The present survey revealed that about 28% of methanol maser sources are not
associated with the 1.6 GHz mainline masers. It is interesting to look for
any differences in infrared properties of OH sources and non-OH sources.
Figure 2 shows the distributions of the m flux density F60 in both
sets of objects. 52 objects were included in this figure as we neglected
objects with the upper limits for F60.
It is clear that the methanol masers without any OH emission are generally weaker
m objects than those with the OH emission.
The occurrence
of OH emission preferentially in objects with stronger infrared emission
appears to be consistent
with the correlation between OH and FIR flux densities
mentioned above. In turn, the methanol masers without any OH emission
are associated with weak FIR sources. This suggests that the infrared photons are less involved in pumping of CH3OH masers (Walsh et al. 1997) than in pumping of OH masers.
Figure 3 illustrates the ratio of OH to CH3OH maser peak flux densities
against the (60)-(25) colour, defined as log(
F60/F25).
The peak flux densities of the 6.7 GHz methanol masers were
taken from Szymczak et al. (2000). Figure 3 suggests that the
intensity of OH masers increases for objects with bluer (60)-(25) colour.
The above observational evidence suggests that the OH
mainline masers are not sustained in sources with weak FIR emission and
OH masers can appear later than the 6.7 GHz methanol masers, when a massive star-forming region evolves from the red to blue infrared colours.
The large scale surveys of OH masers (Turner 1979; Caswell & Haynes 1983a, 1983b; Cohen et al. 1988) provided the most complete inventory of star formation regions. The present observations however, suggest that the number of sites of star formation derived from OH data can be underestimated by about 30%. Gaylard et al. (1994) based mainly on the observations of the southern hemisphere sources also concluded that there is a substantial population of the 6.7 GHz methanol masers without any OH maser emission. A sensitive survey of selected galactic areas in both methanol and hydroxyl maser lines would yield a more quantitative result.
Copyright The European Southern Observatory (ESO)