We have obtained polarimetric data for 10 symbiotic systems whose main
characteristics are included in Table 1.
The results of our observations are presented in the Table 2
where we give for each object, in the different epochs, the average polarization in
the UBVRI bands, in terms of the weighted mean values of
the Stokes parameters PX and PY, the corresponding degree of linear
polarization in percent ,
the position angle in degrees PA,
and the corresponding mean errors. The number of observations, N, is also
indicated.
Weighting according to the inverse square of the estimated error for
each observation is applied. The estimated error is taken either from
the least-square fit of the double cosine curves to the eight
integrations in the different positions of the
/2 plate,
or from the photon statistics, whichever is greater.
The multicolour polarization data were used to determine the wavelength dependence of the degree of polarization and the position angle. In order to investigate whether the observed polarization is purely interstellar, or a significant contribution due to intrinsic polarization exists, we compared the observed spectral distributions of the polarization with that given by the Serkowski's law for the wavelength dependence of the interstellar polarization (Serkowski et al. 1975).
All the symbiotic stars were observed in different epochs and several of them show changes in the wavelength dependence of the polarization on time scales of days or months. Plots of the measured polarization vs. wavelength are presented for each star at the different epochs.
![]() |
Figure 1:
V748 Cen: Wavelength dependence of linear polarization ![]() |
V748 Centauri
V748 Cen has been classified as a R CrB variable, with a photographic
amplitude of about 2 mag and a period of 566.5 days
(van Genderen et al. 1974).
Optical and infrared photometry confirm that V748 Cen is an eclipsing
binary and the orbital period is the same as the photographic one.
During the eclipse the system becomes much redder, indicating the presence
of an M4 giant as the occulting star. Outside the eclipse rapid brightness
variations
were
observed by van Genderen. The presence of a shell absorption spectrum and of emission
lines as well as several evident peculiarities in the light curve indicate a system
in which shells and/or gas streams are present. Such gas stream is expected to flow
from the M giant to the hot component through the inner Lagrangian point.
It means
that the hot component is seen through a dense region of the gas stream just before
eclipse.
H
and other lower Balmer lines are in emission with a strong central
absorption component, characteristic to disk-like emission features.
V748 Cen was observed in July 1995, March 1996, August 1997 and April 1998 and there
are no previous
polarimetric observations of this object. Figure 1 shows
the weighted mean values of the degree of polarization and the
position angle as a
function of wavelength and for the different observational runs.
The amount of polarization changes with wavelength and a sharp increase of the degree
of polarization to the short wavelengths was observed; this is typical for cool
luminous stars, where polarization is produced by light scattering on dust particles
in a circumstellar envelope.
In July 1995 the amount of polarization increases to maximum values in the U and Bbands.
In March 1996, the wavelength dependence of the polarization remained
the same as it was in 1995, but the amount of polarization increased
from 1.6 to 2.6 - 2.8% in the UB and from 0.3 to 1.3% in infrared. In August 1997
and April 1998, the polarization values in UB are intermediate between those
corresponding to the two first epochs while in I they are similar to July 1995.
In the Vand R filters there were no significant changes with time.
![]() |
Figure 2: V748 Cen: Percentage polarization (top) and position angle (bottom) as a function of orbital phases for the UBVRI filters |
The behavior of the polarization in V748 Cen can also be related with
the orbital motion of the eclipsing binary, using the van Genderen et al.
ephemeris,
Figure 2 shows the polarization as a function of the phase. The
percentage of polarization is greater in U and B,
increasing from 1.5% in phase 0.48
to 2.8% in phase 0.56, when the hot component is moving towards the second
quadrature suggesting that at least part of the polarization can be due to scattering
of the light of the hot source due to the M giant envelope and the stream of material
between the stars, such as it was proposed for CH Cyg by
Piirola (1988a).
If this is the case, around quadratures the line of sight is perpendicular to the
line joining the stars and the scattering angles are favourable for producing a
maximum of polarization, but unfortunately we have no observations at both
quadratures.
