gum nebula. The interaction between these two structures can be noticed through the distortion of the isolines at the region of overlap.


next previous
Up: Cold neutral gas

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)
web@ed-phys.fr