Up: Relative figure of merit
Using the theory of model parameter determination, we developed a
general method which permits a quantitative comparison of
observational techniques and optimization of complex observations
through the relative figure of merit, defined as
a generalization of the ratio of random errors of model parameters.
The method was applied to compare the outcome of OLBI and classical
spectroscopic observations, both used to determine the parameters of
the outflow of the P Cyg star. The observable quantities were
computed using an efficient radiative transfer code and realistic
grids of the envelope model. The OLBI and spectroscopic measurements
errors were simulated assuming that the only source of errors is the
counting statistics, i.e. we considered a nearly-ideal interferometer.
Other main assumptions and simplifications of the present work were as
follows: (1) the P Cyg wind is stationary and spherically symmetric;
(2) the only OLBI observable considered here is the visibility modulus;
(3) only the hydrogen H
line is considered.
The main conclusions of the present work are as follows:
- 1.
- A meaningful evaluation of the OLBI vs. spectroscopy relative figure of
merit requires exploration of a large domain of the model parametric
space (about 105 points computed in the present work);
- 2.
- If the P Cyg outflow can be accurately described by a
simple model of a stationary spherically symmetric isothermal
envelope, then the use of interferometry does not substantially reduce the random error in the model
parameter determination;
- 3.
- If the P Cyg outflow requires more complex models, e.g. with a priori unknown
dependence of the envelope temperature on radial distance, use of a
nearly-ideal interferometer can reduce errors in model parameters by an
order of magnitude as compared to the spectrometer of the same
collecting power and noise level;
- 4.
- The study of the relative robustness, i.e. the stability of the
obtained model parameter determination with respect to systematic
biases in the model, indicates that when the OLBI and the physical
model reduce random errors, they also tend to reduce the systematic
error;
- 5.
- The optimal projected baseline lengths for observation of P Cyg with a nearly ideal
interferometer lie in the range 45-90 m;
- 6.
- If several model parameters are to be determined simultaneously,
the OLBI observations at a single projected baseline cannot provide a substantial error
reduction.
Up: Relative figure of merit
Copyright The European Southern Observatory (ESO)