![]() |
Figure 3:
Hen 1103: Wavelength dependence of linear polarization ![]() |
Hen 1103
Hen 1103 was observed in July 1995, March 1996, August 1997 and April 1998 and our observations are the first polarimetric data of this object (Fig. 3). In July 1995 the degree of polarization reaches the minimum value in blue (0.6%) and then it shows a relatively smooth increase to the larger wavelengths with a peak in R of about 2.5%. The wavelength dependence is reversed in March 1996, i.e., the polarization reaches the largest value of 3.7% and decreases slightly to the infrared.
The position angle is the same in all wavelengths, around
and there
is no rotation in the BVRI range.
However in July 1995 a rotation of
between U and B is observed
larger than the experimental error. This fact, i.e. the rotation over a small
wavelength range, is a common phenomenon observed in other symbiotic stars
cf. R Aqr (Schulte-Ladbeck 1985) and EG And (SLAMS). It has been
suggested that the
observed rotation might be explained by scattering of the light of the two
components, a red one and a blue one, by the same circumstellar region
close to the two stars.
KX TrA = Hen 1242
The rich emission-line spectrum of KX TrA resembles the one of the slow nova RR Tel (Webster 1966), in particular the evolution of the spectral excitation levels observed between 1965 and 1972 (Webster 1973). A wide range of ionization states for forbidden lines was observed, for example, [Ne V] and [Fe VII]. A light curve of KX TrA for the years 1889-1975 was given by Liller (1974), with quasi-periodic variations in B between 10.1 and 13.6 magnitudes. This object seems to have a slow-rising outburst every 10-15 years and major outbursts during this interval were not recorded.
SLAMS did not see evidence of an
intrinsic polarization component in KX TrA from
their observations carried out in July 1985 and April 1986. Moreover
in two spectropolarimetric surveys
(Schmid & Schild 1994;
Harries &
Howarth 1996) it was found that the amount and orientation of
the continuum polarization outside the
Raman lines 6825 and
7082 is
small and practically constant in KX TrA.
![]() |
Figure 4:
KX TrA: Wavelength dependence of linear polarization ![]() |
Our observations of KX TrA obtained during five observing runs,
do not show any clear wavelength dependence of the polarization percentage neither of
the position angle. The values are quite similar, within the
error bars (Fig. 4), although it is worth noticing that the degree of
polarization in I during May 1994 and April 1998 is 1.4% while in July 1995,
March 1996 and August 1997 decreases to
0.9%.
![]() |
Figure 5:
CL Sco: Wavelength dependence of linear polarization ![]() |
CL Scorpii
Kenyon & Webbink (1984) suggested that the low excitation symbiotic star
CL Sco is a system similar to CI Cyg, containing a disk-accreting main sequence star.
They found that the well observed optical minima of
this system can be represented by the ephemeris:
For CL Sco we have not found any published polarimetric data.
According to our observations shown in Fig. 5, at the time of the first
observing run between July 6-11, 1995, CL Sco presented a decreasing trend in the
degree of
polarization with a peak of approximately 1.9% in the U band and the position angle
showed an overall
rotation between ultraviolet and infrared amounting to about
.
Twenty days later, on July 27, the polarization increased in the red
from 0.8% to 1.4% but changes in opposite sense were observed in the
orientation with a rotation of
.
In March 1996, the polarization degree increased in all spectral
regions, particularly in B passband where it doubled with respect to July 1995
whereas
the position angle remained constant at
in all
wavelengths.
In August 1997, the wavelength dependence is similar to the one of March 1996 but the
values are smaller, specially in U and B where the polarization has decreased between
0.5 - 0.7%.
Finally, in April 1998, the polarization shows a greater variation, increasing from
to
0.9% whereas the position angle also shows a strong
rotation between UB and V of about
.
In general we can see that the
ultraviolet and the blue light show the larger variations in the percentage of
polarization and stronger rotations in the orientation.
The behavior of polarization vs. the orbital motion is shown in Fig. 6 and
it seems to be very different from that of V748 Cen. The larger polarization is found
at phase 0.05, when the components are in conjunction with the giant in front while
near the first quadrature at phase 0.27, when the line of sight is perpendicular to
the binary axis, a minimum in the polarization together with a strong rotation are
observed. Between the phases 0.66 and 0.9 the ultraviolet polarization decreases but
important information during the second quadrature is lacking.
