Earlier work on these collision strengths was by Norrington & Grant (1987) using the Dirac R-matrix program. This is normally the most accurate approach when the scattering electron energy is comparable to the target level splitting. However, their calculation did not contain resonances arising from excited states above the 3d2 states, and such resonance structures affect the collison strength right down to the 3d2 states. A controversial feature of their results is that in the impact energy range from the highest 3d2 threshold to beyond 3 Rydbergs, the collision strength from the Dirac R-matrix model decreased monotonically with energy, in contrast to that from the distorted-wave (DW) model of Nussbaumer & Storey (1982) which increased. This difference was ascribed to channel coupling included the R-matrix method but not in DW; it is such differences we want to clarify.
Copyright The European Southern Observatory (ESO)