next previous
Up: Ammonia observations towards

4. Discussion

4.1. Location of the exciting sources of the outflows

Through the (J,K) = (1,1) and (2,2) inversion transitions of the tex2html_wrap_inline4459\ molecule we have studied the dense gas in a sample of 15 regions with signs of star formation, as indicated by the presence of outflow activity. We have been able to detect and map the tex2html_wrap_inline4461 emission in 14 of these regions. This high rate of detections is a clear indication of the strong association between tex2html_wrap_inline4463 emission and outflow activity. This result confirms the young nature of the observed objects, since they appear to be still associated with (and most of them embedded in) the dense gas from where they have been formed.

In all cases where we have mapped the tex2html_wrap_inline4465 emission associated with molecular outflows, the ammonia maximum is located near (tex2html_wrap_inline4467) the position of a candidate for driving the outflow. This result gives support to their identification as the outflow exciting sources, following the criterion proposed by Anglada et al. (1989) for such identification. For the sources of our sample that are only associated with optical signs of outflow, the tex2html_wrap_inline4469 emission is weak and does not coincide with any known object in the observed field, suggesting that probably none of the nearby objects that have been detected up to now is related to the outflow excitation.

4.2. Physical parameters of the dense cores

The sizes of the condensations we have mapped in tex2html_wrap_inline4471 range from tex2html_wrap_inline4473 to tex2html_wrap_inline4475 (a somewhat larger value of 2 pc is obtained for the condensation associated with IRAS 20188+3928, but this value may be overestimated by an order of magnitude, since we have adopted the upper limit for the distance). We find evidence for some elongation in the condensations we mapped (as was noted, in general, by Myers et al. 1991). However, our angular resolution, in general, is not good enough to allow us to further discuss on the morphology of the sources. In particular, we are not able to establish whether or not these condensations play a relevant role in the collimation of the outflows in these regions (as suggested, e.g., by Torrelles et al. 1983). We note, however, the very high degree of elongation of the condensation associated with IRAS 22376+7455 in L1251, reminiscent of the tex2html_wrap_inline4481 structure observed in L1448 (e.g., Anglada et al. 1989). In both cases (L1251 and L1448), several objects are seen in projection towards the elongated tex2html_wrap_inline4483 structure. A high angular resolution study of the L1251 region may be relevant in order to investigate a possible fragmentation of the structure. A higher angular resolution study may also be relevant for other sources of our sample that appear unresolved in our present single-dish study.

The intrinsic line widths obtained (tex2html_wrap_inline4485 tex2html_wrap_inline4487; see Table 2 (click here)) are significantly larger than the expected thermal line widths, since the kinetic temperature estimates for these regions give very low values (see Table 3 (click here)). Only for the region associated with IRAS 20188+3928 the line widths reach tex2html_wrap_inline4491 tex2html_wrap_inline4493 (in some positions). This is also the region where we have obtained the highest value for the kinetic temperature, as estimated from our ammonia observations (we note that in many sources we only could obtain upper limits or we were forced to use estimates from CO data, which are less accurate). Despite the uncertainty in the distance, the luminosity of IRAS 20188+3928 appears to be higher than for most of the objects studied in our sample. Thus, this object appears to produce a larger perturbation in its molecular high density environment than the others objects we have observed.

In part due to our lack of angular resolution, we are not able to measure in detail the velocity gradient in our regions. However, it is remarkable that in the condensation associated with IRAS 22376+7455 in L1251, our results show the presence of a strong velocity gradient with sudden velocity shifts of up to tex2html_wrap_inline4499 tex2html_wrap_inline4501 between contiguous positions. A study with high angular resolution of this region appears to be very promising.

The tex2html_wrap_inline4503 column densities we have obtained are tex2html_wrap_inline4505 (assuming [tex2html_wrap_inline4507/tex2html_wrap_inline4509] tex2html_wrap_inline4511), implying mean visual extinctions tex2html_wrap_inline4513. For L483 we have obtained the highest tex2html_wrap_inline4515 column density (tex2html_wrap_inline4517, corresponding to a visual extinction of tex2html_wrap_inline4519), suggesting that this object is very deeply embedded.

The masses obtained for the observed regions lie typically in the range from 1 to 100 tex2html_wrap_inline4521. The values derived coincide, in general, with the virial masses within a factor of 3. This general trend, observed for the regions of our sample, suggests that the condensations are near virial equilibrium and that the assumed tex2html_wrap_inline4523 abundance is adequate. L483 is the region for which the calculated mass exceeds the virial mass by the largest factor. This could imply that for this source the cloud is still in the process of gravitational collapse. We note here that recently Myers et al. (1995) have detected asymmetric line profiles in this region consistent with infall motion, according to the modeling of Anglada et al. (1987). Although the uncertainties involved are still large, it seems clear that this object is among the youngest sources in our sample, in agreement with the results of Fuller et al. (1995), which classify this as a very young object.

4.3. Evolutive differences in the outflow sources

We have detected and mapped the tex2html_wrap_inline4525 emission in 12 out of 13 regions with molecular outflow in our sample. Only in one region, L1048 (for which, in fact, no published map of the CO outflow is available), we failed in detecting ammonia emission (Table 1 (click here)). The tex2html_wrap_inline4527 emission is faint (tex2html_wrap_inline4529; see Table 2 (click here)) only in 3 regions (RNO 43, HH 83 and L100) of the 12 regions associated with molecular outflow we have mapped. On the other hand, in the two regions without molecular outflow (HH 84 and HH 86/87/88), the ammonia emission is very faint. These results tentatively suggest that the ammonia emission tends to be more intense for those sources associated with molecular outflow than for the sources associated with only ``optical'' signs of outflow (such as jets and Herbig-Haro objects).