![]() |
Figure 6: CL Sco: Percentage polarization (top) and position angle (bottom) as a function of orbital phases for the UBVRI bands |
AR Pavonis
It is the first eclipsing binary discovered among the symbiotic stars
(Mayall 1937). The characteristics of this system remain still elusive and several
models have been proposed. According to
Thackeray & Hutchings (1974)
the system is constituted by a cool giant (M3-4 III-II) filling its Roche lobe and
losing mass towards an evolved hot component. The eclipses seem to be due to the
occultation of a dense part of a nebula surrounding the hot star rather than to a
stellar body.
Kenyon & Webbink (1984) modified this model suggesting that the hot
component is a main sequence star with an accretion disk.
The shape of the eclipses in the light curve was analyzed by
Bruch et al. (1994)
and AR Pav seems to be highly variable out of eclipse due to a
modulation of the mass transfer from the red giant to the hot component.
Skopal et al. (1997), re-analyzed the historical light curve (1888-1996) of
AR Pav. During the quiescent stages the observations can be accounted for by a large
accretion disk around the hot component but they proposed that at the outbursts an
opposite mass flow from the hot component towards the cool giant occurs giving rise
to a collisional emission region on the giant surface.
![]() |
Figure 7:
AR Pav: Wavelength dependence of linear polarization ![]() |
SLAMS observed polarimetrically AR Pav on two occasions
and considered this star as
a borderline case.
Our polarimetric observations were carried out during six epochs, July 1995, July
1996, July 1997, August 1997, April 1998 and June 1998. Important changes in the
wavelength dependence are observed both in the percentage of polarization and the
position angle, such as it is shown in Fig. 7. We can distinguish three
kinds of the wavelength dependence. The first occurs in July 1995 and July 1996; it
shows a polarization with a maximum in B and decreasing to red. On the contrary, the
second one shows a minimum in B (July 97-August 97) and finally, the third one (April
98-Jun. 98)
displays a high polarization in ultraviolet decreasing to V while the
VRI bands show the smallest values of polarization.
The position angle curves indicate slight rotations with the wavelength in each one
of the four observation sets but in July 97 and April 98 strong rotations
in U and B of
more than
are evident.
The strongest temporal variations in
the position angle correspond also to the Bband with a time scale as short as 54 days (July 97-August 97).
Adopting the ephemeris given by Bruch et al. (1994):
we analyse the polarization of AR Pav vs. phase in order to know if the complicate
polarimetric behavior of this system is correlated with the orbital motion. First of
all, the three quoted wavelength dependences concerning the percentage of
polarization correspond to three different positions of the component stars with
respect to the observer, namely the two conjunctions, before the first quadrature and
before the second quadrature, respectively.
We can see in Fig. 8 that the polarization reaches the highest values in UB(1.4 - 1.9%) in phase 0.92 (July 95) close to the eclipse, when the cool component is
in front of the observer. At
phase 0.53 (July 96), immediately after the second conjunction when the hot component
is in front, another increase of polarization
in UB is observed.
Simultaneously, the orientation of the position angle at both conjunctions shows a
rotation of
.
Moreover, at phase 0.60 (April 98) the polarization in
VRI presents the minimum observed values,
when the hot star is going away
from the observer.
At phases 0.19 and 0.88 (SLAMS's data) the position angles in U are offset by
and
from the VRI bands respectively.
Khudyakova (1988) found that variations of polarization in CI Cyg and
R Aqr reflect the orbital motion and the maxima lie near the conjunction when the
hot component is between the cool star and the observer.
FN Sagitarii
This typical S-type symbiotic star has undergone two outbursts
(
mag) in 1924-26 and 1936-41. Semiregular variations with
smaller continuous fluctuations are superimposed
(Kenyon 1986 and
references therein). High-excitation emission lines of He II,
[O III] and [Ne III] are present in FN Sgr; in addition, [Fe VI],
[Fe VII] and the Raman scattering band at
have been reported by
Barbá et al. (1992).
