next previous
Up: Membership and structural

8. Star counts and profile fitting

8.1. Counts of complete measurements on different Schmidt plates

In order to increase the accuracy of the tidal radius of M 5 known from Peterson & King (1975), Bahcall & Hausman (1976), Kron et al. (1984) and Trager et al. (1995) we used the full APM scans of 8 Schmidt plates (cf. Table 1 (click here)) for star counts (Lehmann 1996). The automated counts are characterised by a higher statistical significance in the outer region of globular clusters in comparison with the human detection. Due to crowding effects the central cluster region could not be resolved in a range of tex2html_wrap_inline2325 (in dependence on the plate scale, seeing and limiting magnitude). There were also significant crowding effects in the range of tex2html_wrap_inline2327 arcmin (tex2html_wrap_inline2329 - the mean radius of the annulus). Therefore we applied a luminosity dependent crowding correction based on the luminosity function in the outer cluster region and the statistical probability of overlapping star images (for more details see Lehmann 1996).

Note that the crowding correction was not applied in the APM on-line reduction (improved image detection in crowded fields of Irwin 1985) as done in Grillmair et al. (1995). Instead here we used standard APM measurements, originally carried out for astrometry. The crowding correction converted the high number of images with non-stellar classification appearing in the inner annuli around the cluster centre on the basis of their pixel area into additional numbers of stellar images. For this purpose the luminosity function of stellar images in the outer cluster region (not affected by crowding) obtained after the subtraction of the background was assumed to be valid in the inner cluster region, too. The subtracted background surface density was determined from a large region adjacent to the cluster in an annulus between 25 and 50 arcmin from the cluster centre.

The projected surface density profiles of M 5 from the different plates were matched to a single profile and correlated with photoelectric and electronographic surface brightness measurements from Kron & Mayall (1960), King (1966) and Kron et al. (1984). Because of the spread of the surface brightness data in the innermost part of the cluster we used the above mentioned data in different combinations for the fit of the whole profile by the empirical density law of King (1962). The best fit was obtained by combining our star counts with the data of King (1966). By fitting with the Levenberg-Marquardt-method (Press et al. 1992) we got the tidal radius of M 5 tex2html_wrap_inline2331 arcmin, the core radius tex2html_wrap_inline2333 arcmin and the concentration parameter tex2html_wrap_inline2335. Whereas the core radius agrees well with the data from Trager et al. (1995) the tidal radius from our profil is 1.7 arcmin lower than their value (see Table 5 (click here)).

  table623
Table 5: Structural parameters tex2html_wrap_inline2337, tex2html_wrap_inline2339 and c of M 5 as obtained by different authors and methods

Figure 6 (click here) shows for tex2html_wrap_inline2371 an increased surface density which may be an indication for a tidal tail - a halo of unbounded stars around the globular cluster as recently discussed by Grillmair et al. (1995). These authors investigated 12 Galactic globular clusters, mainly at southern declinations, measured on UK Schmidt plates by means of the APM and found extra-tidal wings in the density profiles for the majority of clusters in their sample. The seven globular clusters studied by Lehmann (1996) on the basis of Tautenburg, Palomar and UK Schmidt plates also scanned with the APM are located at northern declinations. There is only one cluster (M 15) included in both studies. It is interesting that Lehmann (1996) also found indications of tidal tails for 5 clusters.

Grillmair et al. (1995) investigated the nearby cluster background in more detail in order to decide whether the increased density at tex2html_wrap_inline2373 is physically existent or an artifact of an incorrect background subtraction. Here we check the reliability of the tidal tail of M 5 obtained in the counts of all objects measured on 8 different Schmidt plates using the member counts for the King profile fitting. Tucholke (1992) proposed this method for globular clusters with rich or variable background (and/or foreground) of field stars.

8.2. Member counts with different membership probabilities

The member counts which we present below do not go as deep as the counts of the full scans of the plates combined into one profile. This is due to the restriction of the sample of objects used in the proper motion study and in the two-colour photometry, i.e. only the objects measured on the reference plate (5821) tex2html_wrap_inline2375 on a second plate (8348) were investigated. No further restrictions concerning the magnitude range of the stars used in the member counts were made.

  figure662
Figure 7: Density profile of M 5 from counts of cluster members with membership probabilities tex2html_wrap_inline2377 (membership determination using coordinates and proper motions). Logarithm of surface density in stars per arcmintex2html_wrap_inline2379 versus logarithm of the mean annulus radius tex2html_wrap_inline2381 [arcmin]. The line shows the best fit with the empirical density law from King (1962). The dotted lines show the radial fitting range

For the member counts we first used the stars with membership probabilities tex2html_wrap_inline2383 and tex2html_wrap_inline2385 obtained in the four-dimensional analysis including the coordinates. These membership probabilities are the most reliable ones, although the assumption of a normal distribution of the coordinates of the cluster stars (see Sect. 4) pre-determines the shape of the density profile. For tex2html_wrap_inline2387 the fit with the empirical density law of King (1962) was more accurate. The results are shown in Fig. 7 (click here) and in Table 6 (click here).

  figure680
Figure 8: Density profile of M 5 from counts of cluster members with membership probabilities tex2html_wrap_inline2389 (membership determination using proper motions only). Logarithm of surface density in stars per arcmintex2html_wrap_inline2391 versus logarithm of the mean annulus radius tex2html_wrap_inline2393 [arcmin]. The line shows the best fit with the empirical density law from King (1962). The dotted line shows the subtracted background of field stars with tex2html_wrap_inline2395 outside of 35 arcmin, the dotted-dashed lines show the radial fitting range

  table693
Table 6: M 5 tidal radius from member counts

For the member counts based on membership probabilities obtained only from the proper motions we present the result for the tidal radius for both using all stars with tex2html_wrap_inline2423 and with tex2html_wrap_inline2425 in Table 6 (click here). As one can see the radial fitting range is larger than in the case of the member counts using the four-dimensional membership analysis. Whereas in the member counts with tex2html_wrap_inline2427 there was no background to be subtracted, here we had to consider the number of field stars with proper motions similar to those of the cluster stars.

The values of tex2html_wrap_inline2429 obtained in the member counts are well in agreement with those of Peterson & King (1975), Trager et al. (1995) and of the complete scans of all Schmidt plates used in this project combined to one profile (Lehmann 1996). But there is no indication of a tidal tail for M 5 as found from the complete scans of the plates (Lehmann 1996). This discrepancy may be due to the different magnitude limits of the full counts and of the member counts.


next previous
Up: Membership and structural

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)
web@ed-phys.fr