In order to substantiate this possible relationship between the type of outflow and the intensity of the tex2html_wrap_inline4531 emission, we have complemented the sample of regions observed in this paper with the results of other Haystack tex2html_wrap_inline4533 observations reported in the literature. We have studied the distribution of the intensity of the tex2html_wrap_inline4535 emission, as measured by the main beam brightness temperature towards the outflow exciting source, in this larger sample of regions. We note here that the tex2html_wrap_inline4537 brightness temperature is a good measure of the intensity of the tex2html_wrap_inline4539 emission only for sources that fill the beam of the telescope. For unresolved sources, a more adequate comparison should be made in terms of the distance corrected flux density of the ammonia emission (``ammonia luminosity''). As we expect that for nearby sources the angular size of the ammonia emission will be, in general, larger than the telescope beam, we have used the main beam brightness temperature to make the comparison, restricting our sample to nearby enough regions. Thus, we have used sources with tex2html_wrap_inline4541, and completed our sample with the data from Torrelles et al. (1983) (9 sources), Anglada et al. (1989) (13 sources), Benson & Myers (1989) (5 sources, and 2 additional sources observed at Green Bank), Verdes-Montenegro et al. (1989) (3 sources), and Persi et al.\ (1994) (1 source).

Our final sample is shown in Table 4 (click here). It contains a total of 47 sources, with 21 sources associated only with molecular outflow, 19 sources associated both with optical and molecular outflow and 7 sources with only optical outflow. In Fig. 21 (click here) we present the distribution of the tex2html_wrap_inline4543 main beam brightness temperature towards the position of the proposed outflow exciting source (Table 4 (click here)) for the three groups of sources. The mean values of the tex2html_wrap_inline4545 brightness temperature are 1.7 K (only molecular outflow), 1.5 K (optical and molecular outflow) and 0.5 K (only optical outflow). Despite the relatively small number of sources with only optical outflow, it is clear that these sources tend to present lower values for the tex2html_wrap_inline4547\ brightness temperature, while for the sources with molecular outflow the distribution is displaced to higher values of the tex2html_wrap_inline4549 brightness temperature. We conclude, thus, that the ammonia emission is in general more intense in molecular outflow sources than in sources with optical outflow.

  figure786
Figure 21: Distribution of the tex2html_wrap_inline4551 main beam brightness temperature for sources with only molecular outflow (top), for sources with both molecular and optical outflow (middle), and for sources with only optical outflow (bottom)

Table 4: Regions associated with molecular or optical outflow observed in tex2html_wrap_inline4553tex2html_wrap_inline4555

We should note that recent sensitive studies have detected weak CO outflows in regions where previous studies failed in the detection (e.g., in HH 1-2 or HH 34; Chernin & Masson 1995). We have not attempted to take into account the effect of the intensity of the molecular outflow in our study, and we have only considered whether or not an outflow detection has been reported in a given region.

The fact that the sources of molecular outflow present more intense ammonia emission can be interpreted as indicating that these sources are deeply embedded in the high density gas, and surrounded by a larger amount of molecular gas, while those sources with only optical outflow have already dispersed the molecular core or escaped from it. This interpretation can be corroborated by comparing the estimated column density in the sources listed in Table 4 (click here). We found that the ammonia column density towards the outflow exciting source decreases as the outflow activity becomes prominent in the optical. The mean values of the tex2html_wrap_inline4621 column density are tex2html_wrap_inline4623 (only molecular outflow), tex2html_wrap_inline4625 (optical and molecular outflow) and tex2html_wrap_inline4627 (only optical outflow). In Fig. 22 we show the distribution of the tex2html_wrap_inline4629 column density for the three groups of sources. A similar correlation is obtained if the comparison is made in terms of the estimated mass of the associated core, but in this last case it is unclear to what extent should the tex2html_wrap_inline4631 emission be considered as associated with a given object.

  figure847
Figure 22: Distribution of the tex2html_wrap_inline4633 column density for sources with only molecular outflow (top), for sources with both molecular and optical outflow (middle), and for sources with only optical outflow (bottom)

These results suggest an evolutive sequence of the sources, traced by the intensity of the ammonia emission and the observational appearance of the outflow. Molecular and optical outflow would be phenomena that dominate, observationally, at different stages of the early stellar evolution. In the younger objects molecular outflows will be prominent, while optical outflows will progressively show up as the star evolves. However, this result does not exclude that both phenomena could coexist simultaneously as is required in the so-called ``unified models'', in which molecular outflows are driven by highly collimated jets (e.g., Raga et al. 1993); only the observational appearance of the outflow evolves in time as the star loses progressively the surrounding high density gas. In this scenario, the driving optical jet is becoming visible as a consequence of the ambient molecular material being progressively removed by the effect of the molecular outflow itself. Alternatively, the observed differences could represent intrinsic differences in the amount of molecular high density gas from one to another region.


next previous
Up: Ammonia observations towards

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)
web@ed-phys.fr