![]() |
Figure 9:
FN Sgr: Wavelength dependence of linear polarization ![]() |
Our data were obtained in May 1994, July 9,
1995, July 27, 1995 and April 1998 and
there are no previous polarimetric observations of FN Sgr. Conspicuous changes in the
amount of polarization for all the
wavelengths were observed, specially during the two sets of observations of
July 1995
(Fig. 9). The maximum values correspond to 2.9% - 2.5% in UB bands on
July 8 but after eighteen days the polarization suddenly decreases in all bands
reaching 0.6% - 0.3% whereas rotations in opposite sense between
UBV and RI bands
were detected. These changes in the position angles were
on
July 9
and
on July 27.
In May 94 and April 98 the polarization presents a maximun in B (
)
and
then decreases slightly to the infrared. The position angles are very similar during
those epochs and a small rotation is detected along the wavelengths.
Visual magnitudes and V photometry collected in the period 1977-1998
(Belczynski & Mikolajewska, private communication) shows that the FN Sgr light
curve presents systematic
brightness decline with moderate periodic-like light changes, and
one major amplitude started in 1995.
In July 1995 we obtained the most remarkable variations in the polarimetric
parameters in a short time scale of eighteen days. All our observations correspond to
the large amplitude in the active state of the light curve.
Hen 1761
Hen 1761 is an infrequently studied symbiotic star. During the period 1990-1992 eruptive characteristics were detected in its spectra and the quiescence phase started in 1993 (Brandi et al. 1998).
SLAMS measured the polarization of Hen 1761 in the bands BVI and H.
The
results indicated that probably there is polarization, intrinsic to the object.
![]() |
Figure 10:
Hen 1761: Wavelength dependence of linear polarization ![]() |
We carried out the observations in six different runs (see
Table 2).
The dependence of the polarization degree with the wavelength is not very conspicuous
and the variations are inside the error bars.
The most important variations take place on July 24, 1995 when the U-filter
polarization decreases from 1.3% to 0.2% and the position angle rotates less
than
(Fig. 10) in UB.
RR Telescopii
RR Tel underwent a nova-like outburst that started in 1944. It was classified as D-type symbiotic system; infrared observations show the presence of a Mira variable as cool component with long-period pulsations. As RR Tel has declined from light maximum, the optical spectrum has slowly developed high ionization lines. A rich emission line spectrum is superimposed on a weak continuum.
Many authors have observed RR Tel polarimetrically but contradictory
results have been obtained.
Schulte-Ladbeck & Magalhães (1987)
found that RR Tel did not show intrinsic
polarization. Spectropolarimetric observations of the emission lines at
6825 and
7082 as due to Raman-scattered O VI
1032 and 1038 resonance lines were carried out
by Schmid & Schild (1994);
Espey et al. (1995) and
Harries &
Howarth (1996).
The measurements of Schmid & Schild in the
range 6700 - 7500 Å together with the polarization map of surrounding
stars, allowed to infer that an intrinsic component of polarization was
present in RR Tel. Moreover, the mean continuum polarization and position
angle over the range 6400 - 7200 Å obtained by Espey et al., indicated
that the continuum polarization is predominantly due to interstellar dust
grains. The continuum polarization data given by Harries & Howarth showed a
significant difference with the red region photopolarimetric measures given by
Schulte-Ladbeck & Magalhães (1987) and
Schmid & Schild
(1994). This temporal variability was an evidence of intrinsic
polarization in RR Tel.
![]() |
Figure 11:
RR Tel: Wavelength dependence of linear polarization ![]() |
![]() |
Figure 12: RR Tel: The polarimetric variations of RR Tel with the Mira phase. From top to botton the figures show the UBVR band polarization variations, The I-band polarization variations, the UBVR band position angle and the I-band position angle. We have included the polarimetric observations of RR Tel given by Schulte-Ladbeck & Magalhães (1987) in the UBVI-bands at phase 0.46; by Schmid & Schild (1994) and Espey et al. (1995) in the R-band at phases 0.03 and 0.57 respectively and by Harries & Howarth (1996) in the I-band at phase 0.79 |
As it is seen in Fig. 11, our multifrequency observations in October 1994 and July 1995 show the percentage of polarization with a slow decrease with increasing wavelengths. However, in August 97 the polarization presents an approximately flat wavelength dependence around 0.3 - 0.4% and it rises with the wavelength in April 98 from 0.5% in U to 0.8% in I.
