next previous
Up: Infrared giants vs.

1. Introduction

Circumstellar envelopes around evolved stars, in particular AGB stars and late-type supergiants, are a two-fluid system, composed of gas and dust. As gas and dust are expected to be coupled both dynamically and chemically, it is natural to look for correlations between their characteristics, and in particular their emission properties.

A consensus has grown (see e.g. Habing 1995, and references therein) concerning the essential role of dust driven out by radiation pressure in the generation of the largest mass-loss rates and the general complexity of mass-loss mechanisms. There is no simple universal estimator of mass-loss rate. Every estimator must be carefully tested with the help of both realistic physical models, and large statistical samples. However, it has been confirmed that among these estimators, the most useful for massive molecular and dusty envelopes are the intensity of millimeter CO lines and the far-infrared emission.

Because of its great stability, CO is thought to concentrate almost all the carbon in AGB oxygen-rich circumstellar envelopes, with the limitation that the radial extension is limited by photodissociation by interstellar UV radiation (see Mamon et al. 1988, and references therein). The intensity of millimeter lines was proposed by Knapp & Morris (1985) as a precise estimator of mass-loss rate. In parallel, the study of the dust component has been greatly improved by the use of IRAS colours (see e.g. van der Veen & Habing 1988; van der Veen 1991) and low resolution spectra (LRS, IRAS Science Team, 1986). In particular, a simple approximate relation using the tex2html_wrap_inline2775 flux can be used to infer the dust mass-loss rate of large samples of sources (Jura 1986).

With the availability of large databases of CO observations (Nyman et al. 1992; Loup et al. 1993), it has been possible to compare CO and far-infrared emissions for all types of circumstellar envelopes. Both resulting determinations of the mass-loss rates appeared roughly consistent, as shown by Nyman et al. (1992), with a narrow range of the ratio between the CO and tex2html_wrap_inline2775 intensities for most sources. However, it had been known for a long time that the correlation between CO and far-infrared emission does not hold for some "extreme'' objects. In particular, Heske et al. (1990) have shown that in the coldest OH/IR stars CO emission is generally weaker by at least one order of magnitude than that expected from the mass-loss rate deduced from the tex2html_wrap_inline2775 IRAS intensity. Heske et al. partly explained such deficient CO emission by the very low kinetic temperature in those very cold envelopes or/and by variations of their mass-loss rates (see also Kastner 1992; Groenewegen 1994; Justtanont et al. 1994; Delfosse et al. 1996).

Our study focuses on a class of slightly warmer O-rich IRAS sources. We attempted to avoid previous biases due to selection criteria, such as the avoidance of the Galactic plane. Furthermore, our CO observations were conducted with a better sensitivity. In the first paper of this series, (Josselin et al. 1996, hereafter Paper I), we presented a statistical study of the CO observations of these objects, with a discussion of the tex2html_wrap_inline2837 ratio. The peak temperature of the CO line was preferred to the integrated intensity as it is easier to derive an upper limit for tex2html_wrap_inline2839 than for tex2html_wrap_inline2841 for the numerous non-detections. Furthermore, it stresses the distinction between AGB stars and supergiants, through the effect of the expansion velocity tex2html_wrap_inline2843. We showed that a low CO emission with respect to the far-infrared emission occurs in fact in an significant fraction of O-rich envelopes. The objects in our sample have intermediate values of mass-loss rates and IRAS colours. They are located in regions IIIa1 and IIIa2 of the IRAS colour-colour diagram of Fig. 1 (click here) (i.e. 0.69 < S25/S12 < 1.20, where S12and S25 are the 12 and tex2html_wrap_inline2851 IRAS fluxes, respectively). This is a region where the tex2html_wrap_inline2853 silicate feature is usually in emission and where many OH/IR stars are located (but not the coldest ones), as well as dusty supergiants. Their mass-loss rates are expected to be a few tex2html_wrap_inline2855.

In this second paper, we detail the analysis of the set of CO data now available. In Sect. 2, we describe the observations of CO and OH. In Sect. 3, we show correlations of the tex2html_wrap_inline2777 ratio with stellar characteristics, such as galactic coordinates, variability, and spectral type. In Sect. 4, we discuss the possible causes of a high tex2html_wrap_inline2783 value in an AGB star. In Sect. 5, we compare CO and OH observations. Finally, we discuss some peculiar sources. Two forthcoming papers will deal with visible spectroscopy (hereafter Paper III) and infrared photometry (Paper IV), basis of the determination of luminosity, opacities and mass-loss rates.


next previous
Up: Infrared giants vs.

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)