next previous
Up: Accurate positions and

2. Existing surveys, confirmed and rejected candidates

2.1. First surveys

Early work on Htex2html_wrap_inline1669 emission-line stars and nebulae was published by Henize in 1956. This survey, based on objective-prism photographs taken with a 10-inch camera, yielded 415 objects in the LMC, and among them 97 point-like emission sources, with no visible continuum, which could thus be considered as candidates PNe. Finding charts were provided. Lindsay & Mullan (1963) and Lindsay (1963), using the same instrument, selected, out of a sample of about 1000 emission objects, 109 point-like Htex2html_wrap_inline1671 emission sources with no continuum. 65 of these were classified as candidate PN because emission lines other than Htex2html_wrap_inline1673 were also seen, while the remaining 44 objects showed only Htex2html_wrap_inline1675. This later group however potentially also contained PNe, because it consisted of fainter objects where other emission lines needed more sensitive material to be revealed. Unfortunately, no finding charts were ever published for this sample, so that recovery of all the PNe is necessary.
In 1964, Westerlund and Smith used a blue objective-prism with a 20/26 inch Schmidt telescope to survey 100 square degrees of the LMC and produced a catalogue of 42 LMC PNe with approximate coordinates and manually drawn finding charts. Only point sources were retained.

2.2. Sanduleak et al. (1978), (1984)

Sanduleak et al. (1978) obtained objective prism plates with the Curtis Schmidt telescope at Cerro Tololo over a large fraction of the LMC. They presented a list (SMP) of 102 PNe, with cross-references to previous work. Objects were selected with no evidence of a continuum, and simultaneously with unresolved structure on direct plates (with the possible exception of SMP007). Unfortunately the coordinates are only approximate and no finding charts are provided, which makes the identification difficult. For further studies, these PNe have therefore to be ``re-discovered''. This was the most complete list of confirmed PNe at that time and therefore their designation is preferred to older ones. Some objects, believed to be of to low excitation to represent classical PNe (and denominated Very Low Excitation (VLE) objects) were presented in an independent list (Sanduleak & Philipp 1977). A few of the objects initially rejected by SMP, have been detected again in later surveys.

Sanduleak (1984) added 26 PNe (denoted Sa in our table, from Sa104 to Sa126) candidates to this list thanks to deeper plates obtained in the central region of the LMC. Nine of those had already been found by Jacoby (1980), but have been labeled with the Sanduleak denomination in our table.
Five objects were later rejected. The candidate Sa103 is a galaxy, with z=0.035, see Dennefeld (1986). Four objects (108-119-125-127) could not be found again: we took ON and OFF line CCD images in Htex2html_wrap_inline1679 and couldn't detect any emission object inside the 4 fields (from tex2html_wrap_inline1681 for Sa108 and Sa119, to tex2html_wrap_inline1683 for Sa125, and up to tex2html_wrap_inline1685 for Sa127).
We note that almost all the objects observed with the smaller field (0.90 m Dutch telescope + CCD camera, with a field of tex2html_wrap_inline1687) fall on the edges of the field. As an example, Sa104 was hard to recovered because the position was erroneous by about tex2html_wrap_inline1689. However for Sa125 and Sa127 the field is large enough to conclude that no PNe are present in these 2 regions. This has been independently confirmed by Morgan & Good (1992) who suggest in addition that Sa108 and Sa119 are carbon stars.
Sa104a was first discovered by Savage et al. (1982) and is a true PNe (with particularly low abundances, Leisy & Dennefeld 1995).

Later on, while this work was in progress, Meatheringham et al. (1991a,b) published, with their spectroscopic observations, better positions for 60 out of the 102 SMP PNe, while 10 others were measured by Vassiliadis et al. (1992). However the R.A. of these 70 PNe are rounded-up to the nearest second of time!

2.3. Jacoby (1980)

Jacoby (1980) used the Cerro Tololo 4 m telescope at the prime focus with a direct imaging technique (on-line/off-line narrow filters photography at [OIII] and Htex2html_wrap_inline1709) in 4 central regions of LMC (small area of the Bar). This is a much deeper survey which produced 41 faint PNe, 5-6 mag fainter than the brightest ones. Later on, Boroson & Liebert (1989) rejected 14 objects: 9 were early type stars, 3 M giant stars, 2 objects were not found at all. Furthermore, 8 PNe candidates were already known and confirmed by previous surveys. The coordinates are good to tex2html_wrap_inline1711 but the finding charts are difficult to use at the telescope because they are taken in narrow-band emission line filters: the object is then difficult to recognize in a typical telescope acquisition camera or a broad band CCD image.
In 1990, Jacoby et al. published the [OIII] photometry and interference filter images of the fields of the 102 PNe from the first Sanduleak list (1978). These images suffer from the same shortcomings at the telescope as only the brightest stars are visible.

2.4. Morgan and Good (1992), (1994)

Recently Morgan & Good (1992) and Morgan (1994) published respectively 86 and 54, new PNe candidates from plates taken with the 1.2 m UKST and objective prism, covering the entire LMC system. The errors on coordinates are ``typically tex2html_wrap_inline1715 arcsec''. Finding charts are provided, but the first series is hardly usable, specially in crowded areas, because of the small dynamics. These objects have also been included here for completeness and homogeneity.

The various lists discussed above provide the basic set of candidate PNe used here. No attempt has been made to be exhaustive. It should be further noted that these are only candidates, and only follow-up slit spectroscopy can confirm the nature of the object. When this was available (from our or published work), it is noted in Table 4. To date, 139 only out of the 277 candidates have been observed with slit spectroscopy.


next previous
Up: Accurate positions and

Copyright by the European Southern Observatory (ESO)
web@ed-phys.fr