The position angle in UBVR shows none or small temporal variations; the rotations in
these filters are less than
.
However a conpiscuous behavior is seen
in the I band where a change in the orientation of about
between the
first two and last two observation sets is evident. There is also a small rotation of
between October 94 and July 95. Consequently, we can confirm the
existence of intrinsic polarization in RR Tel.
RR Tel is the only D-type symbiotic included in our sample with a Mira variable as
cool component. An interesting point is to make a more detailed study of the
temporal variation of polarization in this object, in order to
find a correlation with the Mira phase such as it was found for R Aqr
(Aspin &
Schwarz 1988 and references therein);
UV Aurigae (Khudyakova 1985, 1988) and
Ceti
(Shawl 1975).
As it is quite normal for Mira variables, the light curve of RR Tel is not strictly
repetitive over long timescales. Therefore, for the determination of phases, we used
an epoch of maximum light obtained from JHKL photometric data collected by
Feast et al. (1983) during 1975-81 and the period of 387 days.
Figure 12
shows the variation of the degree and angle of polarization as a function of the
phases. We have included the polarimetric observations of RR Tel given by
Schulte-Ladbeck & Magalhães (1987)
in the UBVI-bands at phase
0.46; by Schmid & Schild (1994) and
Espey et al. (1995) in the
R-band at phases 0.03 and 0.57 respectively and by
Harries & Howarth (1996) in the I-band at phase 0.79.
Inspection of the UBVR polarization variations are not consistent with the phase of
brightness variation of the Mira, but the I-band however,
presents the percentage of polarization with an increasing trend from the maximum
light (phase 0.0) reaching the maximum of polarization (0.8%) around phase 0.5.
![]() |
Figure 13:
CD
![]() ![]() |
CD -4314304
The published polarimetric observations of CD
14304 are
spectropolarimetric studies of the Raman scattered emission lines at
6825 and 7082 carried out by
Schmid & Schild (1994)
and
Harries & Howarth (1996).
The continuum polarization values in the red region presented by those authors are in
agreement within the errors; no temporal variations were detected. Moreover, by means
of the polarization map of surrounding field stars, they concluded that the continuum
polarization at
Å for CD
14304 is probably dominated by
the interstellar polarization.
Our observations confirm the temporal invariance observed in the polarization in the
V, R and
I bands (see Fig. 13) but it is not the same for the ultraviolet
and blue; there is a maximum of about 1% in July 95 and April 98 and the
polarization falls to 0.5% or less during the other sets of observations. The
wavelength dependence of the position angle seems to be variable along the time.
Moreover, there are small rotations in the position angle among the different
filters. A change between
occurs in all the wavelengths for different epochs and strong rotations of
in UB and
in BV are observed in April 98.
![]() |
Figure 14:
CD
![]() |
Schmid et al. (1998) have obtained the radial velocity curve for the cool
component in CD
14304 and an orbital period of 1448 days for circular
orbit of the binary was determined. Using their ephemeris corresponding to the moment
of maximum velocity,
the orbital phases of CD
14304 observations were calculated and
correlated with the polarization degree and position angle such as it is shown in
Fig. 14. The larger polarization in U (1.1%) is seen at phase 0.45 before
the quadrature when the giant is approaching to the observer and the line joining the
stars is perpendicular to the line of sight. Simultaneously, remarkable rotations in
U and B bands are observed. When the giant is in front of the observer (phase 0.75)
the polarization in UB increases again to
but smaller rotations
occur.
AG Pegasi
AG Peg is a well studied symbiotic binary which contains a normal M2 giant and a compact object. A nova-like outburst began in 1850 and a very slow decline has taken place since 1871. At the moment AG Peg may be close to the end of its outburst. The spectroscopic orbital period of the binary (800 days) was discovered by Merrill (1929a, 1929b) and spectroscopic orbits were also determined by Cowley & Stencel (1973); Hutchings et al. (1975); Slovak & Lambert (1988) and Garcia & Kenyon (1988). Belyakina (1970) showed that irregular 0.3 mag fluctuations in Vfollowed the spectroscopic period and that those variations of brightness could be caused by the reflection effect. According to this model, ultraviolet radiation from the hot component heats up the facing hemisphere of the giant, causing the cool star to radiate more energy when its heated hemisphere faces the observer. The photometric period was improved by Meinunger (1981); Belyakina (1985); Fernie (1985) and Luthardt (1990).
AG Peg was studied polarimetrically by other authors,
Serkowski (1970);
Piirola (1983);
Schulte-Ladbeck (1985) and SLAMS.
Variations in the intrinsic polarization
were detected as far as the wavelength dependence and the
time are concerned. In all the cases the polarization values were rather small,
peaking 1% in B
(Serkowski 1970) and large rotations of the
position angle with wavelength were also observed,
the most remarkable being
90
between 3699 Å and 6500 Å and 170
at
8000 Å
(Aspin &
Schwarz 1988).
![]() |
Figure 15:
AG Peg: Wavelength dependence of linear polarization ![]() |
Our observations of October 1994 show polarization
decreasing slightly with wavelength from a maximum of 0.4% in U to a minimum of
0.06% in R and I (Fig. 15).
Similar behavior is observed in September 95 but in July 1995, although the data
have relatively large uncertainties in this epoch; the wavelength
dependence changes, increasing the polarization to 0.6% in R and 0.4% in I. In
August 97 the polarization decreases until 0.06% in U but in the other filters the
values are similar to those of October and September. In the different epochs a
constant value of
in B band is observed.
The position angle shows remarkable rotations. In October 94 a dip in R indicates a
rotation of
between UBV and R and between R and I. In July 95 the
rotation of
between UB and VRI is associated with an abrupt
decreasing to 0.06% in the polarization. In September 95 is
between
U and B whereas in the last data set of August 97 a small rotation of approximately
20
from U to I is observed. Such a large rotation in the position angle
along the wavelengths has been already detected in AG Peg by other authors, as it was
indicated above.
In particular and according to
Daniel (1982), a change in the orientation
by
in the wavelength dependence
was found indicative of the polarization reversal in bipolar
nebula.
AG Peg has an optical nebula (Fuensalida et al. 1988) and
an extended and complex nebula detected at radio
(Hjellming 1986;
Kenny et al. 1991).
The structure surrounding AG Peg detected in H
shows two
lobes resolved at 5'' and 4'' from the central part in virtually opposite directions
approximately NW-SE.
![]() |
Figure 16: AG Peg: Percentage polarization (top) and position angle (bottom) as a function of orbital phases for the UBVRI filters |
The Fig. 16 shows our results of
polarization as a function of orbital
phase. We calculate the phases adopting
Fernie's (1985) ephemeris,
Unfortunately our observations are concentrated
in the second half of the orbital
cycle.
Taking into account the proposed model (Belyakina 1970), in October 94, phase 0.49 corresponds to the moment when the cool star is in front of the observer close to the conjunction with the other star. Here the ultraviolet polarization is more important and then decreases until phase 0.77 near the quadrature, where in all the wavelengths, the polarization reaches similar values (about 0.1%). An abrupt increase in the polarization, specially at U, R and I, is observed at phase 0.82 when the giant is going away from the observer. This fact is accompanied by bigger changes in the position angle. Finally, on September 95, at phase 0.92 the system is near the first conjunction, when the hot hemisphere of the giant is in front of the observer and the polarization decreases in UVRI bands. We can mention that although the blue polarization is nearly constant along the phases, it shows the strongest rotation of the position angle at phase 0.82.
It is very difficult to bring out conclusion about the behavior of polarization in AG Peg, as far as the wavelength dependence and the orbital motion are concerned. It seems that several polarigenic mechanisms are working producing different polarization in the ultraviolet, blue and longer wavelengths. Perhaps a superposition of mechanisms would give rise to such complicated results.
Copyright The European Southern Observatory (ESO)